AdventAI

THE MINISTRATION OF DEATH.

By W. H. Littlejohn

From Review and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 34., August 22, 1893

BY ELDER W. H. LITTLEJOHN.

  • (Battle Creek, Mich.) *
  • (Continued.) *

“AND such trust have we through Christ to God-ward: not that we are sufficient of ourselves to think anything as of ourselves; but our sufficiency is of God.” 2 Cor. 3: 4, 5.

In the foregoing verses there is nothing difficult. They simply give expression to the apostle’s confidence that the work accomplished in the Corinthians by him as a minister was genuine, and that the glory of the whole transaction belonged to God.

“Who also hath made us able ministers of the new testament; not of the letter, but of the spirit: for the letter killeth, but the spirit giveth life.” Verse 6.

Paul’s sufficiency to perform the work of the Christian ministry was not found in his own natural ability, but rather came from the help which he received from God. He was a minister of the new testament (covenant), so far as its spirit was concerned, though not of its letter. He did not minister the letter of the new covenant; for that resulted in the death of the offender, which death Paul did not execute. That was to be administered by God himself in the end of the world, in the form of the second death.* Rev. 20: 4-9.

Paul, however, was a minister of the spirit of the new covenant, which spirit offered life to all who would enter the covenant of grace. It was the province of Paul as a minister of Christ to offer life freely to all who would accept the terms of the gospel. The spirit of a law is the ultimate intention, or design, of that law. It is not the purpose of the gospel to destroy any one. Its object is purely beneficent. God would not that any should perish, but is anxious that all should be saved. 2 Peter 3: 9. Nevertheless it is true that the preaching of the word is a savor of life to some and a savor of death to others. 2 Cor. 2: 16. It is just as true under the new covenant that “the wages of sin is death,” as it was under the old covenant. Rom. 6: 23. A covenant without a penalty would be an anomaly indeed. The text in hand proves conclusively that the letter of the new covenant inflicts death upon all who set it at naught. I am aware that some repudiate this idea, claiming that the words “the letter killeth,” refer to the old covenant. According to their theory, Paul intended to institute a contrast between the two covenants, speaking of the first as the one that “killeth,” and of the second, as the one that “giveth life.” Such a conception, however, is not warranted by the facts. Of what does Paul say that he was made a minister?—Why, of the new testament, or covenant. It is the new covenant, then, which he is talking about. But what does he say about the letter of the covenant of which he is speaking?—He says that it killeth. The letter of the new covenant then killeth, does it not? Assuredly so, if Paul rightly understood the matter. It would be strange indeed if the apostle, while talking about a covenant of which he was an able minister, should in the same connection go out of his way so far as to declare that the letter of another covenant of which he was not the minister, killed, and then without explanation, whipped back again onto the new covenant, of which he was a minister, saying of it that its spirit gave life. Every covenant has its letter and its spirit, the same as every law. Understand that in the case in hand Paul is discussing the letter and the spirit of the new covenant, and all is clear. Insist that by the “letter” he means the old covenant, and by the “spirit” he means the new covenant, and all is confusion.

The writer has given as much space as he has to verse 6, because an argument is frequently built upon that passage against the perpetuityp. 530 of the moral law. It usually runs like this: The letter which killeth is the old covenant, which condemned to death all violators of the ten commandments. The ten commandments, therefore, have not been brought over into this dispensation, since otherwise it would still be their office work to kill, whereas Paul in 2 Cor. 3: 6 teaches that the new covenant does not kill, but simply “gives life.” Having denuded this argument of all of its force by showing that “the letter which killeth” is the letter of the new covenant and not that of the old, it is time to pass to another text.

“But if the ministration of death, written and engraven in stones, was glorious, so that the children of Israel could not steadfastly behold the face of Moses for the glory of his countenance; which glory was to be done away; how shall not the ministration of the spirit be rather glorious? For if the ministration of condemnation be glory, much more doth the ministration of righteousness exceed in glory.” Verses 7-9.

No-law advocates regard these verses as the stronghold of their doctrine. Their logic is this: The passage teaches that “the ministration of death, written and engraven in stones,” was done away. It was the moral law, or ten commandments, say they, that was engraven in stones;* therefore the latter are done away. At first blush there would seem to be a degree of plausibility in the foregoing deduction. But pause a moment and look into the matter a little more critically. Verse 7 informs us that there was a certain thing, glorious in itself, the glory of which was to be done away. Now let us see if we can find out what that thing was. The key to the whole passage is found in the word “ministration.”

Webster defines that word as follows: “2. Office of a minister; service; ecclesiastical function.” Does such a definition comport with the scope of the passage? Beyond question it does. The ministration, or office, of a minister, was one thing, and that which the incumbent of such an office administered, was another thing. In the case in hand, the ministration of death was so styled because through it the law, the penalty of which was death, was promulgated. Moses, being the first and greatest of the ministers of the old covenant, is in the connection made to represent the whole of the ministry of the Levitical age. That it was the ministry of Moses which Paul had in mind, several considerations will serve to prove: 1. Moses was chosen of God as the favored instrument through whom the tables of the law were delivered to the Israelites. He therefore might properly be said to minister the death penalty of the law. 2. The apostle cites as evidence of the glory which pertained to the ministration of which he was speaking, the circumstance that the “children of Israel could not steadfastly behold the face of Moses for the glory of his countenance.”

