AdventAI

THE LAW OF GOD IN THE GOSPEL AGE.

By W. H. Littlejohn

From Review and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 9., February 28, 1893

BY ELDER W. H. LITTLEJOHN.

(Battle Creek, Mich.)

(Continued.)

Besides the lack of Scriptural authority for the theory we are combating, besides the fact that the process by which it is claimed that the fourth commandment was eliminated from the decalogue was unnatural and illogical, certain other objections might be urged, any one of which would prove fatal to its soundness.

Perhaps enough has been said to make it clear that the theories relating to the change, or abolition, of the fourth commandment of the decalogue are untenable. The balance of this article will be devoted largely to a discussion of the doctrine that the decalogue as a whole was set aside by the Lord Jesus Christ, at the time of his crucifixion, and never re-instated. Practically speaking, those who entertain such an opinion are Antinomians. The signification of the latter title, as well as its proper application, is fittingly set forth in the subjoined extract:—

“Antinomians; these derive their name from two Greek words, signifying against law, their favorite tenet being, that the law is not a rule of life to believers under the gospel. The appellation is also generally given to those who carry the doctrine of justification by faith without works to such an extreme as to separate practical holiness from true believing, and injure, if not wholly destroy, every obligation to moral obedience.”—Cyc. of Relig. Knowl., p. 92.

Antinomians arose in the fifteenth century. Their doctrines were strenuously opposed by Luther and Melanchthon. There seems never to have been a sect by that name, and those holding Antinomian views have not all carried their opposition to the law of God to the same extreme. While some have denied that good works promote our salvation, or that evil works hinder it, others again have contented themselves with avowing their hostility to the decalogue as being in any sense a rule of life to the Christian. It is said that Antinomians in England as late as the seventeenth century expressly maintained that as the elect cannot fall from grace, nor forfeit the divine favor, so neither are the evil actions they commit really sinful, or to be considered as violations of the divine law; and that consequently, they have no occasion to confess their sins, or to seek renewed forgiveness. The Antinomian does things wrong in themselves, but they are not wrong when he does them, because he is a believer; so that were he to steal, the crime commonly called theft would in him lose all its criminality, and cease to be a breach of the eighth commandment. Sentiments so gross and demoralizing as those just stated need no refutation. They are but a reaction from the Romish doctrine of justification by works. It is the more moderate view that will secure attention at this time; i. e., the opinion that the decalogue is in no sense a rule of action to the Christian.

Strange as it may appear, it will be found that the advocates of this tenet agree practically with those who hold that nine of the commandments find a place in the Christian system. If the reader has any doubt upon this point, let him question any of those holding the view stated above in reference to the ten commandments, taking them up one by one. Let him ask them, for example, whether a Christian can have any other God but Jehovah, whether he can worship idols, whether he can blaspheme, whether he can dishonor his parents, whether he can kill, whether he can commit adultery, whether he can bear false witness, or covet, without incurring the divine displeasure. The reply to each of these questions will be that he cannot. As a consequence, he will acknowledge the obligation of every commandment of the decalogue save the fourth, or the one which relates to the Sabbath. But practically speaking, that is the identical position of the individual who holds that nine of the commandments have been brought over into this dispensation. As remarked heretofore, all the shifting and turning on the part of such a one has been gone through with in order to dispose of the Sabbath precept in the decalogue.

The reader needs not to be reminded that the more ultra Antinomians are equally hostile to the Sabbath command. If all ten of the commandments have been abolished, and are no longer binding in spirit or in letter upon the Christian, why, of course the fourth commandment is gone with the rest. Thus it appears that all classes of Antinomians strike hands with those who insist that the fourth precept of the decalogue alone has been repealed. Can the reader explain this fact satisfactorily to his own mind? Why this hostility to the Sabbath institution? Did God write with his own finger and utter with his own voice a command which was not made in the interest of those to whom it was given?* Has it not been the unvarying verdict of the church that a weekly day of rest and worship is indispensable, both from the physical and spiritual standpoint, to the child of God? Is it replied that the church celebrates a Sabbath, and that one day in the week is all that she requires?

The answer is, Very good, provided she hallows the day that God commanded her to hallow. If on the contrary she is keeping a day which has no divine warrant, the case is very different. The Saviour said that it was in vain to worship God “teaching for doctrines the commandments of men.” Matt. 15:9. If the Sabbath institution is a beneficent institution, then it would be a singular transaction indeed, should the Almighty remove from his law the command which makes it obligatory. Having once enacted a law for rest and worship on a given day, and that law having worked well under all circumstances, it is to be presumed that it would be perpetuated through all time. True it is that God might change the day, could sound and sufficient reasons be found for such a change. But has he done so? The answer is in the negative. There is not a scintilla of proof to be found in the word of God to the effect that either God or Christ or an inspired man has ever taught that the first day of the week has supplanted the seventh day as the Sabbath, or that the latter has in any way lost its sacred character. Throughout the New Testament the seventh day is always styled the “Sabbath,” and the first day is always referred to by the use of the secular title, “first day of the week.” In at least three instances it is said to be the day which followed the Sabbath, a thing which could not be true if it were in fact the Sabbath itself.† To say that redemption is greater than creation, and therefore ought to be commemorated by the hallowing of the day upon which it is claimed that it was completed, is but idle talk, so long as God has never said that such was the case; it is not the province of uninspired men to create ordinances for the Christian church, and command them under sin. This is the very thing which the Roman Church has attempted to do, and thereby incurred the divine wrath. It is by no means certain that the resurrection of Christ, which it is falsely claimed finished the work of redemption, could be fittingly celebrated by a day of rest.

