A BILL to tax church property in Michigan was presented at the present session of the Legislature at Lansing. It was referred to a committee, which, after hearing from both those who favor and those who oppose the bill, April 18 reported, through its chairman, Mr. Gluecklich, in favor of the bill. The following is the report, which we clip from the Detroit Tribune, of April 19:—
CHURCH TAXATION.
“The Committee on Taxation gave a hearing this morning on the bill of Mr. Gluecklich for the taxation of church property. Mr. Gluecklich presented a report, which, after citing statistics, made the arguments that ‘the exemption of churches from regular taxation is in violation of every principle of equality and justice, and is an evident disregard to the most obvious obligations of public morality.
“‘The church does not render an equivalent for this exemption. Two thirds of the people do not regularly attend any church, and they should not be taxed to pay for the other third; moreover, those who attend church are for the most part, of that educated and refined class who do not need any special moral restraint to secure the observance of law.
“‘It creates a prejudice against the church, and drives the masses into an attitude of antagonism, because of the huge injustice of the churches’ increasing their personal taxes, and receiving favors for which it has no shadow of a claim.
“‘It detracts from the glory and independence of true religion to be a pauper and a leech upon the State, and all honorable persons should be ashamed to imply that the church needs this favor from the State, even if an incidental service be rendered.
“‘The people are in duty bound carefully to consider whether any given appropriation of the public money is wisely made, but as an exemption from taxation is the same as appropriation, they have an opportunity to judge and act in the matter.
“‘The taxation of church property would make very little difference to church goers, as they are already mainly taxpayers, and what is saved to the church by exemption is added to the duplicate of personal taxation.
“‘A system of mendicancy is encouraged by the exemption of convents and similar institutions, where the vow of poverty is taken, and convent expenses are paid by the proceeds of beggary.
“‘The same reasons can be given for the exemption of many other kinds of property from taxation that are given for the exemption of church property; and if these additional exemptions were allowed, the State would become bankrupt, and sequestration and revolution would be the result.
“‘Why should the church assume the character of a beggar, asking remission of taxes, instead of paying its full share of the cost of protection and defense, thus rendering unto Cæsar that which rightfully belongs to Cæsar.
“‘It is not an attack on the church to insist upon the just taxation of its property; but it champions the rights of the people in claiming that all property, except that belonging to the State, shall be equally liable to taxation.
“‘In new countries there may have been some excuse for encouraging the building of churches by exempting them from taxation, but this policy does not apply to our large cities and towns. The most valuable property on our public streets is owned by the churches, which pay no taxes. This is manifest injustice, if not downright dishonesty.’”