AdventAI

SUNDAY LAW AGITATION.

By M. E. K.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 31., August 1, 1893

The agitation over the Sunday-closing of the World’s Fair has had a tendency to try some of the theologies of the day, and determine to what extent people were living up to the denominational standards they have erected. We have taken an especial interest to watch the papers which represent those denominations that hold that the ten commandments are abolished, and that Paul’s words in Col. 2:16 include the Sabbath of the fourth commandment. One of these denominations—the First-day Adventists—have not to our knowledge uttered a word in condemnation of a Sabbath enforced by civil law. They have in the past earnestly contended that every man should be “persuaded in his own mind” in regard to what day he should keep. But they have not said a word about the sin or danger of the government taking away what they have always held to be a God-given privilege. In their anxiety to be considered evangelical, and to be on good footing with the “churches,” they have stultified themselves upon this point in a most surprising manner. We have not heard one voice raised among them in opposition to religious legislation. That men should claim that a Sabbath enforced by the law of God is a bondage that cannot be borne, and then admit the right of the State to command the observance of such a Sabbath, is, to say the least, surprising. But this Sunday agitation has developed many surprising things.

Another body of Christians who take substantially the same ground as those above mentioned, upon the law and the Sabbath, are the Disciples, often called Campbellites. We have been particularly interested in watching the effect that the proposed Sunday exaltation by Congress was having upon them; for there has been quite a diversity of opinion among them. It is evident that there are many among them who have lost sight of the standard of liberty they once followed, and who are quite ready to join the popular churches in their effort to enforce the observance of Sunday by law; but we are glad to note that there are among them many who see danger in such a movement, and who are not afraid to speak their minds freely upon it. The Christian Oracle, which is one of the organs of the Disciples, has opposed a governmental Sabbath. Some of the brethren who had been drinking at the fountain of theocracy, were much displeased, and even stopped their papers. Others wrote letters strongly advocating the national Sabbath idea. This has had the effect to call out others, and lately the Oracle has contained some articles making excellent points upon the subject of religious liberty, which we herewith place before the readers of the REVIEW. They show that while the anti-Christian theory of religious observances commanded and enforced by the State, is working like leaven in the church of the Disciples, there are still some lumps that refuse to be leavened,—some who have a true idea of the relations of the State to the church of Christ. The Oracle of July 13 contained the following article, entitled,—

“ALEXANDER CAMPBELL AND THE SUNDAY ISSUE.”

“If some of our arguments relative to the Lord’s day and its affinity to baptism, the Lord’s supper, and other Christian observances are ‘streaked with insanity,’ as alleged by our good brother, D. R. Dungan, we at least have the satisfaction of knowing that we are in good company, inasmuch as they were used by Alexander Campbell, as the following extracts will show:—

“This same question, only in another form, came up in 1820 in connection with the organization of the so-called ‘Moral Societies’ in western Pennsylvania, a full account of which will be found in ‘Richardson’s Memoirs of Alexander Campbell.’ Among other things, these bodies existed to punish people for reputed Sabbath-breaking, and brother Campbell characterized them as ‘unevangelical, anti-constitutional, and anti-rational,’ and furthermore contended that ‘the whole of the precepts or commands of the Christian religion are contained in the New Testament. But there is no precept or command in the New Testament to compel by civil law any man who is not a Christian, to pay any regard for the Lord’s day, any more than to any other day. Therefore to compel a man who is not a Christian to pay any regard for the Lord’s day, more than to any other day, is without authority in the Christian religion.’ In addition to this, he claimed that ‘the gospel commands no duty which can be performed without faith in the Son of God. “Whatever is not of faith is sin.” But to compel men destitute of faith to observe any Christian institution, such as the Lord’s day, is commanding duty to be performed without faith in God. Therefore to command unbelievers or natural men to observe in any sense, the Lord’s day, is anti-evangelical or contrary to the gospel.’

“Of course these and similar utterances raised a furor, and brother Campbell was denounced as ‘immoral and irreligious;’ this being so, we small stars and minor satellites and such of us as the Apostolic Guide has been pleased to designate ‘evangelical preachers out of color’ can afford to bear a like reproach.”

