AdventAI

AN IMPUDENT FRAUD.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 14., April 4, 1893

The Chain-Letter Scheme.

The devices resorted to by unscrupulous people to acquire money without having the trouble of working for it, are many, but one of the most ingenious, and at the same time one of the most successful, is the “chain letter.” These chain letters have been sent to all parts of the United States and Canada, and, no doubt, have been the means of wringing thousands of dollars from charitably inclined people who were unable to resist their piteous appeals. Sometimes these appeals are for “money to educate a young lady who is filled with a burning desire to preach the gospel to the heathen in foreign land;” sometimes imploring aid “to carry on the noble work of an institution for educating poor orphans;” always something calculated to secure the sympathy of kindly people, and winding up with an earnest appeal not to break the chain by refusing to help the good work. No doubt some of the chain-letter schemes have been originated with good intent for some real charity, but as a rule they are fraudulent. In view of the fact that we have received several inquiries as to the reliability of this scheme, the following, which appeared in a recent issue of the San Francisco Call, signed Adeline E. Knapp, will be of interest:—

“I presume that nearly every reader of the Call has at some time in his or her lifetime received a ‘chain letter.’ Judging from the number that I have received of late, this form of pestilence has again broken out in the land. I have accorded these communications a variety of receptions. I have meekly complied with their unassuming request to ‘send ten cents’ (always ten cents) to the deserving object for which the chain is designed to raise a fund, and have selected from among my friends three other victims, and inflicted the outrage upon them, in turn. I have bought off the senders by direct contributions of money; I have cruelly ignored the touching reminder that ‘any one who declines to comply with this request, and does not notify the originator thereby breaks the chain and causes irremediable confusion in the sequence,’ and stony-hearted and regardless of results have consigned the letters to the waste-basket, and I have—

“RETURNED THE THINGS TO THEIR SOURCE, declining to be victimized by their plea, but not until one of these chain letters appeared the other day, asking the donation of ten cents, and the writing of three letters involving the outlay of considerable valuable time and ten cents more for postage and paper—all for the benefit of an orphanage somewhere in the East—did I sit down to consider the true inwardness and significance of a letter of this sort. The request seems so trifling on the face of it. ‘Ought we not help this good work? I have a plan. It is not original, and I ask you to help in it. It will cost you a dime and a little trouble. Each one receiving this letter is asked to make three extra copies of it, sending them to three of your friends, changing only the heading, and putting one number higher at the top. At the same time send this letter, with the names and addresses of your circle of three, and inclosing ten cents, to—etc., etc.’ By the time you have complied with these requests, you have consumed anywhere from an hour to an hour and a half of valuable time. You have written four letters, three of them of good length. You are out the cost of four sheets of paper, four envelopes and four two-cent stamps and ten cents in money. You have, moreover, a sense of having—

“IMPOSED UPON THREE OF YOUR FRIENDS, and are already wondering, depreciatingly, what they will think of you. Judging from your own feeling of resentment toward the sender of your letter, you think you can judge pretty accurately as to what they will think. Your letters all mailed, beyond recall, you begin to wish you had had the moral courage to give the cringing, lying imposition the go-by. ‘Only ten cents and a little trouble,’ forsooth! It has cost you double that amount in actual money, and the trouble, to boot—to say nothing of the loss of self-respect involved and the direct injury to your sense of justice. But the appalling thing about these chain letters is the result that a very little calculation about them will bring to light. This particular one to which I have reference states that it is one of a chain of sixty-four. That does not seem a very long chain. You think, carelessly, that it hardly seems worth while to take that amount of trouble for the small result that will obtain. But consider what this chain of sixty-four means. I have gone through a trifling calculation over it, and the process covers several sheets of paper. It is like the old problem of the nails in a horse’s shoes. Number one of this series is sent out—

“BY THE INITIAL FRAUD, to three people. Each of these three persons, if obliging or lacking in courage to refuse, sends back ten cents, and mails a copy of the letter to each of three other friends, and thus nine letters, each numbered ‘2,’ are sent forth to destroy the peace of mind of nine victims. These nine in turn send out twenty-seven letters numbered ‘3.’ The twenty-seven write eighty-one letters, numbered ‘4,’ and the eighty-one victims in turn select 243 others who shall be mulcted of ten cents in coin—ten cents in value and ‘a little time.’ These 243 receive letter No. 5, and send letter No. 6 to 729 other fellows, who, unless they are stony-hearted and indifferent to the orphan’s cry and the manager’s yearning to accomplish ‘needed repairs,’ will each send ten cents to the aforesaid manager, and write 2,187 letters to as many other innocent men and women, some of whom doubtless never did any harm to any living creature. If there is no one cruel enough to break the chain, letter No. 8 goes to 6,561 unfortunates; No. 9 is received by 19,683, and when No. 10 goes forth, it carries its burden to 59,049 people. The dimes by this time foot up to—

“QUITE A TIDY SUM, and the originator of the scheme has $8,857.20 as interest on his original outlay. I have carried the multiplication of this nuisance up as far as letter No. 26, which is the number of the one that lies before me, and I find that if no one has refused to comply with this simple request, a copy of this twenty-sixth link in the chain has been sent out to 2,493,253,921,329 other people, and if each one who received it remits a dime, the poor little orphans will be able to repair their orphanage to the tune of $249,325,392,132.90, which is quite a comfortable sum, even if you leave off the ninety cents. The letter tells us that there are sixty orphans in this orphanage, and it seems to me the management ought to be able to get along and keep the wolf from the door for quite a spell on the above amount. They evidently think otherwise, for while the above result is on the twenty-sixth letter, they state that the chain will not end until it has reached No. 64. When one considers what that means, one wonders why they end it at all. Why not let it ‘go on forever,’ like Tennyson’s brook, and become a permanent source of income. Now, of course, we know that no such number of letters has been written in behalf of this orphanage, and it would hardly be possible to estimate just what proportion have refused thus to dry the orphan’s tear; but there is no doubt that enormous sums are often received by the promoters of chain-letter schemes.”—Montreal Star.