AdventAI

A REVIEW.

By M. E. K.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 23., June 6, 1893

An article attempting to sustain the first day of the week as the Sabbath of all Christians, has appeared in a late number of the Michigan Christian Advocate. It contains about the usual amount of assumption of articles of this kind to take the place of Scripture, which it is unable to find. We wish to point out a few weaknesses, such as are always inseparably connected with all Sunday arguments. The first Scriptural proof offered for the observance of Sunday is the following:—

“The change [from Saturday to Sunday] was based upon divine authority. The psalmist sang, ‘The stone which the builders refused is become the head of the corner. This is the Lord’s doing; it is marvelous in our eyes. This is thep. 361 Lord’s doing; it is marvelous in our eyes. This is the day which the Lord hath made; we will rejoice and be glad in it.’ Christ is that stone. He was refused at Calvary, but on the resurrection morning he became the head of the corner. Truly it was the Lord’s doing, a demonstration of Christ’s divinity. Truly the resurrection day is the day of days. ‘This is the day which the Lord hath made.’ Prophets had seen it. Psalmists had mused on it. Apostles have preached of it. God saw this day of supreme spiritual rest and triumph when he hallowed the day of rest from the physical labor of creation.”

The above reasoning proceeds upon the assumption that the word “day,” in the 118th psalm, which is the one quoted, refers not only to a particular day of the week, the first day, but to every first day thereafter! For this idea there is not the slightest proof given, but the writer makes up for the psalmist’s failure by several strong assertions of his own. Thus he says: “Prophets had seen it.” What prophet saw Sunday as the Sabbath? We wish he had been just a little more explicit. “Psalmists had mused on it.” Who were these psalmists and in what chapter and verse of their psalms do they “muse” on Sunday as being the Sabbath? We are afraid the writer in the Advocate has been “musing” rather than studying the Scriptures. “Apostles have preached of it [Sunday]!” Which one of the apostles preached that Sunday was the Sabbath? He did not tell us. We cannot but wish he had been a little more particular in some of these statements. Lastly, upon this point he says: “God saw this day [Sunday] of supreme spiritual rest and triumph when he hallowed the day of rest from the physical labors of creation.”

According to this, when God sanctified the seventh day at creation, he saw in it the sanctification of another day,—Sunday! Or does he mean that God sanctified two days at creation, one sanctification to take immediate effect, the other to be effected 4,000 years later! Such reasoning, based entirely upon imagination, is all the foundation for the statement preceding it that the change was based upon divine authority. If the word “day” in this quotation can by any device be made to apply to a definite day of twenty-four hours, there is much more reason for applying it to the one day of Christ’s triumphal entry into Jerusalem; for when the events of that day are described by the evangelists, they refer to Ps. 118:26, where it is said, “Blessed is he that cometh in the name of the Lord.” According to Hale’s Chronology, Vol. III., p. 168, this day was Monday. Others make it to have been nearer the middle of the week. But even if this day could be proved to be Sunday, it would not establish a new order of Sabbaths; it would have no effect upon the succeeding first days. Such a transfer would need a specific command, and this is wanting. A new Sabbath would also need to be preceded by six days of successive labor; for the whole week and its duties grow out of the relation of mankind to the Sabbath and its duties; and divinity has set forth the way to spend the whole week as truly as it has expressed the way to spend the Sabbath. To conclude upon this point, there is no reason for believing that the word “day,” as here used, refers to any literal day. It is no doubt used in the sense of time, referring to the day of salvation under the work of the gospel. It is so used twice in 2 Cor. 6:2: “For he saith, I have heard thee in a time accepted, and in the day of salvation have I succored thee: behold, now is the accepted time; behold, now is the day of salvation.” We are still in the day of mercy, which the “Lord hath made,” and it is our privilege to rejoice and be glad in his salvation.

He next claims that the Jewish Sabbath was but a type of what he calls the true Sabbath, meaning Sunday. For proof he introduces Dr. Akers, as follows:—

“Dr. Akers says: ‘The apostle alludes to this in Heb. 4:3–10. First, he speaks of the rest, or Sabbath keeping of the seventh day, which God appointed for men when he had finished his work, all the blessings of which had been lost through sin. Secondly, he speaks of a typical rest, or Sabbath keeping, given to the Israelites in Canaan. Thirdly, he shows that the Holy Ghost has spoken prophetically to Israel of another day of rest, or Sabbath, saying in respect to entering into it they should not harden their hearts, as their fathers had done with respect to entering the rest, or Sabbath keeping, of Canaan. Into this day of Sabbath keeping the apostle says, “We which have believed do enter into rest.” The Scripture certainly points out for the people of Messiah a Sabbath different from that of the Jews. Believers in Christ entered at once upon observance of the true Sabbath, both as to the particular day and its spiritual blessings.’”