Another article, entitled,—

“LIBERTY AND THE SABBATH,”

in the Oracle of July 20, upon the same subject, and also referring to Alexander Campbell’s position upon the enforcement of Sunday laws, is worthy of a careful perusal:—

“Civil liberty springs from religious freedom. Christianity tends to make men gentle and obedient, patient and forbearing, willing to concede to all their just rights; and it employs persuasion and truth to accomplish its ends. But a perverted Christianity stirs up envy and rivalry among the clergy, who contend for precedence and power. Under such influences, they impose shackles upon men’s minds by decrees of councils; they abridge the rights of private judgment, make civil government the subservient instrument of spiritual tyranny, and thus destroy civil liberty. It should be remembered that these efforts to make the State subservient to the interests of the Church, have always proceeded from the clergy and from politicians, and not from the people. At the same time it is remarkable with what readiness the people often fall in with the propositions of their religious leaders.”

“People seem to forget that Christ’s kingdom is not of this world, and that the weapons of our warfare are not carnal, and that neither Christ nor his apostles ever once appealed to Cæsar for power to enforce or protect anything that belonged to the kingdom of Christ.”

“As early as 1815, in the county of Washington, Pa., the religious people, who, for the most part, were Presbyterians, formed an association for the suppression of vice and immorality. These societies were called ‘moral societies.’ One of the evils to be suppressed was Sabbath-breaking. Every member was a sort of detective bound to inform against any one found breaking the Sabbath. The whole society was a band of informers. The authority for keeping the Sabbath was the fourth commandment of the decalogue. They had a graded catalogue of fines and punishments, according to the offense committed.”

“The arrest and punishment of non-religious people for violating the Sabbath, stirred up very bad blood among the people. They regarded the operations of this society as an impertinent interference with the rights of conscience, and they resented it, until an antagonistic party was arrayed against the society.”

“About this time, Alexander Campbell appeared in the Reporter, a paper published in Washington, over the signature of Candidus, attacking the principle on which the societies acted; viz., that fining men for their vices would make them moral. In another article he continued his argument, showing that moral societies are anti-evangelical, because ‘Christians are not at liberty to interfere with men of the world in anything pertaining to God and conscience.’ Later he argued the unconstitutionality of the moral societies, because the Constitution gave the right to all to worship God according to their consciences, expressly declaring that ‘no one can be compelled to erect, attend, or support any place of worship, or to maintain any ministry against his consent, and that the observance of the Sabbath, or of any other day, is purely a right of conscience.’”

“Andrew Wylie, president of Washington College, replied to Mr. Campbell, and this discussion continued nearly two years, and it resulted in breaking up these societies, and in turning Mr. Wylie away from Presbyterianism.”

“Mr. Campbell held that ‘there is no precept or command in the New Testament to compel by civil law any man who is not a Christian to pay any regard to the Lord’s day, any more than to any other day, and to do so is contrary to the gospel.’”

“Notwithstanding the failure of the Presbyterians to establish by law in Washington county their views of the Sabbath, another and more general effort was made, a few years later, to get these notions of the proper observance of the Sabbath sanctioned and established by law. ‘For this purpose, in the year 1829, Congress was suddenly overwhelmed with numerous petitions, coming in from all parts of the country, and from various ecclesiastical bodies, praying that the public mails might all be stopped upon the Sabbath day; and every possible influence was brought to bear upon the national legislature in order to obtain the passage of an act to this effect.’ The question was referred to a committee, of which Richard M. Johnson was chairman. Alexander Campbell, it is said, wrote the opinion for the committee. This report was regarded as a remarkable document, ‘and it excited so much interest, and received so much applause, that it was published throughout the country, and largely distributed also in the form of hand-bills which were framed and hung up in dwellings, like a new Declaration of Independence.’”

“Some of the principles of this remarkable document I will here recite:—

“‘It should be kept in mind, that the proper object of government is to protect all persons in the enjoyment of their religious as well as civil rights, and not to determine for any whether they shall esteem one day above another, or esteem all days alike holy.’”

“‘Again: in view of the fact that religious people differ in regard to the day that should be observed, some holding to one day, and some to another, and all on religious grounds, the committee held that government could not require that any one day in particular should be observed, without discriminating against one or more religious parties. The committee hoped that no portion of our citizens could willingly introduce a system of religious coercion in our civil institutions.’”

