Geary Chinese Exclusion Act Proves Unenforceable

50%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 6, 1893

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 23.

Read the full edition

Geary Chinese Exclusion Act Proves Unenforceable

When acts are passed which cannot be enforced, it is a travesty upon legislation. Such appears to be the nature of the Geary Chinese Exclusion act. To test the matter, one Ny Look, a Chinese of New York, who has resided about thirty years in this country, and was a cook in the Union army, was brought before the court, having no certificate of residence, and so, according to the law, subject to deportation from the United States. Judge Lacombe could of course do no less than to give an order in accordance with said act; but with grim humor he worded it in this way: “That the said Ny Look be, and he is, hereby discharged from said marshal, and ordered to be deported from the United States whenever provision for such deportation be made by the proper authorities.” The Geary act authorizes no one to carry out the order for deportation, and makes no provision for the expense of the same; and it would require no small sum to deport nearly a hundred thousand persons. So the whole matter falls as a dead letter, greatly to the welfare of American missionaries in China. Ny Look was told by his counsel that he would not be troubled any further, and departed to his place of business with “a smile that was childlike and bland.”