AdventAI

MORE SUNDAY SOPHISTRY.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 14., April 4, 1893

A PAPER called the Christian Standard recently published an article entitled “Sunday, Sabbath, or Lord’s Day, Which?” wherein the writer attempts, by a sly trick of legerdemain, to transfer all the Bible sanction for the Sabbath to the first day of the week. It is looked upon as a very specious presentation of the subject, and a number of our brethren in the localities where the said paper has a large circulation, request that some criticisms be offered upon it in the REVIEW.

Whatever may be said in this paper in regard to articles that appear in other papers, will, of course, reach very few, if any, of the readers of such papers directly. The only object, therefore, in noticing them here, is to furnish our brethren with some suggestions which may be of use to them as they casually come in contact with the views in question.

The positions which the article in the Standard endeavors to maintain may be briefly but fairly stated as follows:—

(1.) It was not a day, but the Sabbatic institution that was established in the beginning; the Sabbath may come on any day.

(2.) The Sabbath was a part of the Mosaic law, and passed away with that law.

(3.) God has made two wills, or testaments. He may change his will at pleasure. The bringing in of the second will, nullified the first, and nothing is now binding from the first will, covenant, or testament, except what has been brought over into the new. But the seventh-day Sabbath has not been brought over.

(4.) The first day of the week is the day of rest and worship under the new covenant; but with reference to its name there are certain distinctions to be made, as follows: Considered as a secular day, the term, “Sunday,” though of heathen origin, like the names of the other days of the week, is properly applied to it. As a day of rest from labor, the name “Sabbath,” which means rest, is a proper name for it. But as a day of worship, the term, “Lord’s day,” is the name to be used. As a secular day, it is claimed, the Sunday is to be treated as any other day; as a rest day it is a “civil Sabbath,” and may be enforced by the law of the land; and as the Lord’s day, or Christian Sabbath, it is the day of worship for Christians.

The folly of every one of these propositions is apparent at a glance.

(1.) That which was blessed and set apart in the beginning, was not an institution, but a day. It was a day that was rested upon, which made it a “rest day;” a day that was set apart, and blessed, and sanctified. It was the day which made the institution. There was not, and could not be, any such thing as an institution without the specific day. Such an idea is invented and introduced simply for the purpose of sustaining error.

(2.) The Sabbath was no part of the Mosaic law. It was a part of the decalogue, or moral law, which is never called, “the law of Moses.” Hence the passing away of the law of Moses did not affect the Sabbath a particle. The Sabbath was instituted, set apart, blessed, sanctified, and commanded 2,500 years before Moses lived. There is no excuse for confounding it with the law of Moses.

(3.) It is true that the Lord has made two covenants, wills, or testaments; but it is not true that the moral law constituted the first or any other of these testaments, or covenants. This is another specimen of the astonishing confusion which men have suffered themselves to fall into on this question. They would be saved from all this if they would only remember that the law of God, as expressed in the decalogue, in its first, highest, and universal office, is simply an expression of natural, primal, immutable, and eternal principles. Given, God as he is, the creator and ruler, and creatures to love him, and to love one another, and it is impossible to conceive of the absence of these principles. They govern the relation that exists between these intelligences. They are as inherent in them, and as inseparable from them, as light and life are from a state of existence. Love to God includes the first four, and love to our neighbor, the last six, commandments of the decalogue. And there they are, separate and apart by themselves, distinctp. 217 in their own nature; and, in this office, defining the moral relation between God and his creatures, they are a part of no other system of ethics whatever.

But God, in dealing with man in his fallen condition, working out the great plan of salvation, carries forward his purposes on certain plans, establishes dispensations, makes covenants, enjoins services; and in these he may bring in more or less of the principles of his moral law. Indeed, he must do this; for he can do no good thing for man in any age without making it a condition that they shall obey him. That law must be the condition of all his promises. It was the condition of the old covenant. It is the condition of the new covenant. Under the Jewish theocracy it was incorporated into the civil regulations of that commonwealth in such a way that the violation of the commandments was punished by temporal death at the hand of the magistrate. But these dispensations, testaments, or covenants, may change; the relation of the people to their requirements, as such, may change; but that does not in any way change the moral law, nor the position it holds as regulating our moral obligations to God, above and independent of, all these subsidiary relations, primal, universal, immutable, and eternal. This will be clearly seen by considering that if there never had been any dispensations or covenants or anything of that kind, this moral law would still have existed and been binding upon all men just the same. It does not owe its existence to any covenant. This distinction is strangely lost sight of, and even some from whom we might expect a better understanding of this question, seem to fail to grasp it. But when once seen and borne in mind, all this idle talk about a change of the law, or of its Sabbath, on account of passing from one dispensation to another, is seen to be the merest child’s play; and every no-law, or law-changing, or no-Sabbath, or Sabbath-changing, argument, is smitten with a complete and everlasting paralysis.

