In the periodical press of Russia, in public opinion, and in the anxiety of the government, one sees constant evidences of the general feeling of alarm engendered by the famine of 1892, and in the Preussische Revue for January we find a paper on the subject in which the assertion is made that the result of all investigations has been to demonstrate two very serious facts; (1) that European Russia is overpopulated, and (2) that a terrible catastrophe hangs over a great part of the country—it is being converted into desert. Treating of the first statement, the writer says:—
“This may sound paradoxical, but becomes intelligible on a review of the facts. More than eighty per cent of the population subsist by agriculture. The emancipation of the serfs involved a distribution of the land, which is now divided between large landholders and peasants in the proportion 21 : 19. The estimated agricultural area of European Russia is 400,000,000 dessiatines (the dessiatine is about two and one-half acres); of this 190,000,000 are in the hands of the peasants, 110,000,000 belong to the crown, 60,000,000 to private owners, and the remaining 40,000,000 are town and mineral lands. The agricultural land includes pasture and forest lands.”
The writer then, estimating the agricultural population at 80,000,000 to 83,000,000, argues that the land is admittedly inadequate under existing conditions, and discusses the proposed remedies, the first of which is the distribution of the whole land among the peasants or their expatriation in masses to the agricultural lands in Turkestan and Siberia; the second, the introduction of a more rational system of agriculture. On the subject of these proposals the writer quotes the unfavorable criticism of the Vestnik Europy, which is very much to the point:—
“In the first place, the Russian peasant is too poor to raise the standard of agriculture. If he had more land, it is possible that he might improve his status while paying the increased taxes, and the one means of increasing his holding is to make the State lands communal. This would increase his holding by about fifty per cent, but the gain would soon be paralyzed by increase of population, and moreover the measure would entail the sacrifice of the last acre of Russian forest. Nine tenths of the State lands are forests, and constitute the reservoirs of the water system of the Upper Volga and the tributaries of the Baltic and White seas. This destruction, while affording temporary relief, would involve northern Russia in the fate which has overtaken the south—an ever-increasing drought. If the inadequacy of the soil to the support of the people is evidence of overpopulation, then Russia in Europe is overpopulated.
The writer then considers the transportation of a large body of the people to central Asia, but argues that the conditions there are very much what they are at home. Capital is needed for profitable farming, and although the virgin forest soil may yield fair crops at first, it would not be long before the wholesale forest denudation would be followed by precisely the same results as in Europe. “For wasteful farming Asia is too small, and for a rational system Europe is large enough.”
Very good then, says the party of the second part, “intensive farming is what we want; a rational system of agriculture alone can save us.” But to this the Vestnik Europy replies dryly:—
“The recommendation is about as useful as to prescribe a costly remedy to a man who has not a kopeck in his pocket.”
“This comment (says the writer) hits the nail on the head. The Russian peasant is so poor that every season he has to sell his corn in the ear, and every few years the oxen in his stall, to raise the means to cover taxes, usury, and the indispensable necessities for carrying on his labors. From year to year he sinks deeper; that is a fact universally recognized; and for years past the government and rural authorities have been endeavoring to improve his condition, but in vain. The agricultural banks have not materialized, and on the side of the farmers there is a sad want of self-reliance, the natural consequence of the sudden change involved in emancipation. From the first day the peasants acquired possession of their own lands, they have persistently impoverished them.”
As regards the advocacy of a more intensive and rational treatment of the land, the writer first reviews the existing conditions, which he attributes to utter exhaustion engendered by the effort to keep alive an export trade in farm products, to the denudation of the forests for the extension of railways whose chief function has been to facilitate this export trade, to the enormous taxation rendered necessary for the support of Russia’s immense army and war material which keeps the farmer at the lowest level of possible subsistence, and finally to the low condition of culture with its attendant want of hope, self-reliance, and industrial energy; and argues that to raise the standard of agriculture,—
“Would necessitate an enormous expenditure for stock and implements, for an army of agricultural inspectors, and for a military force for the suppression of the agricultural riots, which would inevitably result from the attempt to enforce such novel methods.”
To this the Vestnik Europy adds:—
“Yes! The matter with Russia is lack of culture. But in saying this, we are quite aware that it is only a theoretic proposition which can contribute nothing to the solution of the problem. It is simply equivalent to saying that there would be hope for Russia if existing conditions were replaced by higher but unattainable ones. The country will become desert long before the people can be fitted for its redemption.”
The writer closes with a very cheerless review of the situation, seeing nothing more practical than the inauguration of extensive irrigation works, nothing more hopeful than the reduction of the population to the soil capacity. Finally he once more quotes the outspoken Vestnik Europy for the conclusion that neither gold nor medicine can help sick Russia until she comes to her senses, and disabuses herself of the false idea that her neighbors are only seeking an opportunity to assail her. This is the delusion which exhausts Russia, involving an outlay for military purposes, which, applied to raising the social and industrial condition of her people, would suffice to emancipate her from her present dilemma.—Literary Digest.