“‘The report further says: “With these different religious views, the committee is of the opinion that Congress cannot interfere. It is not the legitimate province of the legislature to determine what religion is true or what false. Our government is a civil and not a religious institution. Our Constitution recognizes in every person the right to choose his own religion, and enjoy it freely without molestation. Whatever may be the religious sentiments of citizens, and however variant, they are alike entitled to protection from the government, so long as they do not invade the rights of others.”’”

“‘The transportation of the mail on the first day of the week, it is believed, does not interfere with the rights of conscience. The petitioners for its discontinuance appear to be actuated from a religious zeal, which may be commendable if confined to its proper sphere, but they assume a position better suited to an ecclesiastical institution than to a civil one. They appear in many instances, to lay it down as an axiom, that the practice is a violation of the law of God. Should Congress, in its legislative capacity, adopt the sentiment, it would establish the principle that the legislature is the proper tribunal to determine what are the laws of God. It would involve a legislative decision in a religious controversy, and on a point on which good citizens may honestly differ in opinion, without disturbing the peace of society or endangering its liberties. If this principle is once introduced, it will be impossible to define its bounds. Among all the religious persecutions with which almost every page of modern history is stained, no victim ever suffered but for the violation of what government denominated the law of God. To prevent a similar train of evils in this country, the Constitution has wisely withheld from our government the power of defining the divine law. It is a right reserved to each citizen, and while he respects the equal rights of others, he cannot be held amenable to any human tribunal for his conclusions.’”

“‘Our Constitution recognizes no other power than that of persuasion for enforcing religious observance.’”

“‘The committee was discharged, and Congress did not interfere with the carrying of the mails on the Sabbath.’”

“‘I am opposed to Sunday legislation. It is contrary to our Constitution and to the New Testament. On the same principles, I am opposed to the American Sabbath Association. It is itself anti-American and anti-evangelical. It is the same thing in principle that Mr. Campbell opposed in the moral societies of Washington county, Pennsylvania, seventy-five years ago. I stand by the principles of this great man on this question. In respect to seeking the aid of the State in maintaining its pet notions and institutions, Protestants are scarcely a whit better than Catholics. In seeking the aid of the national legislature to prevent worldly men from “desecrating the Sabbath,” Protestants are doing the same thing they condemn in the Catholics. Both Protestants and Catholics are wrong in this regard, and if either party succeeds, it will bring ruin both to our civil and to our religious liberties. May God defeat them both. Let us fight out the question of religion and of observing holy days, and especially the Sunday question, with the “sword of the Spirit, which is the word of God,” and not with the sword of Cæsar.’”

We will close these quotations from the Oracle by giving an extract from an article in the same paper as last quoted. Like the others, it has a sound ring. We are glad to hear from these champions of religious liberty:—

“‘The Lord’s day is one of holy memories to be sacredly observed and taught. History is full of awful wrong-doing by mistaken zealots desiring to compel the conscience of the noblest of mankind. The unlawful connection of Church and State was oft the cause. If popery was to-day supreme in our country, can we doubt that she would compel submission of heretics and exclude them from all political offices?—No. Have we Protestants in our country who would do the same?—Yes! Nonsense, some leader exclaims, and therefore I quote from an address published this month by a sound Reformed Presbyterian. He declares that ‘the State must receive and apply both tables of the decalogue. This nation should make a constitutional recognition of the authority and law of Christ, and give its pledge to serve him, and that will bring down his spirit, and unite us one composite Christian nationality. (!!!) It should stipulate in the compact that the enemies of Christ be excluded from office, and only his friends be made eligible. And the application of Christ’s law to incoming foreigners would result.’ We shorten the language, in excluding from citizenship all Roman Catholics, Mormons, saloonists, etc., etc.!! O, what a pure state of new fangled scribes and Pharisees there would then be in these United States! The Reverend does not, because he cannot, refer us to any such New Testament instructions of Christ and his apostles; but he is evidently as confident as any priest or pope could be in the traditions of their church.”

“‘American citizens, you neglected slavery until it brought the Civil War! Will you neglect the slavery of millions of citizens to the conscience tyrants who subvert the root principles of the civil government of our country and our Christianity? Tyrants over conscience toward God? Men who would have their church usurp the duties of the State, and use the sword and the jail to compel conformity to their State church! How long would our civil government and our personal freedom of conscience continue under such a régime as would be approved by such Romish or Protestant church and stateism?’”

M. E. K.