Now the writer addresses himself to the task of getting out the Sabbath from the new covenant, and putting the first day of the week into its place. He says, “We look in vain for any re-enactment of the great Sabbatic law of the Jews in the new will.” What a foolish idea is this, of re-enacting a moral law in this dispensation! The moral law, as we have seen, can never be changed or abolished any more than the heavens and the earth can cease to exist; hence there is no occasion for any re-enactment of any of its principles. The very conception is idiotic. But we wonder if there is any enactment of the Sunday institution in the new will! Where is it? Where did Christ ever speak of it? When did he ever keep it? When did he rest upon it? When did he sanctify it, to make it a Sabbath? Where have the apostles spoken of it? Where did the disciples ever keep it? There is not a scrap of any such evidence to be found. Yet, such is their wonderful proficiency in theological jugglery that they have no trouble at all in getting the Sunday into the new will, a full fledged Sabbath. But the writer strangely upsets all his own claims when he adds, “The great moral precepts that were contained in the law of Moses are all found in this new will and testament. Indeed, they are all summed up in the two great commandments, ‘Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and thy neighbor as thyself.’” Yes, and these contain the whole moral law, Sabbath and all. On them hangs that law which Christ said he came “not to destroy,” and from which he declared that “not a jot or tittle should pass till all things should be fulfilled” (Matt. 5:17-20), and in that law is the Sabbath, as it was from the beginning.

(4.) The first day of the week. Here he tries to bolster up the fraudulent distinctions which so many are in recent times trying to make. “As a day of rest,” he says, “the first day may be called a Sabbath, and be enforced by the civil law as a civil Sabbath!” Such a claim is shameful sophistry. The State has no such right whatever. Men are born with certain “unalienable rights,” and among these is the right to use and employ their own time as shall be for their best interest. And, especially if God has told in his word how to employ it, as he has done, the State has no right to interfere. To do so, is simply tyranny and oppression. To say that the State may enforce the day as a sanitary measure, for the physical well-being of men, is to say that the State may also prescribe how often a man shall take a bath or an emetic! Away with all this diluted folly about the State’s having a right to enforce Sunday-keeping upon the people as a civil Sabbath!

The claim for Sunday as a day of worship for Christians to be called the Lord’s day, is equally without foundation. He would make out the Sunday to be the Sabbath because it is “a great memorial day,” as was the seventh day. This is a bare-faced assumption. The observance of the first day of the week does not commemorate anything. Christ rose, to be sure, on the first day of the week, but what is there in that to indicate in the slightest degree that the first day of every week should be so observed? Who ever heard of an observance established on the same day of every week, with nothing to indicate a weekly observance? Why not take the day of the week on which the declaration of American independence was signed, and observe that every week in commemoration of our national freedom? Nothing but theology would be guilty of such folly. But why observe it anyway, without any command or instruction for such observance, or any fitness in the practice to commemorate the thing intended? Protestants find themselves in a sore dilemma in this thing. Sunday is an institution of the Catholic Church, and rests on her authority alone. Protestants have retained the institution, but rejected the authority, and so find themselves standing on nothing.

We need not follow this author further. One sample of the way in which he manufactures Scripture will close this paper. In answer to the query how Christian people should properly observe the Sunday Lord’s day, he says: “We are certainly under obligations to observe all that the civil Sabbath enjoins; but in addition to this we are also to do that which is enjoined upon us by the will of God, as revealed to us in the New Testament. We are ‘not to forsake the assembling of ourselves together on that day, as the custom of some is.’”

The reader will notice that the words “forsake the assembling of ourselves together on that day, as the custom of some is,” are put in quotation marks. But if he will turn to Heb. 10:25, he will see how much the apostle has to say about “that day.”

We do not blame them for wanting some Scripture to sustain their position. They badly need it, and should produce it if possible. But we can hardly approve of their seemingly deliberate determination to bare-facedly manufacture out of the whole cloth whatever they cannot find.