AdventAI

“BABYLON IS FALLEN.”

By D. H. Lamson

From Review and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 36., September 5, 1893

BY ELDER D. H. LAMSON.

(Lincoln, Nebr.)

A few years since, I heard a prominent minister of the Methodist Episcopal Church say, “If any one asks you if Adam was the first man, tell them you don’t know. If any one asks if the flood covered the whole earth, or only a small part of Asia, tell them you don’t know. If any one asks if the great fish absolutely swallowed Jonah the prophet, tell them you don’t know; and if any one asks if you really believe there ever was a man by the name of Job, with the actual experiences related of him in the Bible, tell them you don’t know.”

A recent article in the Detroit Evening News, shows progress for Michigan Methodism in this matter of “higher criticism,” as follows:—

“Poor old Job, as an historical personality, was annihilated yesterday by the Methodist ministers without a protest from a single mouth. The old book itself opens with the distinct and unequivocal assertion that there was such a man. ‘There was a man in the land of Uz, whose name was Job; and that man was perfect and upright, and one that feared God, and eschewed evil.’ James afterward assumed the truth of the narrative, and said, ‘Ye have heard of the patience of Job, and have seen the end of the Lord.’ The ministers discussed the old patriarch yesterday, and concluded that the book that bears his name is mere poetical tragedy like Goethe’s ‘Faust,’ and that Job himself had no actual existence. Many of the men of this meeting were taught that Job was a character who lived long anterior to the days of Moses, and that the history of Job, probably written by himself or a contemporary, is the oldest piece of literature extant. Now here is a pointer for Dr. Briggs: Here in Detroit are a body of learned and godly gentlemen who are not afraid of a little freedom of criticism. When there is so little suggestion of difference between Briggism and Detroit Methodism, it does seem as if the distinguished Presbyterian heretic ought not very long to remain lonely.”

It is becoming a popular theory that the “unwritten word,” as it is called, is of greater consequence than the book called the Bible. “The great apostasy” has not completed but is fast accomplishing its work. When Protestants fully grasp the Romish idea, it will not be hard for modern prophets to interpret the word in harmony with modern ideas; and there are as great a multitude of prophets now as in the days of Ahab, who will dare to prophesy in the name of the Lord. Dr. Lyman Abbott, in Plymouth church, Brooklyn, N. Y., June 4, 1893, said: “It was not Dr. Briggs that was heretical, but the stand taken by the general assembly was one whose logical result was infidelity.” He spoke of the battle which has gone on from the days of Moses down to the present time, between the ecclesiastic and the prophet; the one maintaining that the institution is the essential thing, and the other that the individual, personal life is the essential thing, and there could be no religious institution without it. That is, that the true word grows out of man’s inspiration and man’s need, and not from the authority of God and the eternal fitness of things, not only to men but to and for all created intelligences.

This is in harmony with another statement by another prominent Presbyterian, in the synod recently held at Hillsdale, Mich.,—that all the work of God in the gospel was for man, for man’s upbuilding, for man’s ennobling, for man’s exaltation; and the bosom swelled with conscious pride, and the form dilated, and many seemed to feel the man-god spirit, as man was glorified and beatified. In my own heart I acknowledged it all to be the work of Christ, and peace like a river came into my soul.

Dr. Briggs was charged with heresy in the assembly that tried him. “Heretic!” exclaimed Dr. Abbott.

“What is heresy? For one thing, it is to declare that God is not the Father of all mankind, and leaves no door of access to himself, save the one door of a written word that was not completed till the human race had longed and cried and prayed to their Father for two thousand years. In your name, and in the name of them that believe in a living God dwelling in the hearts of his children to-day, I thank this prophet [Dr. Briggs] successor to the prophets of olden times, that in these two years of cruel trial, he has never receded from his one position, never used words in a double sense, never retracted his one assertion, but has stood firmly and faithfully, against persuasion on one hand, and attack on the other, for his fundamental principle that God is in the heart of the individual and in the heart of his church, as revealed in the pages of the Bible. ‘The Bible is not the word of God,’ and repeating almost the words, and certainly the sentiment, of Dr. Horton, who lectured last year before the students of Union Theological Seminary,—‘I charge any man who calls the Bible the word of God, to find that phrase “the word of God” ever employed in the Bible to designate the Bible, or even employed in one part of the Bible to designate any other part.’ When a man takes the book,—that is, what men have written [the Bible],—puts it up and says, ‘You must not hear the word of God [that is what the modern prophets say]; you must only hear the echo of that word [that is the Bible],’ I don’t wonder that misplaced indignation goes out against the book which the would-be defenders are misusing.”

Truly we have fallen on peculiar times, when the individual is above the Bible, his interpretations and his inspirations above the written word. “Believe in the Lord your God, so shall ye be established; believe his prophets, so shall ye prosper.”