Christians in the Chain-gang for Conscience’ Sake.
BY ELDER W. H. LITTLEJOHN.
(Battle Creek, Mich.)
THE reader versed in the Scriptures will recall the fact that on one occasion eleven of the twelve tribes of Israel decreed to exterminate the tribe of Benjamin. That decree was decided upon in blood made hot by a shocking affair enacted by several wicked Benjamites, and which the tribe as a whole refused to deal with in a proper manner. Judges 19:22–29. A terrible battle ensued, in which, with the exception of a few scores of men, the whole tribe of Benjamin, including women and children, were left dead upon the field. This done, bitter regrets took the place of wrath, and the successful combatants mourned piteously the terrible tragedy which they had caused to take place. Here is the record: “And the people came to the house of God, and abode there till even before God, and lifted up their voices, and wept sore; and said, O Lord God of Israel, why is this come to pass in Israel, that there should be to-day one tribe lacking in Israel?” Everything was done which could be done to atone for the terrible crime which the the eleven tribes had perpetrated upon the one tribe: but the events of that day of battle, resulting from zeal for God not according to knowledge, were ever after felt and deplored.
It is a trite but true saying, that history oft-times repeats itself. In the judgment of the writer, a crisis is approaching in this, our own356favored land, resembling in some particulars that reached in the history of the Jewish nation, when it was determined that the tribe of Benjamin must be blotted out. The parallelism between the two cases is marked in several, but very dissimilar in one respect. Like the men of Benjamin, those whose destruction is sought are vastly in the minority. Like them, also, the danger which threatens, emanates from their own brethren, who ought to be their protectors and counselors, instead of their enemies. Unlike the Benjamites, however, the men whose existence is now imperiled, have been guilty of no outrageous crime, nor are they justly chargeable with palliating the crime of any one else. Their condition resembles in a marked manner that of Daniel, when those who plotted against his life frankly admitted that if they could make out a case against him, it must be from the standpoint of the law of his God. Dan. 6:5. Indeed, as they look upon the matter, it is on account of their fidelity to the God of heaven that they are called upon to suffer fines and imprisonment in this, the freest nation upon the earth. In the catalogue of Christian denominations, they are listed as Seventh-day Adventists and Seventh-day Baptists. As their names indicate, one of their marked peculiarities consists in their observance of the seventh day of the week as the Sabbath. It is on account of this latter peculiarity of their faith that they are subjected to the annoyances spoken of above. In the States of Pennsylvania, Georgia, Maryland, Texas, Arkansas, Tennessee, and others which it is not necessary to mention at this time, they have been either fined or imprisoned, or both, for quietly working on the first day of the week, after having set apart and observed the seventh day as a Sabbath to the Lord.
In 1886 three Seventh-day Adventists were incarcerated for two months in jail at Paris, Henry Co., Tenn., for this offense, even when it was admitted by all that the work performed was done at such a distance from the highway that it could have disturbed no one. Subsequently, Mr. R. M. King, of the same faith as the former, was fined and imprisoned for Sunday work. His case was carried at last to the United States Court. Before the decision was reached, Mr. King, who was out on bail at the time, died very suddenly of heart difficulty. That this catastrophe was hastened, if not wholly occasioned, by the tremendous mental strain under which the unfortunate man was kept so long, there can be no doubt. At one time during the progress of the trial of Mr. King, the prosecuting attorney failing to put in an appearance at court, there was a prospect that the case might not come to trial. The Ministerial Association of the city of Memphis, Tenn., hearing of this fact, immediately convened and passed resolutions to employ counsel to continue the prosecution of Mr. King. Mark this, reader; it was not Robert G. Ingersoll; it was not some open-mouthed blasphemer of God, and hater of all who bear the name of Christ, that made haste to offer his influence and his money to insure the conviction and imprisonment of that solitary Sabbath-keeper who perhaps had surrendered the highest ambitions of his life, in order to obey God strictly. No, far from it. The men who did this miserable work were ministers of the gospel of Him who said, “My kingdom is not of this world.” John 18:36. What think you would have been the emotions that would have filled their breasts had they stood by the open grave, and listened to the dull thud of the clods as they fell upon the coffin box of that servant of Christ whom they were instrumental in sending to his untimely end. They were not there, however, but angel forms were, and the judgment will reveal the record which they made on that occasion. King is dead, but happy would be the lot of those who were responsible for his death, could they exchange places with him.
