THIRD ANNUAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAN SABBATH UNION.
By W. E. Cornell
The third anniversary of the American Sabbath Union was held in Des Moines, Iowa, Dec. 16, 17. Its organization was effected Dec. 12, 1888, and it is incorporated under the laws of the State of New York. Delegates were present from New York, Wisconsin, New Jersey, California, Nebraska, Maryland, Illinois, Iowa, and Pennsylvania. Among those in attendance whose names are familiar to the readers of the REVIEW may be mentioned Col. Elliot F. Shepard, Dr. Herrick Johnson, Rev. L. Mc Lean, Rev. Jas. P. Mills, J. H. Knowles, D. D., Rev. Dr. Thompson, and President Blanchard. Dr. Crafts, Messrs. Gault, Hunt, and others who have figured so prominently in former Sabbath conventions, were absent. The convention from beginning to end was conducted in a dignified, gentlemanly manner, and there appeared to be perfect harmony in all the deliberations, quite in contrast to the district association held here one year ago. In personal appearance it would be difficult to get together a more prepossessing body of men, and their earnestness and enthusiasm hardly knew any bounds. There was a marked absence of personalities, the addresses and papers being confined closely to the discussion of the subject under consideration. The attendance was much better than at any previous like gathering held here, not only from the city, but from the State as well, and there was evidence of a deepening interest in the subject of Sunday-closing. The friends of the opposition were not idle, but distributed from house to house about three thousand Sentinels, in each one of which was placed the tract, “Sunday and the World’s Fair,” yet this elicited no comment whatever on the part of the assembly, and in fact no reference whatever was made to the work of our Association. So far was this carried, that Col. Shepard stated to the writer that he had never heard of the American Sentinel. It was very apparent that the big thing, the objective point of their effort is the closing of the gates of the World’s Fair on Sunday, and to this end they seem to have concentrated all their energies. Indeed, three fourths of all the addresses bore directly or indirectly on this subject. The matter was presented almost wholly from the “civil” stand-point, yet the “moral influence” of Sunday closing came in for its share of consideration. The leading spirits of the convention were Dr. Johnson and Col. Shepard, the latter of whom is a son-in-law of the millionaire Vanderbilt, and was so advertised in the city papers. He is a man not far from fifty years of age, above the average size, gray hair which he parts in the middle, closely cut beard that covers his face, and his carriage is of a military order. His dress is rich and faultless in taste. He is a very deliberate speaker, and does not have what would be called a prepossessing appearance. Dr. Johnson is a tall, clerical looking gentleman, with white hair and burnsides, sharp, penetrating eyes, his whole bearing giving the impression that when he stated a thing as a fact, that should end all controversy. He is singularly incisive in speech, is very direct and clear in his emphasis, and has a wonderful discrimination in the use of words. He gave the opening address on “Sunday Opening of the Columbian Exposition” in the evening, not far from five hundred people being present, presenting nine arguments in favor of its closing, as follows:— “1. It is contrary to all World’s Fair precedents. “2. It would be against the best memories and traditions of our national life. “3. It is against the consciences of 10,000,000 church members. “4. It would be a national humiliation for us to put our American Sabbath in the backyard, and bring to the front that mongrel bastard thing, the European Sunday. “5. It would be a fearful menace to social orders. “6. It would be taking the down grade for labor, when Europe is starting on the up grade. “7. It would be enforcing of labor upon a whole army of Sabbath workers. “8. It would prove another strong link in the chain that will turn over the working-man, bound hand and foot to those who would work him 365 days a year. “9. It would be selling the Lord’s day for a few pieces of silver, not less the Lord himself.” And so favorable an impression did he make, that when at the close of his address an expression was called for from those who favored the closing of the Exposition on Sunday, the audience rose en masse, and when those opposed were asked to stand, but one solitary person responded, a reporter on one of the morning papers, who had written against Dr. Johnson’s position. Then Dr. Johnson produced a copy of the reporter’s paper, adjusted his “specs,” and read from the editorial the following:— “Let every piece of machinery on the grounds be stopped on Sunday, and its silence will be a most eloquent witness to the fact that this particular day is one of holy rest. Mute machinery will speak louder to the devotion of the American people than even closed gates, . . . and will be a more eloquent plea for Sunday than ever fell from the lips of man.” Assuming a dramatic position, the doctor said:— “Well, look at this. You go up to the gates. You see the crowds. You hear the jingling of the coins as they fall into the till. You are shocked as you walk in. But stop, place your ear to the ground, and listen to the ‘eloquence of the mute machinery’ and your conscience is allayed. Mute machinery,—just think of it,—what a power there is in mute machinery. O, yes, more eloquent than any plea that ever fell from human lips. Who believes it? Do you, my friends?