Fifth Petition.
“And forgive us our debts, as we forgive our debtors.” The meaning of the word, “debt,” in this petition, is sufficiently indicated in our Lord’s explanatory words which immediately follow: “For if ye forgive men their trespasses, your heavenly Father will also forgive you: but if ye forgive not men their trespasses, neither will your Father forgive your trespasses.” The trespasses of men which we are to forgive, are such as pertain to ourselves. The trespasses which we ask God to forgive us, are our trespasses against him. In the substantial reiteration of this prayer by Luke (11:4), he brings out the idea more clearly, by calling them “sins.” “Forgive us our sins; for we also forgive every one that is indebted to us.”
This petition is connected with the preceding one (the prayer for daily bread), by the conjunction “and,” this being the first use of that word in this prayer, and perhaps not without some significance. Sir Richard Baker has the following quaint thought upon this point, that as the first use of the word was to join the heavens and the earth together (referring to the language in Gen. 1:1, “In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth”), so the use of it here is to join the blessings of heaven and earth together (that is the daily bread and the forgiveness of sin); “for as the earth without a heaven would have made but a miserable world, so these earthly blessings [daily bread] without the heavenly [forgiveness of sin] will make but a miserable man.”
The use of the word, “and,” here, makes the petition for pardon of our trespasses, or sins, against our heavenly Father, as much a daily supplication as the prayer for daily bread. Dr. Dods says, “Forgiveness is as much the basis of a day’s duty as bread. If we are to serve on earth, we must have bread; but if we are to serve, either on earth or elsewhere, we must have forgiveness. As surely as we faint and die without bread, so surely do we faint and die from all godly life, and for all godly purposes, if we have not forgiveness.”
Cyprian says that we are here taught that we sin daily, by being commanded to pray daily for the forgiveness of sin. And Sir Richard Baker (1645) presents these thoughts upon this point: “By this petition, then, it appears that every man commits sin, because every man is here enjoined to ask forgiveness. But are they not the just?—Yes, but they are just before God in his mercy, not in his justice; before God as a father, not as a judge; before God in Christ, not in themselves.” Again he says, “God indeed hath granted a general pardon to all sinners, in the merits of his Son; but none shall have benefit of it but such only as sue it forth by the tongue of faith, and fetch it out by the feet of charity. And this is the tongue of faith when we say, ‘Forgive us our trespasses.’ These are the feet of charity when we ‘forgive them that trespass against us.’”
There is one clause in this petition which is of most solemn import. It is that which reads, “As we forgive our debtors.” We ask God to forgive us, as we forgive those who have trespassed against us, or have done us wrong of any kind. The measure of our forgiveness to our fellow-men is therefore the measure of the forgiveness which we ask for ourselves from God. This brings indeed a close test upon every heart; for if we do not forgive, if we harbor sentiments of revenge, or hard, ungenerous feelings against any, when we pray this prayer, we virtually ask God not to forgive us.
In Matt. 18:23–35, this fact is brought out in a vivid and startling light. A servant owed his lord an immense debt, and having nothing with which to pay, besought him to have patience with him; and the lord, pitying his condition, forgave him all the debt. But the same servant went out and found one of his fellow-servants who owed him a trifling sum, and he, having nothing with which to pay, asked him to have patience with him, and he would pay it all; but he would not, but cast him into prison till he should pay the debt. This coming to the ears of the lord of those servants, he sent for the unmerciful man, and reminded him of what he had done for him, and admonished him that he also should have showed mercy to his fellow-servant; but as he did not, he took back all that he had forgiven him, and charged back upon him again his whole immense indebtedness, and subjected him to the requisite penalty to make good the payment. Then Christ closes the parable with these solemn words: “So likewise shall my heavenly Father do also unto you, if ye from your hearts forgive not every one his brother their trespasses.” “Yet there are persons,” says Robinson, “who repeat this petition, who are not afraid to say, ‘I forgive, but I cannot forget.’ In those words there is little agreement with the prayer. They may have the spirit and the sound of cherished animosity. They are self-contradictory, professing to put out the flame, while pouring on oil.”
The comparison implied in the word, “as,” does not mean that we can plead the fact that we forgive others as a reason why God should forgive us. It is not because we forgive, that we ought to be forgiven; but because God has forgiven us, we ought to forgive others. Neither does it imply any similarity of measure between our forgiveness and that of God; for we can at most forgive but little, while he forgives much. Neither does it imply that he imitates us, but we imitate him; for the rule of priority is that in all action of love and mercy, God is first. He manifests these graces unto us, and this prompts us, or should do so, to show mercy unto others.
But we should consider the limitations also that belong to this subject. This petition does not imply that everything promiscuously is to be forgiven; as, in this case, the Saviour would virtually encourage the doing of injury to others; for there are many who would engage in all manner of violence, fraud, injury, and oppression upon others, if they knew that these were all to be passed by, and they escape all punishment for their crimes. Injustice is not to be excused or connived at, nor the innocent to suffer. Governments are to be maintained, and magistrates are appointed to call offenders to account. Reference is only had, therefore, to matters of a personal and private nature, which affect ourselves alone.
Thus, while the importance of our exercising forgiveness is shown in the fact that it is the measure of the forgiveness that we shall receive from God, it is important also in the wonderful effects it hasp. 281 upon those toward whom we show forgiveness and love. Great account is made of the wonderful effect of the power to work miracles, which the early disciples had in bringing men to accept the truths of the gospel. But it has been well said, that no miracle which they did, had so great effect in turning the hearts of men to Christ as “the miracle of faith which they carried about in their own hearts, by which they overcame all injuries by forgiving them.”—Williams. And the blessed work, wrought in changing an enemy to a friend, by exercising toward him the duty of forgiveness and the spirit of the gospel, is well set forth in the following beautiful words of Augustine:—
“Ye have enemies; for who can live on this earth without them? Take heed to yourselves; love them. In no way can thy enemy so hurt thee by his violence, as thou dost hurt thyself if thou love him not. And let it not seem to you impossible to love him. Believe first that it can be done, and pray that the will of God may be done in you, for what good can thy neighbor’s ill do to thee? If he had no ill, he would not even be thy enemy. Wish him well, then, that he may end his ill, and he will be thy enemy no longer, for it is not the human nature in him that is at enmity with thee, but his sin. Let thy prayer be against the malice of thine enemy, that it may die, and he may live, for if thine enemy were dead, thou hast lost, it might seem, an enemy, yet thou hast not found a friend. But if his malice die, thou hast at once lost an enemy and found a friend.”