But to resume. Since the death of Mr. King, other prosecutions have been instituted against Sabbatarians in Tennessee. Four were convicted and confined in jail at Paris, Henry Co., for several months. Their persecutors not satisfied with their confinement in jail, ransacked the old and obsolete statutes of the State, until they found one which made the jail the common work-house of the county. This was just what they required for the realization of their plans, and they immediately caused these men of God to be set at work on the highway in the chain-gang, in company with low and base criminals. Nay, more; they even conspired to compel these men to work on the Sabbath day. Had not the God-fearing jailer utterly refused to carry out their behests, it is not impossible that the scourge and the pump might have been resorted to in the vain endeavor to force the prisoners to do violence to their consciences by working when God has commanded them to rest. What a spectacle was that for heaven to look upon. What must have been the spirit which actuated the men who brought about and gloated over such a state of things as this? Unhappily the individuals who were the prime movers in this infamous transaction, like the ministers at Memphis, spoken of above, were nominally the disciples of Him who uttered the sermon on the mount, which breathes nothing but the kindliest sentiments toward all men. I am aware that the authors and abettors of these cruelties deny that there is in them any element of religious persecution. These men, say they, are allowed by the laws of Tennessee to rest on the seventh day, if they choose to do so. All that we require of them is that they should rest also on the first day of the week in deference to the law of the State.
But I ask what is such a requirement but religious persecution? Is not the law of a State which enforces rest on Sunday, to all intents and purposes, a religious law? Is it not based upon the idea that Sunday is the Christian Sabbath, and should be enforced as such? To deny this would be to deny that which every intelligent man knows to be true. Who are they that are stirring up the people from Maine to California to enforce the Sunday laws? Are they not the members of the National Reform Party and the American Sabbath Union? These gentlemen do not care the snap of a finger for the civil Sabbath, only as it can serve the ends of the Christian Sabbath, so-called. It is not the sanitary condition of society that they are so deeply interested in. Take from the Sunday issue the Christian element, and their ardor for the enforcement of Sunday laws would at once cool.
But suppose that we admit for a moment that the laws in question are made merely in the interest of a weekly civil rest day, then what? Does that materially change the case practically speaking, so far as Sabbatarians are concerned? Does not the fact still remain that as a class they are burdened by the laws of many States in a most serious and oppressive manner? The majority of them are poor in this world’s goods, and if they were compelled to rest two days in the week, it would be very difficult for them to obtain a livelihood. Among the 50,000 Sabbath-keepers in this country, there would be, say 8,000 families. At a moderate estimate each family could earn two dollars on each first day, when permitted to work. When compelled to rest on that day, therefore, they would lose that amount weekly. In each year there are fifty-two Sundays. Provided Sunday laws were made and enforced in all the States, the loss to each of these families would be $104 yearly, or in the aggregate, the 8,000 families would be compelled to forfeit $832,000 yearly, in order to enjoy the privilege of worshiping God according to the dictates of their own consciences.
Would this be religious liberty? If so, it falls far short of what its boastful admirers have claimed for it. Would this be placing the men of all denominations upon a common footing? Would this be carrying out the spirit of our national Constitution, which forbids Congress to make any law prohibiting the free exercise of religion? If so, then we have been deluded with empty words and glittering generalities.
But to return to the civil Sabbath idea. A civil Sabbath is one which is designed to secure purely secular objects. Its most prominent purpose is that of insuring one day of rest weekly to each citizen. This is done because, as is claimed, men are so constituted by nature that they require respite from labor at least one day out of each seven. It is not urged that there is any choice of days in this matter. All will admit that for the designs of bodily rest, Saturday will answer as good a purpose as Sunday. Now, therefore, those who observe Saturday as the Sabbath, meet all the physical necessities of the situation as fully as do those who rest on Sunday. What possible excuse can there be, consequently, for passing a law which in its practical operation compels the conscientious Sabbatarian to rest on two days in the week? Suppose it be granted, for the sake of the argument, that the unity of rest on the first day of the week is desirable because otherwise a little friction might arise from the observance of different rest days. In other words, suppose it were admitted that in some particulars there would be advantages that would grow out of the keeping of the same rest day by all, which would be lost were there two classes observing different rest days. Would such an admission justify the enforcement of one and the same rest day upon all, even from the point of view of the advocate of the civil rest day?—That would depend upon the nature and extent of the advantages to be gained from the course in question. If those advantages would be counterbalanced by disadvantages greater in number and importance than they are, then it must be conceded that it would not be wise for legislators to hold too strictly to unity as to the time of rest. Let the matter be fairly tested right here. In doing so, let it be remembered that the subject is being canvassed from the purely secular aspect. Already it has been shown that the loss of each Sunday in the year by Sabbatarians would amount to four fifths of a million of dollars annually. That estimate did not include the Jews. There are about half a million of them in this country. Admitting that half of them would adhere to the seventh-day Sabbath strictly, in spite of Sunday laws, and you have an added loss of $4,160,000, or a total of $4,992,000. This, I say, would be the result, financially speaking, of enforcing Sunday as a day of rest for all. The amount mentioned, and probably much more, would prove a dead loss to the nation. Is it not doubtful whether the losses resulting from having two rest days instead of one would necessarily reach anything like such a figure? In communities where a portion of the inhabitants observe Sunday, and another portion observe the Sabbath, the two classes very soon adapt themselves to the situation, and so far as deal is concerned, get along with but very little jar or discord.