An inference is a conclusion we arrive at in our own mind from some real or imagined premise. If the premise is a reality, then the inference based upon it may be correct. But if the premise only exists in the imagination, and has no real foundation in fact, the inference drawn from it must be wholly unreliable. Any argument, then, based only upon an inference, must be very weak; for there is always the probability that the premise upon which it rests, and from which it derives its entire strength, has no real existence.
How many persons have been deceived by allowing that something was true, of which they knew nothing positively, but they inferred that it was so. Merchants have invested heavily in certain products which they inferred were about to rise in value, but the basis for their inference was only imaginary, and loss and ruin were the result. Generals have inferred that the enemy were moving in certain directions, and were about to attempt to do this or that, and trying to intercept and thwart such movements, were themselves thwarted and defeated, simply because the enemy were not doing what they supposed they were. Should the merchant or the general exercise great care that his inferences have some actual foundation, how much more careful should we be that our faith and practice—things upon which hang our eternal destiny—should rest, not upon what we infer may be so, but upon what actually is so. This principle is recognized in theory, at least, by various denominations. Thus the Methodist discipline says, “The Holy Scriptures contain all things necessary to salvation; so that whatsoever is not read therein nor may be proved thereby, is not to be required of any that it should be believed as an article of faith, or be thought requisite or necessary to salvation.”
According to this statement, inferences, even if drawn from Scripture, will not do. Doctrines must be “read therein,” or “proved thereby.” This is a good theory indeed, but is the practice and theory of this church in harmony? Do they hold things as “requisite or necessary” to salvation that are not read in the Scriptures? They claim that Sunday is the Sabbath. From their thousand pulpits they proclaim that Christ changed the law of God, so that now the seventh day need not be kept to commemorate the creation, but that the first day should be observed to commemorate the resurrection of Christ. A great change surely, and if true, there ought to be some substantial statement of it in the Scriptures; for if Sunday-keeping is not “read therein” nor “proved thereby,” it “is not to be required of any man that it should be believed as an article of faith, or be thought requisite or necessary to salvation.” But the Scripture argument for Sunday does not rest upon any plain statement, and its greatest friends and abettors are compelled by stubborn facts to acknowledge their weakness upon this point. Did God rest on the first day? No one claims that he did. Did he ever bless the first day? It cannot be proved by the Scriptures. Has he ever sanctified the first day? Who can point out the chapter and verse? Where is the proof in the New Testament that Jesus or his apostles rested on the first day, or that it was the stated time for religious meetings? It is not “read therein” nor can it be “proved thereby.” Upon what, then, does this Sunday structure rest? It rests upon inferences, nothing but inferences at the best.
After Jesus rose from the dead, the first day of the week, he appeared to his disciples (John 20:19), and it is inferred that they had met to commemorate his resurrection, and that he approved of their course by his presence and his blessing. But we should ever bear in mind that an inference must have a perceptible basis, or else it amounts to nothing . We carefully search the records of those stirring days in the four Gospels, and we find, 1. That the disciples were not having a meeting; they were in their own house at home. John 20:10; Acts 1:13. 2. The reason for their being together is given, and it was not to celebrate the resurrection, in which they did not then believe. 3. They were not celebrating the Lord’s supper, as is often claimed, but were eating their own supper (Mark 16:14); their food, broiled fish and honeycomb (Luke 24:42), is conclusive upon this point. And lastly, they did not at this time believe in his resurrection. Witness his upbraiding them for their unbelief and “hardness of heart, because they believed not.” Mark 16:14; Luke 24:41. Tracing back, then, this inference for Sunday, to see upon what it rests, we find—nothing, not even sand; it is an air castle, nothing more!
Take another scripture. Acts 20:7, 8 is supposed to furnish proof for Sunday-keeping in the apostolic age. Here we have an account of a religious meeting on the first day of the week, the only instance recorded in the New Testament, and it was inferred that this was therefore the Sabbath, and the regular day for religious services in the primitive church.
Let us see if this inference has a real or only a fancied basis. Paul stayed at Troas seven days. One of those days was the Sabbath. We are not left in the dark as to the way Paul spent the Sabbath. Luke tells us that it was Paul’s manner to preach on the Sabbath. Acts 17:2. Hence he must have preached upon the Sabbath spent at Troas, and judging from his usual earnestness and zeal, and the fact that the brethren were in a large town, and very convenient for frequent assembling, and more than all, that this was to be his last opportunity of seeing them, it seems reasonable to conclude that services were held every day, certainly every evening during Paul’s stay at Troas. The last meeting only is recorded. While Luke and the other disciples went on before Paul, around the isthmus to Assos (Acts 20:13), Paul stayed to have a last farewell meeting with the brethren. The meeting was interrupted at midnight by a serious accident; a young man overpowered by sleep, fell through an open window to the ground below, and was taken up dead. Paul immediately went down and fell on him, and embracing him, said, “Trouble not yourselves; for his life is in him.” Then they broke bread, after which Paul talked a long while, even till break of day, and departed, going afoot across the isthmus, meeting those who had gone on ahead with the boat at Assos, when they again pursued their journey together.
Now what real basis is there in this record for the inference that the first day had become the Sabbath, and the stated time for religious meetings? Is the first day called the Sabbath, or Lord’s day?—It is not. Does Luke say this was the regular time for their meetings?—He does not. Indeed, this was an evening meeting, hence could not have been the regular weekly service.
Again: Luke did not stay to this meeting, nor any of the company, except Paul, a strange procedure if this first-day meeting was the regular weekly service and the principal meeting during Paul’s stay there. We now inquire upon what evening this meeting was held? It was the evening of the first day, and as in all Bible reckoning the dark part of the day precedes the light part, this meeting must have been held upon what we now call Saturday evening, and the apostle pursued his journey Sunday morning.
That this meeting was held on Saturday night, is the opinion of many eminent expositors. Then, far from regarding the first day as the Sabbath, Paul started Sunday morning on his journey to Jerusalem! Scanning thus closely the record, we find no premise to warrant an inference that the first day had become the Sabbath, or the stated time for worship; but we do find a good premise for an inference that neither Luke and his companions, nor Paul, considered the first day holy; for they took ship on that day, and he took a long and toilsome walk Sunday morning to meet them!
Following back, then, this inference for Sunday sanctity to find its basis, like Noah’s dove let loose from the ark, we find nothing to set the foot upon. So we must conclude that this inference, having no foundation, is nothing but a figment of the imagination. M. E. K.
(Concluded next week.)