GENERAL BOOTH VINDICATED, BUT HIS PLAN A FAILURE.
The committee which was appointed to investigate the Salvation Army and its disposal of funds for carrying out General Booth’s scheme for the redemption of the “submerged tenth,” has made its reports, and “vindicated” General Booth. That is, the charges of dishonesty and recklessness are not sustained. But it appears that the Social Wing of the Army, whose object is the reclamation of the degraded and lost by supplying them with remunerative work, is almost bankrupt, being in debt to the amount of nearly seventy thousand pounds, while the Spiritual Wing is very prosperous. This indicates that there is a far greater effective demand for the kind of food which the Salvation Army managers offer to the body than for that intended for the soul. The Social Wing can be carried on upon its present scale only at a loss of at least £30,000 a year. Is it worth while to continue the work? Is the deficit likely to decrease? The committee cautiously suggests, with reference to this point: “It is evident that if, when assisting the submerged, a course is taken which causes a number of persons previously independent to be submerged, an evil comes into existence which must greatly detract from the good done, and might, if a balance could be struck, be found to exceed the benefit conferred.” It should be added, to throw light on this suggestion, that the people are beginning to appreciate the fundamental fallacy upon which General Booth’s “Social Wing” rests. It is well known that in certain cases, as in the cutting of firewood, General Booth has succeeded simply in helping Peter by injuring Paul. He has provided a number of unemployed with work and wages, by taking the work and wages away from another lot of men. He has not increased the demand for labor or products in any way; he has only effected a re-distribution of the opportunities. Under his plan, the submerged must always be with us.—The Weekly Review.