—Of course you don’t.” This is but a sample of his way of disposing of opposition argument. His address was followed by one from Dr. Thompson of California, bearing on the same subject, but treating it in a little different manner. He opens thus:— “This movement is not to compel any man to have a Bible, to go to church, or even to give a nickel for the support of the gospel. It simply says that so far as its obligations are concerned, you must rest, and on that ground we plead for it.” Of the closing of the World’s Fair on Sunday, he said:— “The Columbian Exposition must be closed on Sunday in order to make good the guarantee of religious liberty. Every man in this land is guaranteed the privilege and right and opportunity of religious worship, and in no way shall we interfere with it.” No really new arguments were advanced, that is, none that are new to readers of the REVIEW. Those of the other speakers were Dr. Johnson’s in substance, only put in different words and enforced by different illustrations. “Observations Abroad as Related to Conditions at Home” was the subject of an interesting paper by Hon. F. J. Lamb of Madison, Wis., in which was told his observations of fifteen continental Sundays during his stay in the Old World. A paragraph may be of interest as showing how a statesman views the matter of compulsory Sunday observance, as follows:— “Year after year the breakers of the Sabbath are becoming more numerous and bolder. The solution of the problem depends on the Evangelical congregations and ministers, who can remedy the matter by practicing what they preach in every particular. If the Columbian Exposition is open Sundays, the Evangelical church members will be responsible in a large measure for it. The reform we desire must begin at home, in the church.” “Reform must begin at the home of God. If Christians will do their part in saving the Christian Sabbath, they must make up their minds to do it at the cost of taking up the cross of self-denial, give up these practices, and endure, if need be, public odium as being cranky and fanatical, and submit to be reviled as puritanical and have all manner of evil spoken against them falsely for this cause if it must be, but by their lives and example be on the Lord’s side. Will they do it? It seems to me idle to talk of reforming the nation in observing God’s Sabbath when the hands of Christians to whom its keeping is committed, are not clean and their skirts not clear of all complicity with every form and method of Sabbath observance. Will the Christian Sabbath be saved to this nation?—I don’t know. I think I do know it cannot be saved by appealing to the penal laws of the land, however well planned. Nor will it be saved by great conventions with their accompanying speeches—nor by adopting resolutions however strong, logical, and persuasive they may be.” Hon. A. G. Scott of Nebraska, one of the World’s Fair commissioners, gave an address on the “World’s Fair and its Relation to Sunday Opening.” Among other things he stated:— “The vast importance of the question of the Sunday opening of the Columbian Exposition and its power to confirm or destroy the moral influence of rest one day in seven does not halt at the close of the World’s Fair. May we emphasize that this question is vital in the life, history, and preservation of Sunday as a day of rest? It must be confessed that mankind has measurably weakened in late years in the observance of Sunday. But to open the World’s Fair on Sunday is to demoralize and abolish the American day of rest. To observe and reverence the sacred rights of Sunday is so firmly imbedded in our national and State laws as to be recognized as a duty incumbent on our people. Shall the American people now build upon the ruins of Sunday observance the marts of trade and commerce, convert our churches into theaters, and adopt the continental Sabbath? An eminent divine has said: ‘Happy is the land where Sunday is kept in its purity. A week without Sunday is like a country without the fragrance of flowers; it is like a year without summer; it is like night without morning, nothing but sorrow, darkness, and death.’ Shall the light of Sunday that has given character to America be darkened by opening the gates of the World’s Fair on Sunday? We cannot afford to make the sacrifice. The American Sunday is the noblest of our institutions, the noblest structure in civilization, an emblem of humanity to man.” Rev. J. P. Helwig, president of the Ohio Sabbath Association, spoke on the “Geographical Argument,” the main thought being that in those countries and nations where the Sabbath was best observed, there was the progress, the intelligence, and the greatest freedom from crime, and he therefore concluded that if this land was to maintain its place among the nations of earth as the greatest of them all, it must at all hazards preserve intact the American Sabbath, that institution that had done more than anything else to make us a distinctive people, and if this day was allowed to grow into what the continental Sabbath was, he believed that God’s frown would rest upon the people. Hon. L. S. Coffin, ex-Iowa railroad commissioner, spoke on the “Sabbath and Railroad Men,” taking the ground