AdventAI

THE FLIGHT OF LIBERTY.

By L. A. S.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 21., May 23, 1893

When we consider the various steps which this nation, through its legislative and judicial branches of government, has recently taken, and the attitude which it has assumed with respect to questions of individual right, we can but realize that the much vaunted expression, “American liberty,” is a phrase which is rapidly losing its meaning. In one country at least, it is now merely the language of mockery, and to millions of people brings only thoughts of oppression and intolerance. That country is China. The Geary Exclusion law, by which all Chinesep. 329 now in the United States, not possessed of a certificate of registration, are liable to imprisonment for one year, and banishment from the country, is the latest of a series of national steps taken by the legislative and executive branches of our government, in the direction of the entire subversion of individual rights and liberties. How strongly it tends in this direction will very probably be seen more clearly at a later time than it is now; for it is characteristic of such laws that they are eventually made to strike where least intended or contemplated by their authors. An exhibition of tyranny toward a few, rightly considered, is a menace to all.

Under the provisions of this law, which has been sustained by the United States Supreme Court, the Chinese who has the misfortune to be a resident in our domain enjoys just about as much liberty as did the southern negro before the war. He is liable to arrest at any time, and in such case must produce his certificate of registration, or establish his innocence upon the testimony of at least one white person. Failing to do this, he is deemed guilty, and may be banished from the country without trial, after first suffering a year’s imprisonment. It is the most drastic measure ever passed by the Congress of the United States.

This un-American and anti-Christian law is a flagrant violation of both the spirit and the letter of our national Constitution, unless that grand instrument be understood as applying to, and protecting, only the rights of United States citizens. But certainly it cannot be understood that our revered forefathers, hazarding their lives, their fortune, and their sacred honor to rear a nation founded upon humanity and justice, and the principle that “all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, among which are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness,” intended that the government so reared should pursue a cruel and intolerant course toward a citizen of their own or of any other country on earth. From this standpoint the Constitution is violated by this law in several particulars: (1) It supposes a man to be innocent until he is proved guilty; the Geary law supposes him to be guilty until he is proved innocent. (2) It guarantees the right of trial by jury; the Geary law denies this right. (3) It guarantees the right to give bail except for capital offenses; the Geary law takes away this right. (4) It declares that “cruel or unusual punishments shall not be inflicted;” the Geary law declares that offending Chinese shall be banished from the country,—a form of punishment which is unusual and in its consequences essentially cruel.

The Chinese, to be sure, are not the most desirable class of residents; but neither are they the most undesirable. They are far worthier to find a welcome here than many that come to our shores from the slums of Europe, and enter our domain without let or hindrance. But as the Occident, a San Francisco paper, sarcastically remarks, “The fact is, we don’t like Chinamen. They drink too little rum, and thus give no help toward sustaining the American grogshop. . . . Such vices as the Chinaman has, pay us no percentage. His heathenism corrupts the religion of—our saloon-keepers. His industry discourages our tramps. His crimes are wanting in the picturesque. . . . Worst of all, his patience, persistency, and strict attention to business are so masterful that we are afraid of him; it has become a moral certainty that while we can take care of a half million emigrants a year from Hungary, Russia, and Italy, many of them beggars, the 65,000,000 of us are utterly unable to cope with or tolerate the presence of the 100,000 in all who have come from China prepared not only to make their own living while here, but also to beguile us into giving a free trip home to as many of them as care to go.” We have nothing to say against restricting Chinese immigration; but that is a very different thing from placing unbearable hardships upon a people already here, in violation of the Constitution and of all principles of justice and humanity.

This law, significant to the Chinese because they are the individuals proscribed by it, is significant to us not only for its injustice to them, but because it is another violation of our national Constitution. It is subversive of liberty. It is establishing a precedent under which other persons than the Chinese, for no better reasons than those mentioned by the Occident, may suffer the penalty of banishment.

And mark it; the same Congress which passed this anti-Chinese law, which Justice Field of the Supreme Court characterizes as inhuman and brutal, as violating the Constitution, and fraught with grave dangers to the constitutional liberties of the people, also enacted the pious legislation which closed the World’s Fair on Sunday. Is it not cause for gratitude that our national legislators, though giving official expression to such sentiments as are embodied in the Geary law, are nevertheless men of such piety that they will not venture to keep open the World’s Exposition contrary to the law of God!

Was it not always thus? Have not the civil governments of the past exhibited their capacity for cruelty and oppression simultaneously with their greatest display of piety and zeal for the law of God?

The Supreme Court of the United States is not the defender of the liberties of the weak and the oppressed. It never was. The Dred Scott decision and the Geary law decision speak in perfect concord on this point. Nor can we look for any protection of our liberties to State or national legislatures when they are ready to trade off legislation in the supposed interests of religion, for the political support of the church. The Fugitive Slave law and the Geary law testify alike that man in his best estate is naturally cruel and tyrannical toward his fellow-man whom fortune has made weak and defenseless.

When legislators are terrified by ecclesiastical threats, and give to the church element or any other faction of the people the control of legislation, we may know the goddess of American liberty is about to take her flight. But alas! whither will she go from the shores of “free America,”—the land which has been the asylum for the oppressed of other nations? Like the dove sent out from Noah’s ark, there will be on earth no resting-place for her abode. She will take her flight, and with her the angel of divine mercy will leave the confines of earth, never to return. Meanwhile we wait and query in our minds, What next? L. A. S.