Defenders of the Sabbath are usually sound and logical reasoners; but whenever they run off into some side issue of error, their arguments immediately degenerate into a corresponding weakness.
The Sabbath Outlook (Seventh-day Baptist monthly) unfortunately has adopted the view that Christ was crucified on Wednesday and arose on the Sabbath, an error which stands on two stilts, both of which are pure assumptions; namely, first, that the expression, “three days and three nights,” means absolutely seventy-two hours, and nothing less; and, secondly, that the terms, “heart of the earth,” mean the grave.
Rev. Smith B. Goodenow of Battle Creek, Iowa, sends a fatal shot into that theory (as reported in the December, 1892, Outlook), based on the testimony of the two disciples, as they journeyed to Emmaus on the day of the resurrection, recorded in Luke 24:21. Speaking of the condemnation and crucifixion of Christ, these disciples say, “To-day” [the first day of the week, verses 1, 13] “is the third day since these things were done.” On this Mr. Goodenow says:—
“‘To-day (Sunday) is the third day,’ the very day when Jesus promised to rise (as just stated in verse 7). Thirteen times over in the New Testament it is promised, and asserted, that Christ should rise, and did rise, ‘on the third day.’ And that Sunday, ‘the first day of the week,’ was ‘the third day,’ is here declared by two witnesses on the spot, who ought to know what day it was. (See verses 1, 13.)”
To attempt to parry the force of this, the Outlook says: “As is usually the case, when men rush into a question hastily, our correspondent has failed to get in all the facts, or to quote all the texts and contexts.” Then the Outlook refers to verse 14, where it is said the two disciples talked together of “all these things which had happened,” and then jumps over to verse 21, and makes the “things” the disciples spoke of to Christ, the same as the “all things” referred to in verse 14.
But is there any warrant for this?—Not a particle. Verse 14 speaks of what the disciples were saying to each other; but verse 21 refers only to what they said to Christ in answer to his question, “What things?” in verse 19; and these are enumerated in verse 20, and include simply the condemnation and crucifixion of Christ, and nothing else. But the Outlook says:—
“‘All these things which have happened,’ include the trial, condemnation, and burial of Christ, and the special efforts which had been made to prevent anything like a resurrection or removal of the body. Now, if the theory of Mr. Goodenow be correct, ‘all these things’ did not ‘happen’ until ‘Saturday,’ when the guard was set, and the next day would have been only the first day since they were done, instead of the third.”
The assumptions of this statement are truly surprising. The disciples did not say, “To-day is the third day since all these things were done,” as the Outlook would have us read it, by its unwarrantable joining of verse 14 to verse 21. When Christ said, “What things?” in verse 19, that cut off all that had gone before, and the things spoken of afterward can include only such things as are mentioned in the answer to that question; and these, as already stated, are enumerated in verse 20, and include simply the condemnation and crucifixion of Christ. They say nothing about the “trial” of Christ, and especially they say nothing about setting the guard over the sepulcher, which took place the next day. Again we ask what warrant the Outlook has to thus go beyond the Scripture, and bring in things which it does not mention at all?—None, whatever. But having taken a false position, it is obliged to resort to such means to sustain it. “Be careful, brother Goodenow,” exclaims the Outlook, “and get all the Scripture in before you come to a conclusion;” to which he might very justly retort, “Be careful, brother Outlook, not to bring in altogether more than the Scripture gives you, to sustain your conclusions.”
If, as the Outlook claims, Mr. Goodenow is in the ditch on the one side of the road, by not bringing in enough of the circumstances, the Outlook is certainly just as far in the ditch on the other side by putting in more than the Scriptures give it any right to use; and in an argument it is certainly as bad to put in too much as it is to put in too little.
Luke 24:21 is a nail in a sure place. By no possible jugglery, in view of its testimony, can even the betrayal of Christ be put further back in the week than Thursday. Thus, if the first day of the week was the “third day” since these things were done, Saturday would be the “second since,” Friday the “first since,” and Thursday the day itself, on which they were begun, even including, as already noted, the betrayal and trial preceding the crucifixion. Those, therefore, who put the crucifixion itself back as far as Wednesday, and the resurrection of Christ on the Sabbath, have simply missed the mark, and are one side of the truth; and no such theory can endure; for truth cannot be permanently displaced by error. (See the tract published at this Office on “The Time of the Crucifixion and Resurrection of Christ.”)