WORLD’S FAIR COMMENTS

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jul 4, 1893

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 27.

Read the full edition

WORLD’S FAIR COMMENTS.

The decision of Chief-justice Fuller, that the United States government has no such jurisdiction in the World’s Fair grounds as to give the government the power to say when the Fair shall be open or shut, has naturally provoked much criticism from those who have had an idea that the World’s Fair was a church exhibition, run by the United States government. The Northwestern Christian Advocate complains that “the issue was debated and decided on legal grounds solely, and religion and good morals were not taken into account.” Since United States courts are not for the purpose of trying heretics or deciding knotty points of theology or religion, but for the simple administration of justice between man and man, and only in relation to the things of this present life, the objection raised by the Advocate seems to us not to be well taken. The longer we can keep the discussion of religious questions out of the courts, the better it will be for the country. Any court which has a legal right to decide what day is the Sabbath, and to command its observance upon a basis derived either directly or indirectly from an interpretation of Scriptures, has also a right to try Dr. Briggs for heresy, or decide any other contested religious dogmas.
But while the question of religion, also the question involved in that, of the unconstitutionality of the Sunday-closing provision, was not touched by Justice Fuller in his decision, since it was not argued before him upon that basis, some questions that he asked showed that he knew there was such a question, and that it had something to do with the formation of his decision. Albeit, it did not have the effect that the ardent Sunday-closers hoped that it would. He asked the attorneys of the government, who were contending that Congress had an absolute right to close the Fair on Sunday without any appropriation whatever, if Congress had a right to close the Fair the other six days. That Congress had a right thus to do, they did not dare assert; and since the attorneys on both sides had agreed to keep both the religious question and the constitutional question growing out of it, out of the pleadings, and hence out of the court, they could only say by their silence, what certain persons once said when asked about the baptism of John: “We cannot tell.” So while Sunday-opening of the Fair is pronounced by the court to be legal, the question of the constitutionality of a Sunday law is nicely shelved over to some future time.
The Sunday following Justice Fuller’s decision will be likely to be known in the annals of church history as “brimstone Sunday,” such was the lurid character of many of the sermons that were delivered on that day. Dr. Henson, of Chicago, revived the old Miltonian idea of the Devil, as a toad squatting at the ear of Eve, and has him in that form at the ear of Justice Fuller, suggesting the lines of his decision. Others express the expectation that the lightning will dash the “white city” to fragments; that fire like that which fell upon the cities of the plain will destroy the inhabitants; that the cyclone will sweep away the city; that the cholera will overleap the national quarantine, and wreak upon wicked Chicago divine vengeance to the full! And all this senseless and fanatical jargon is based upon the unscriptural and unreasonable notion that the observance of Sunday is established upon the authority of God as proclaimed in the fourth commandment,—a commandment that has no more relation to Sunday-keeping than the decree of Julius to destroy the Gothic youth in the cities of the Roman empire, in A. D. 378, has to do with the deportation of the Chinese from this country under the operations of the “Geary law,” when that law shall be enforced.
The Methodist Church is seriously agitating the idea of removing their exhibit from the Fair. Indeed, this church had long ago declared through their official organs, that they would boycott the Fair entirely if it was not run to suit their notions. Much of this talk was religious buncombe; for they have counted their own towers and bulwarks so long, and ignored the towers and bulwarks of others, that they did not realize that it might be decided against their wishes in the matter. They evidently looked upon the Fair directors as men to be swayed by the same influences as the members of the Methodist Episcopal General Conference, and the result has been to them something of a disappointment. So, many of the more radical Methodist bishops and papers are calling for the removal of the Methodist exhibit, and a general stay-away from the Fair. Others advocate a more rational course. Among the latter class is Bishop Fowler. The bishop says, “For myself, I shall attend week days as much as other duties and financial conditions will permit. As a church, we are not managing the Fair, and are not responsible for its management.” This is certainly a consistent view to take of the matter. If the whole church would take this view, that they are not “managing the Fair,” and would take the strength and energy they are using to manage what is not, and should not be under their control, or the control of any church, or all the churches put together, and apply it to good, honest, early Methodist evangelistic work, they would better fill the purpose God designs his church to fulfill.
Not content with suggesting electricity, brimstone, cyclones, and the cholera as the proper visitations of divine wrath, one zealous minister suggests that Lake Michigan might be induced to sweep away the “pagan show.” A zealous Canadian, Colonel Hunt, from Toronto, proposes to bombard the skies every Saturday, from several points near Chicago, in the style of the modern rain-maker, and thus draw down floods of water every Sunday. This, he says, will “save the honor of the nation.” He says he has plenty of money which he is anxious to spend in the Lord’s cause. He has written Mr. Wanamaker and other leading Sunday-closers, and shows much enthusiasm. The way he proposes to go to work to answer his own prayers, reminds us of the colored man’s experience. He had prayed several days for some chickens for his Thanksgiving dinner. The day was near, and the chickens had not arrived. Suddenly an impression came over him, which with its succeeding consequences, he described thus: “Bum by de Laud said, ‘Sambo, whaffor yo no answer yo own prayers?’ and as shua as yo is bon to die, dose chickens come right into my front yard befo midnight!”
Another reverend gentleman presents the question in the following manner: He supposes a hundred people toiling in a mine for gold until they are nearly dead with fatigue. Finally they make an agreement, all consenting that they will work six days, and rest the seventh, and that if any more people come to join them, they must understand this rule and obey it. He then draws the following conclusion:—
“That is the fundamental principle of our government, and that is the Sunday question. On Greely’s arctic expedition they got out of provisions; and while they were waiting for supplies, they entered into a compact to eat just so many biscuits each day. One day it became known that two men were quietly getting at the biscuits, and had been eating more than their share between meals. A small matter, you may say, but Greely had both those men taken out, court-martialed, and shot.
“By the compact formed in the cabin of the Mayflower, it was agreed that the Sabbath should be kept sacredly; and we as a government and a people have ratified that compact continuously. We are talking of it simply as a compact entered into for our protection, just as the hundred men enter into a compact not to work the mine on the seventh day. And if our compact is broken, and one man runs his mill on Sunday, and another his store, they are robbing the rest of society, and they ought to be shot—out of society.”
The utter folly manifested in the above comparison is enough to cause one to fear that the ministerial intellect of this country is dwarfed in knowledge and weak in logic. The difference between the case of a man stealing the last morsels of food from his starving companions, and a man running his mill or store on Sunday, is so apparent that a child can see it, if learned divines cannot.
Again: The people who came over in the “Mayflower” were not all even of the early settlers of this country, and there is no more reason that their “compact” must be kept forever than there is that any or all the conditions of the Colonial charters under which the various colonies were established, must be so observed. The whole history of the Puritans in this country is only one of the incidents in American history. No king and no people have a right to make laws binding on future generations. All laws made by men of past ages, which we now observe, are only binding on us now because of our consent. When that consent is taken away, whether the law was made on the “Mayflower” or anywhere else, it loses every element that gives it life. To shoot a man, even out of society, for the non-observance of a compact made by a small portion of the early settlers of America over two hundred years ago, under influences and conditions far different from those which now surround us, because he does not do that which the majority of all the people since have done, is a suggestion so outrageous that we wonder any intelligent man can be its abettor or apologist.
M. E. K.