There would be no point in this remark unless Moses was a representative of the ministry under consideration. Admit that he did represent the ministry in question, and the allusion to the irradiation of his face was full of significance since, being of a miraculous character, it proved precisely what Paul had stated; i. e., that the ministration of which Moses was a typical representative was a glorious ministration. Having premised thus much, it is time to apply the crucial test to the theory, that the verses passing in review teach the abolition of the ten commandments. If there is any statement which they contain that would support such a conception, that statement must be found in the following words: “Which glory was to be done away.” Verse 7. To repeat: the only declaration found in verses 7-9, to the effect that anything whatever mentioned therein was abolished, is covered by the words just quoted. If, therefore, those words will support the hypothesis that they teach the abolition of the law, it is well with the theory of our friends. On the other hand, if they teach distinctly that it was something entirely separate from the law which they represent as having been done away, then that view must go by the board. Let the test be applied. That something was done away cannot be denied. What was that something? The text reads, “Which glory was to be done away.” It was something, then, in the nature of glory, was it not, that was done away? But what glory is alluded to by the apostle? Was it the glory of the ten commandments? Mark the words again: “Which glory was to be done away.” The pronoun “which” implies an antecedent, or something going before in the connection, to which it refers. Now what was that antecedent? Was it the ten commandments, or was it something else? The connection shows that it was something in the face of Moses. Did Moses carry the ten commandments in his face, or in his hands? If in his face, then there is a bare possibility that they were the thing which was done away. If he carried those commandments in his hands, instead of his face, then by no fair deduction from the passage can it be proved that they were done away, or abolished. See if such is not the case. Here is the full sentence in question: “So that the children of Israel could not steadfastly behold the face of Moses for the glory of his countenance; which glory was to be done away.” What glory was it “which was to be done away”?—Why, the glory that the apostle had been talking about. What glory had he been talking about?—Manifestly the glory in the face of Moses, which was so bright that the children of Israel could not steadfastly look upon his countenance. Then it was the glory in the face of Moses, and not the ten commandments, which, after all, was done away. Is not this matter perfectly clear to your mind, reader? If you understand the structure of the English language but imperfectly, I cannot comprehend how it is possible for you to stumble over this passage hereafter. It was the glory in the countenance of Moses, and not the moral law, that was done away, according to this scripture, as surely as the apostle said what he meant, and meant what he said.†

  • (To be continued.) *

Notes

  1. *It is worthy of remark here that the Levitical priesthood did administer the penalty of the law to a certain extent. Whenever men were guilty of breaking, by an overt act, certain of the commandments as, for instance, those against adultery, murder, theft, Sabbath-breaking, etc., they were authorized to inflict the death penalty. Not so with the Christian ministry. They had no jurisdiction whatever over civil offenders, as such. Their power was exhausted when they expelled criminals from the church. That done, the culprit was left in the hands of God to be punished at the day of judgment. 1 Cor. 5: 5. ↩
  2. *There is a difficulty, real or seeming, which arises from the fact that the original Greek makes it clear that it was the “ministration of death,” and not death merely, which was engraven on stones. Literally the opening clause of the passage reads: “But if the ministration of death in letters engraven in stones, was glorious.” The word “diakonia” (ministry) is a noun in the singular number and feminine gender. The following participle, “entetupomene” (engraven), is also in the singular number and feminine gender, and grammatically belongs to “diakonia,” thus proving that it was the “diakonia,” or ministration, that was engraven on stones. As a matter of fact, this was not literally true. The ministration of death was not inscribed upon the tables of the law. How, therefore, is the difficulty to be removed? Manifestly there is one, and but one, way in which this can be done. Understand that the apostle in the case in hand employed a figure of speech, putting the ministration in place of that in reference to which the ministration was performed, and all becomes clear. Olshausen seems to take this view of the subject. He says, “The entetupomene en lithois [engraven in stones] refers only figuratively to ‘diakonia’” (See also quotations of like import from Alford and Meyer in an article by Elder U. Smith, published in the REVIEW of Jan. 8, 1889. It is to that critical survey of the question that I am indebted for the substance of this note.) ↩
  3. †The grammatical construction of the passage, when examined into from the standpoint of the original, furnishes a striking confirmation of the view of the passage just presented. The following, from the pen of Elder U. Smith, will show that such is the case: “The words ‘done away’ are from a participle, in the singular number, feminine gender (katargoumenen), preceded by the feminine article ‘the’ (ten); literally, ‘the done away.’ This participle must agree with some antecedent word in the passage. Which one is it?—It cannot be ‘ministration,’ for that is too far back in the sentence; it cannot be ‘death,’ for that is masculine; it cannot be ‘stones,’ for that is both plural and masculine; it cannot be the ‘face of Moses,’ for ‘face’ is neuter, and ‘Moses’ is masculine; it cannot be the law (nomos) understood, for that is masculine; it must be some noun of the feminine gender, and singular number; and there is just one such word to which it can refer and that is the word ‘glory’ (doxan) in the preceding clause. Taken together, the sentence reads thus: ‘Ten doxan tou prosopou autou, ten katargoumenen—the glory of his countenance, the done away;’ or that which is done away. Thus when we come to the real, vital point in the passage which law-phobists so greatly desire to find applying to the ten commandments, we discover that it cannot possibly be translated, ‘which tables of stone were done away,’ or ‘which law was done away,’ but only, ‘which glory was done away.’ Nothing here, therefore, about the abolition of the law, or ten commandments.” ↩