that they were the most abused of any class of men so far as compulsory work was concerned, and the time had come when there should be a change. He urged that the subject be agitated till there be a change in public sentiment, a change that would cause a spontaneous uprising of the people, and demand of the railroads that their employees be granted a day of rest. He thought the Sunday closing of the World’s Fair would be a long stride in the direction of creating the proper sentiment, and was therefore heartily in favor of the gates being shut on Sunday. Strong resolutions were adopted, re-affirming the conviction of the truthfulness and strength of the principles of the American Sabbath Union, urging the people to labor for their promulgation, asking the co-operation of all labor associations, lauding the President for his order that the inspection of the army hereafter be held on secular days, urging that the presidential inauguration be held on the first Wednesday of March instead of the fourth, which day has in the past, and will in the future, sometimes fall on Sunday, demanding that the Exposition close its gates on Sunday, and numerous other like resolutions, one of which reads as follows:—11 “In the interests of the whole American people and the national reputation, order, and prosperity, as well as in those of all persons occupied with carrying on the various departments and kinds of labor connected with public affairs, we ask our national Government to grant and order the weekly rest day for all such employees of every rank and description, whether serving at the national Capitol, in the States or in the Territories of the nation.” As was stated at the onset of this report, the outward appearance was very fair, and the earnestness of the speakers captivated the people. However, in the light of prophecy, it is not difficult to read between the lines something of the real spirit possessed, the “hidden hand,” the cloven foot, as the following interview with Col. Shepard and one or two others will show:— “Question.—What do you hope to secure by this agitation? “Answer.—We hope by this agitation so to mold public sentiment that there will be a popular uprising of the people in favor of a more strict observance of Sunday.” “Ques.—But suppose the people didn’t come up to the desired standard, what then?” “Ans.—If they do not yield to the plain, conclusive arguments in its favor, then we must resort to law.” And here another one spoke up:— “Yes, and I believe we might as well start in that way at first, as I doubt if moral suasion will ever reach them.” “Ques.—Have you made preparation for an effort in this direction?” “Ans.—Yes, sir, we have in contemplation a committee whose chief business is to look after Sabbath legislation at the national Capitol, and at all the State legislatures.” “Ques.—Do you still intend to prosecute the introduction of a bill in Congress similar to the Blair bill?” “Ans.—Indeed, we do, and we intend to keep agitating it till our desires are met.” “Ques.—But do you not think the movement you are interested in, carried to its legitimate results, will end in religious persecution?” “Ans.—No, sir. A man who says that we are in favor of a movement that will persecute any one, is 100 years behind the times.” “Ques.—But already there has been some persecution, or at least something that bordered on it, in the case of Mr. King of Tennessee, who was an observer of Saturday, but who was imprisoned for working on Sunday.” “Ans.—Yes, I remember something of such a case, and the judge ruled against him on the ground that he had no right to set himself up against the sentiment of any community, and by prosecuting his course outrage the feelings of a religious people. When a man enters society, there are certain privileges and rights that have to be surrendered, and this is one of them.” Dr. Knowles, who took it upon himself to tell the convention in a sanctimonious speech how those engaged in this work were praying people, and who never had a meeting of the Board or Executive Committee without opening and closing it with prayer, even in the busy mart of trade that Park Row, New York, was, and also how the committee on its way to Chicago last August to present the case before the World’s Fair commissioner actually prayed on the train, said in his report:— “We believe that awakened conscience of the nation in regard to the fourth commandment is the supreme need of the hour. Sunday laws must be formulated for the civil good; and while this need is great, there is a deeper and nobler reason calling for a closer inculcation in the national life of our citizens of the laws of God.” Other utterances of a like character were made, but these will suffice. Personally, it was a privilege to attend the convention, and as I looked back only a few years when the movement was but feebleness, which now in so incredibly short time has grown to such dimensions that its power is felt around the world, my very being was thrilled at the thought that we are right on the verge of that mighty conflict between truth and error which will usher in that glad morn which has been the hope and song of the people of God in all ages. And it was the testimony of those of our brethren who were present that their confidence in the truthfulness of our position was re-established, and that they had received a new inspiration to labor on faithfully and earnestly till the end.