AdventAI

IN THE QUESTION CHAIR.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 9., February 28, 1893

[Designed for the consideration of such questions as will be of interest and profit to the general reader. All correspondents should give their names and correct post-office address, that queries not replied to here, may be answered by mail.]

297.—EVIL SPIRITS FROM THE LORD. 1 SAM. 16:14.

In this passage, and in Judges 9:23, the record speaks about an evil spirit from the Lord troubling people; but how can this be shown to agree with James 1:13, which says that “God cannot be tempted with evil, neither tempteth he any man”?

T. T.

Answer.—The texts referred to in the Old Testament are in accordance with a law laid down in the New Testament, which is a natural and consistent law. In 2 Thess. 2:11, 12, we read: “And for this cause God shall send them strong delusion, that they should believe a lie, that they all might be damned who believed not the truth, but had pleasure in unrighteousness.” There are two contending forces acting upon men, truth and error, light and darkness, good angels and evil angels. Man is a free moral agent, and can choose between them, yielding to one or the other, as he may decide. But when he resists the one, he of course gives place to the other. That cannot be otherwise. If he rejects truth, he just as surely, and by a natural law, takes in error; if he rejects light, the inevitable result is, darkness; if he refuses the influence of the good angels, he just as inevitably makes himself a prey to the evil angels. But God always gives people first an opportunity to receive the truth, the light, and his Spirit; and not until these are rejected can the other influences control them. Those to whom he is said to send strong delusion in 2 Thess. 2:11, 12, are such as would not believe the truth, but had pleasure in unrighteousness. He first sent them the truth, and tried to draw to righteousness; but they would not receive the one, nor practice the other; and what else, then, could result, but strong delusion that they should believe a lie? So it is said to Saul, that “the Spirit of the Lord departed from” him. He had grieved that away. He had done despite to the spirit of grace. He had made himself a prey to evil spirits, and they came upon him; said to be “from the Lord,” because the Lord has established this law in the spiritual world, and permits these results to follow those who will not receive him. So in the case of Abimelech, and the men of Shechem; and so also in the case of Ahab (1 Kings 22:20-23) and Pharaoh. Ex. 9:16. God is said to do things that he permits, and he permits them because he has set the two ways before men, and they, as free moral agents, have the power of choosing; and, as a result of their choice, the consequences follow which are attached to the two courses of action respectively. But the testimony of James refers evidently to a time before a person has placed himself on the side of the enemy, as in the other cases referred to, and his words are wholly true, that God does not tempt any man to evil or the commission of sin under such circumstances.

298.—DOES GOD REPENT? GEN. 6:6.

Will you be so kind as to explain Gen. 6:6? Some are puzzled to know how God could repent if he is the all-wise God. Others ask, Did he make a mistake? J. W. K.

Ans.—The word “repent,” like many other words, is used in different senses. The Lord is said to “repent,” yet it is also said that he is “not a man that he should repent.” 1 Sam. 15:29. Just as we also read that God tempteth no man, yet that he did tempt Abraham. James 1:12; Gen. 22:1. The skeptic thinks he finds a contradiction in such passages; but there is none, as he would learn if he would stop to consider in what sense these words are used. Thus “tempt” means, “to try, or prove,” and in this sense God did tempt Abraham, tried him, tested, or proved, him. But tempt also means to solicit into sin; and in this sense, God tempts no man. So the word, “repent,” means both to change one’s course of action toward others on account of some change of relation on their part, and also to change one’s course from his own inclination, from instability or fickleness of character. In the first sense God does repent, in the latter, never. In all those cases in which he is said to repent, it will be found that the object in reference to which he repents has changed its relation toward him.

In Jer. 18:7-10 he gives the rule by which he is governed in these respects. He says that when a nation becomes so wicked that he is obliged to decide upon its overthrow and destruction, if it repents and turns from its wickedness, he will “repent” of the evil he had intended to do, and do it not. That is, if the nation changes its course from evil to good, he will change his purpose in the same respect, and not inflict upon it the evil he intended. Likewise, if a nation concerning which he speaks, to build it up and prosper it, turns to evil and apostasy, he will “repent” of the good wherewith he designed to benefit it. In such cases there is no change on the part of God. The change is all on the part of man. And this is a rule which is consistent with the character of God, and one, which, to be true to his own nature, he must follow with his creatures.

Apply this rule to the world in the days of Noah, and it will be seen what he means by saying that it repented him that he had made man. Man was created a free moral agent; he could go in any direction in which, in the use of that free, untrammeled will, he might choose to go. Every possible direction that he might take, was, of course, open to the mind of God; and in his omniscience he would have provision in his mind for every contingency. At the same time, he had a design which he wished man to carry out in accordance with his will. He designed that he should be holy and happy, and honor and glorify him. In that case, he would prosper him and build him up. If he did not take this course, according to the rule laid down in Jeremiah, he would have to change his purpose concerning him, and destroy him. And this is just what took place. With the exception of one family, man became utterly apostate. Hence it repented the Lord that he had made him. That is, it made it necessary for him to change his purpose concerning them, and destroy them from off the face of the earth, instead of continuing their existence here in prosperity and happiness.

Just so we read that it repented the Lord that he had set up Saul as king (1 Sam. 15:11); that is, Saul did not meet the design of God in his position, and so he must vary his treatment of him from what it would otherwise have been, and instead of continuing him in the kingdom, take the kingdom from him and give it to another. But the change was on the part of Saul, not on the part of God. Because Saul changed his character and course of action, God, according to his unchangeable rule, must treat him differently from what he would, had not this change taken place in Saul. So in Ex. 32:14, God, on account of the intercession of Moses for Israel, repented of the evil he purposed to do unto them, on account of the change of circumstances in relation to them. Viewed in this light, we see that there is no ground for regarding God as a changeable being, as man is changeable, nor is there any contradiction in the Scriptures on this question.