Of the comparatively few who can discern the evil results of religious legislation, and who protest against the Church and State meddling with each other’s affairs, the majority do so from the standpoint of present expediency simply, and not from the principle involved, which, if allowed to work out its logical course, will result in not only very great inexpediency, but even in oppression and persecution. While expediency is involved, induction is not always the best process of reasoning. Yet these same persons in their efforts to show the undesirability of such legislation, often expose the impracticability and absurdity of it frequently to a ludicrous degree. Such is the following from “an excited fisherman,” who gave expression to his views in the “Sunday” issue of the Sun, July 2:—
“There are about half a million anglers in the State of New York, who can only enjoy their sport on Sunday, because they are compelled to attend to their daily labors during the week. To attempt to interfere with them in the quiet, peaceful, and retired way in which they practice what is called ‘the gentle art,’ would be an outrage; and in these days, when the working-men evince a disposition to complain often even without just grounds, it is unwise to attack them wantonly in their innocent amusements.
“Section 265 of the penal code is regarded as a dead letter, and very properly, because it is a crazy section, and consequently is not the law. It is the creation of cranks, as any sensible person can see. Look at it:—
“‘All shooting, hunting, fishing, playing, horse-racing, gaming, or other public sport, exercises, or shows upon the first day of the week, and all noise disturbing the peace of the day, are prohibited.’”
“Now before enforcing all this, let us begin by building several new jails, and while we are at it, a lunatic asylum or two, close to the halls of legislation, might not be out of place. There is no hunting in the neighborhood of villages and churches, except perhaps that kind in which the preachers and deacons are past masters, judging from the records of a few years back; and it may perhaps be a legal question yet to be decided whether the Constitution of the United States and of the State, which provide for the right to carry arms and for free fishing, without mentioning anything about Sunday, do not give our fishing friends the right to enjoy their sport and to laugh at section 265. If this is not sound legal doctrine, then we must put into jail all the fellows who shoot on Sunday, who hunt on Sunday, who fish on Sunday, who ‘play’ ball on Sunday, who ‘play’ the piano on Sunday, who ‘play’ the organ on Sunday, who ‘play’ the Devil with the deacons or with the ladies on Sunday, who ‘exercise’ on horseback on Sunday, who ‘exercise’ on bicycles on Sunday, who ‘exercise’ on foot on Sunday, and who make noise by shouting and yelling at revival meetings or other church meetings on Sunday, thereby disturbing the peace of the day.
“Then let us stop the running of the ferries and the railroad cars on Sunday, stop the ringing of all the church bells on Sunday,—many of them are cracked and unmusical,—stop all the clocks on Sunday, and stop the world from going round on Sunday.
“Then our fish and game commissioners will be happy.”
Although this enthusiastic fisherman’s ire was probably aroused because religious legislation interfered this time with his occupation, or pastime, whichever it happens to be, his portrayal of the absurdities to which the spirit actuating such legislation will lead, is at the same time amusing and true. As absurd and ludicrous as it may seem at first thought, it is but the logical and inevitable result of this kind of legislation. Grosser absurdities and greater ludicrousness than these set forth by our fisherman, are embodied in the old Puritanic blue laws. These blue laws are being revived to a considerable extent in Maryland, Massachusetts, and other eastern States in which these laws are retained on the statute books. May we not reasonably expect that worse things than some of those pointed out by this fisherman will soon be not simply mere imaginations and speculations, but realities?
W. E. HOWELL.