Indeed, God himself has decided that such is not the case; for he has appointed a very different institution for that purpose; i. e., baptism by immersion. That ordinance symbolizes in a most impressive manner the burial and resurrection of Christ.‡ How could it be accomplished more suitably than by first lowering the candidate into, and then raising him up out of, the water? It would seem to be a reckless thing indeed for the churches to substitute, as most of them have done, sprinkling for immersion, thus destroying the signification of one of the most solemn ordinances that Christ ever appointed; but it is adding insult to insult when the same churches, after setting aside God’s chosen memorial of the resurrection of his Son, attempt to substitute an entirely different memento of that event.

Even if it were granted that the church might upon its own motion with propriety hallow the Sunday in honor of the resurrection of Christ, it would by no means follow that she could do away with God’s chosen memorial of creation. Redemption and creation are so different in their very nature that the same ordinance could hardly commemorate both. But admit for the sake of the argument that redemption is greater than creation, and that the former ought to be commemorated by the sanctifying of the day on which it is said that it was completed, then what? The logic of this position, if it has any, rests upon two assumptions; i. e., (1) that redemption should be honored by the celebration of a day of rest; (2) that such a day must be the very one on which it is argued that redemption was finished. Does not the reader perceive that the reasoning proceeds upon the hypothesis that if a transaction is to be commemorated by the setting apart of a day for that purpose, the dayp. 132 thus set apart must be the very one upon which the said transaction occurred? This being true, the Sunday could not commemorate the creation and redemption at the same time, since according to the view in question these events were completed upon different days of the week.

What, then, is the attitude in which our friends find themselves placed? Are they not by every principle of sound argument compelled to hallow two days in the week, instead of but one? The Saturday they must hallow because God has commanded them to do so in honor of his rest after the completion of the creation. The Sunday they must hallow because of the self-imposed duty of commemorating on that day the work of redemption. Are they ready to do this? If not, which will they drop, the Sabbath that God has instituted, or the one which has no higher authority than merely human conceptions of the fitness of things? When men undertake to supplement the wisdom of the Almighty, they by that very act demonstrate a lack of wisdom on their own part. “All scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness: that the man of God may be perfect, thoroughly furnished unto all good works.” 2 Tim. 3:16, 17. He who goes outside of the word of God in his search for doctrine and duty is but walking in the “sparks of his own kindling,” and in process of time is sure to find that he is doing a work of supererogation, if not directly violating the precepts of the word of God.

If those who find themselves in the theological muddle presented above wish to discover a direct and sure way out of it, they can do so by adopting the principle that it is not safe to conclude either that God has failed to instruct us in his word respecting all matters of duty, or that he will not insist upon exact obedience to all of his commands. The prophet Daniel has forewarned the church that a power would arise who should think to change the law of God. Dan. 7:25, 26. Protestants generally agree that this power was the papacy. Remarkable as it may appear, that same power claims that it has changed the Sabbath, and chides Protestants with keeping the Sunday upon no other authority than their tradition.§ Let those therefore who would not be guilty of putting the pope in the place of God, consider this matter carefully and prayerfully.

Those who are willing to do so, are invited to accompany the writer in a candid examination of the teachings of Scripture respecting the relation that believers sustain to the decalogue, or moral law, in this dispensation. If the reader shall find that the ten commandments are still obligatory, the question of the Sabbath will be settled without difficulty, since the fourth commandment will then furnish a Sabbath precept too plain to be misunderstood. On the other hand, if he shall decide that the ten commandments have been abolished altogether, he will be forced to the conclusion, regret it though he may, that there is no Sabbath in the Christian age.

(To be continued.)

Notes

  1. *And he said unto them, The Sabbath was made for man, and not man for the Sabbath.” Mark 2:27. ↩
  2. †“In the end of the Sabbath, as it began to dawn toward the first day of the week.” Matt. 28:1. “And when the Sabbath was past, Mary Magdalene, and Mary the mother of James, and Salome, had brought sweet spices, that they might come and anoint him. And very early in the morning, the first day of the week, they came unto the sepulcher at the rising of the sun.” Mark 16:1, 2. “And they returned, and prepared spices and ointments, and rested the Sabbath day according to the commandment.” “Now upon the first day of the week, very early in the morning, they came unto the sepulcher, bringing the spices which they had prepared, and certain others with them.” Luke 23:56; 24:1. ↩
  3. ‡“Therefore we are buried with him by baptism into death: ... For if we have been planted together in the likeness of his death, we shall be also in the likeness of his resurrection.” Rom. 6:4, 5. (Read the whole of the foregoing texts and along with them Col. 2:12.) ↩
  4. §“Question.—Is it then Saturday we should sanctify, in order to obey the ordinance of God? “Answer.—During the old law, Saturday was the day sanctified; but the church, instructed by Jesus Christ, and directed by the Spirit of God, has substituted Sunday for Saturday; so we now sanctify the first, not the seventh, day. Sunday means, and now is, the day of the Lord. “Q.—Had the church power to make such a change? “A.—Certainly; since the Spirit of God is her guide, the change is inspired by the Holy Spirit.”—[Cath.] Catechism of Christian Religion. ↩