The apostle in Hebrews 4 does indeed speak of a typical rest, which he illustrates by the Sabbath, but he does not compare the Sabbath with any future Sabbath. The “limited day” of verse 7 is the day of probation,—the time when the gospel is to be preached to men. During that time those who hear should be careful lest they harden their hearts. The “day of temptation in the wilderness” covered the whole forty years of the journeys of the children of Israel. The new “day” which God has given us covers not every seventh day or every first day, but every day from the time Jesus became our mediator in the heavenly sanctuary until he leaves that place just previous to his second advent. Now notice verse 8: “For if Jesus [margin, Joshua] had given them rest, then would he not afterward have spoken of another day.” Joshua did not give them the Sabbath, so the “rest” which Joshua gave the Israelites could not have been the Sabbath rest. But Joshua did lead them into the promised land. He gave them that rest, and that was a typical rest, not typical of a future weekly Sabbath, but typical of the possession of all God’s Israel of their final home. This was the rest spoken of prophetically. If Joshua had given the people that rest, God would never have spoken of another day,—a future Canaan. The land of Canaan not being the final rest, God has spoken of a future rest. We are to labor to enter that rest, lest we fall, during our time of probation, as the Jews did in theirs. That rest begins when we accept Christ, and reaches forward and appropriates by faith the future kingdom of God, the true and final rest.

The writer next, assuming that he has proved that the seventh-day Sabbath was typical of the first-day Sabbath, quotes Col. 2:16, 17, as applying to the weekly Sabbath. But if the sabbaths there mentioned include the weekly Sabbath, his former argument of a transfer of the Sabbath from the definite seventh day to the equally definite first day, is wrong; for the days here mentioned must be the same as those mentioned by the same writer in Rom. 14:5, 6, and there it is stated that the observance of these days is to be a matter of each person’s individual choice. The idea of a transfer of the Sabbath to the definite first day, and that of individual choice as to what day a man shall keep, as he shall be “persuaded in his own mind,” cannot possibly be made to harmonize. This proves that the apostle is not in these passages referring to the weekly Sabbath, but to the various ceremonial sabbaths of the Jews.

Again we quote:—

“The disciples, after the illumination of their minds by the Saviour, at once saw the propriety of such a change set forth in Scripture. It is very evident that, had not this change met the divine approval, the enlightened disciples would not have endangered the perpetuity of the seventh day by instituting observance of the first day of the week. To the objection that no express command has been given for the abolition of the Jewish Sabbath, it may be said that the same is true of the sacrifices, yet they have passed away.”

The above is the purest assumption. Where is there any “change [of the Sabbath] set forth in Scripture?” The ablest advocates of Sunday have acknowledged they have no Scripture for its support. Again: what is said about the sacrifices is not true. The whole scope of the book of Hebrews is to show that the Jewish sacrifices had been superseded by a better sacrifice. Thus we read in Heb. 10:6–10:—

“In burnt offerings and sacrifices for sin thou hast had no pleasure. Then said I, Lo, I come (in the volume of the book it is written of me) to do thy will, O God. Above when he said, Sacrifice and offering and burnt offerings and offering for sin thou wouldest not, neither hadst pleasure therein; which are offered by the law; then said he, Lo, I come to do thy will, O God. He taketh away the first, that he may establish the second. By the which will we are sanctified through the offering of the body of Jesus Christ once for all.”

Does not this plainly show that the body of Christ has taken the place of the former sacrifices?—Certainly it does. Where is there the least intimation that the first-day has taken the place of the seventh as the Sabbath? There is no such statement in the Bible.

The writer then takes up Paul’s night meeting at Troas, and says “that this custom [of meeting on Sunday] had Paul’s approval, is seen also in his exhortation to the Hebrews, ‘not forsaking the assembling of yourselves together,’ etc. But it is well understood by critics that this meeting was held on Saturday evening, and Paul mentions no particular day of meeting in his letter to the Hebrews. It is also a well-known historical fact that the Hebrew Christians observed the seventh day as the Sabbath for several centuries after the opening of the Christian era. These are the most important points made in the article. A casual examination such as we have here hastily given them, shows the positions taken to be untenable. A closer and more complete analysis would prove them all to be without foundation. A “Thus saith the Lord” is a better foundation than human reasoning. The custom of Sunday observance has no authority but the contradictory opinions of men. M. E. K.