Editor “American Idea”: It has not been all fair sailing since Satolli was made American pope. His invested authority of final arbiter of all controverted points that might arise in the hierarchy has not been regarded with that deference by some of the church dignitaries that might be expected. The public have occasionally of late been made aware of an internal disruption by what has appeared in print, the following being about the gist of the matter:—
There are in the American Catholic Church two parties, one more liberal and progressive than the other; and when Satolli came here, his decisions soon marked him as favorable to the liberal wing, of which Archbishop Ireland, of Minneapolis, is the acknowledged leader. This was fully confirmed when he rendered his famous decision reinstating an excommunicated church-member for refusing to patronize the parochial school in obedience to the decree passed at the Baltimore Catholic Council. This incurred the displeasure and antagonism of the opposing party, one of the leaders of which was Archbishop Corrigan, of New York, who, in common with others, saw that if this policy were pursued, a “grave injury would be inflicted” on their educational system. And, indeed, this was true; for immediately following the decision, thousands of Catholic children were withdrawn from the parochial schools, and in one instance it is reported that a certain western school lost three hundred in one week. As the archbishop said, “Can we wonder . . . that the people who have built and maintain these parish schools should be thoroughly alarmed and indignant at such a prospect?”
A halt was called, and the controversy and bad blood engendered called forth a letter from the Vatican reaffirming the binding nature of the Baltimore decrees, and this not only put a quietus on any further action of the kind on the part of Satolli, but it has practically ended the school controversy against Archbishop Ireland, who, it is well known, has sought to step outside the old beaten paths, and establish a sort of hybrid State-and-Church school, known as the Fairbault system, the nature of which all are more or less familiar with. But Archbishop Ireland is a fighter, and a hard one, too, and instead of dropping his pet scheme, he began to advocate it more vigorously than ever. This incurred the increased antagonism of those who were contending for the “old landmarks,” notably among whom was Corrigan, but it also called from the pope, it is alleged (but which has been suppressed from the public), a severe castigation.
Through all this controversy it has been plain to be seen that Satolli was a friend of Ireland, and unfavorable to Corrigan. The matter has come to a head, as it were, within the past few days. For reasons sufficient to him, Corrigan deposed Mr. Burtsell, a friend and counselor of Dr. McGlynn, from his parish, and the case was appealed to Satolli, who ordered that he either be reinstated in his old parish or given another in the city equally as good. This Corrigan refused to do, and upon this refusal, Mgr. Satolli, who has been in the Northwest for some time past, left for Washington, and the Minneapolis Journal of the first instant is authority for the statement that the incorrigible archbishop is to be punished in a very diplomatic way. The wily papal ablegate deems this action necessary; for he sees in this resistance a determination on the part of Corrigan to refuse to recognize his authority. After consultation with his friends, Satolli has decided to go to Rome and lay the matter before the pope, with a recommendation that a coadjutor be appointed to “assist the archbishop of New York in the management of so large a diocese.” This action, if approved by the pope, as it is believed it will be, will thus remove Corrigan from active management of the affairs of the archdiocese. But the head and front of the offending got wind of what was up, and it was reported that he departed for Canada at once, from whence he sailed for Rome for an interview with the Holy See; but later advices say that the report was circulated by his enemies, and that life is made such a burden to him by the fierce opposition that is waged against him, that the indications now are that he will soon resign the diocese over which he has been so long, and retire to private life.
This controversy that has been raised is aptly styled by the New York Sun as “Satollicism vs. Catholicism,” and there is a cry for a little home rule—that if there must be a pope over them in this country, let him be an American, and not an Italian ablegate.
But whatever the outcome of this personal difficulty may be, one thing can be certainly predicted, that the hold that this power has secured on the reins of American government will never be loosened, but rather tightened, and the “Christian world will learn what Romanism really is, when it is too late to escape the snare.” The “vantage ground” she has long desired has been given her. “Men are closing their eyes to the real character of Romanism and the dangers to be apprehended from her supremacy.” “Her doctrines are exerting their influence in legislative halls, in the churches, and in the hearts of men. She is stealthily and unsuspectingly strengthening her forces to further her ends, when the time shall come for her to strike,” and “the people of our land need to be aroused to resist the advances of the most dangerous foe to civil and religious liberty.”—W. E. Cornell, in American Idea.