Can Spiritualist Mediums Prove Spirit Identity?
☞ Dr. Horton, of the Union Congregational church, of Providence, in a recent discourse on Spiritualism, said: “I have looked into the matter carefully, and I defy any Spiritualist to identify the personality of those manifesting themselves. There is the sticking point. They cannot do it.” In this the Doctor is right; and this is one of the most vulnerable points in that system of fraud: Of course Spiritualists feel that such a damaging allegation must in some way be wiped out, and so the Banner of Light, of May 6, comes to the rescue. And this is its defense: It publishes each week in what it calls its “Message Department,” communications purporting to be from departed spirits, and points triumphantly to that as proof that spirits can be identified. What is the proof?—Why, it is found in some cases that a person of the name given by the communicating spirit, did die at the place, and time, and by the means claimed in the message. But does this identify the spirit?—Not in the least iota. Suppose scores of correct statements were made? Would that prove anything toward identity?—Not in the remotest particular. For the Devil can easily acquaint himself with even the most secret circumstances of the life and death of an individual, and behind the dark veil of Spiritualism, personate that individual, stating private facts, and simulating actions, expressions, tone of voice, and even looks, of the deceased; but is anything proved as to identity?—Nothing at all. The fact remains that the spirits cannot be identified; and thus the Devil has the field all to himself for his deception.