[Designed for the consideration of such questions as will be of interest and profit to the general reader. All correspondents should give their names and correct post-office address, that queries not replied to here, may be answered by mail.]
344.—FORBIDDEN AND PERMITTED.
I do not understand Deut. 14:8, as compared with 1 Tim. 4:3–5. Please explain the same. Mrs. J. H.
Answer.—Deut. 14:8 was spoken to the Jews. It was a part of the Mosaic system. The distinction between clean and unclean meats followed, in general, the law of hygiene, those kinds being pronounced unclean which were especially unhealthful; but it contained some features not based on this law, as in the scripture under notice. If a man touched the dead carcass of a swine, he was counted unclean; but it would not particularly endanger his health to touch it. So that law was not wholly governed by the question of the healthfulness or unhealthfulness of the objects in question. But that system was done away at the introduction of the Christian dispensation. There is now no distinction based merely on the Jewish law of clean and unclean meats. But there is a distinction still existing. It is now, however, based wholly on the law of hygiene. Whatever is healthful may be used; and whatever is not so, is to be scrupulously avoided. When Paul says to Timothy that “every creature of God is good, and nothing to be refused,” he certainly cannot be understood to recommend the eating of snakes or poisons, or using tobacco or whisky. He simply refers to distinctions which had formerly prevailed, and leaves us free to choose, without reference to that, such things as will be for our good, knowing that one would naturally avoid that which is repulsive, and ought to be conscientious enough to shun that which is injurious.
345.—AARON’S ROD AND THE MANNA.
In the REVIEW of Oct. 10, p. 636, at the foot of the first column, it is stated that the pot of manna and Aaron’s rod that budded were placed in the ark of the Lord; and Ex. 16:33, 34 and Num. 17:10 are cited in proof of it. But does it not appear from Num. 17:4 and Ex. 30:6 that the rod was placed where it budded, and that the same language is used in regard to the altar of incense that was used about the pot of manna? These articles were placed outside or by the ark of the testimony, the object being that they might be seen.
J. E. R.
Ans.—The language referred to in the REVIEW, was used on the authority of Paul, who, in Heb. 9:4, positively states that the pot of manna and Aaron’s rod were in the ark, the same as the tables of the covenant. Our correspondent makes no effort to show that Paul’s language means other than what it expresses. The language of Num. 17:4 is not exactly parallel to that of verse 10. The first says, “Lay them up in the tabernacle, before the testimony.” The other simply says, “Before the testimony.” Ex. 30:6, which speaks of the altar of incense, is altogether different. It says, “Thou shalt put it before the vail, that is by the ark of the testimony,” etc. There is nothing in these texts to forbid the idea that in the time of Moses, of which Paul speaks, the ark did contain the pot of manna and Aaron’s rod. And the statement of 1 Kings 8:9 confirms this idea. That states that when the ark was brought into the temple built by Solomon, there was nothing in the ark but the two tables of stone. Why make a special mention of this fact, if the ark had never contained anything else but the two tables of stone? The very language implies that the ark had at some time contained something else, but that a change had been made, and that it was worthy of notice that it then contained nothing but the two tables. In the article in the REVIEW of Oct. 10, reference was made to “Early Writings,” p. 26. In a view of the sanctuary in heaven, we there read this concerning the ark: “In the ark was the golden pot of manna, Aaron’s rod that budded, and the tables of stone, which folded together like a book.” To those who have confidence in the statements of “Early Writings,” this will explain what disposition had been made of the pot of manna and Aaron’s rod, and why they were not in the ark when it was finally placed in the temple of Solomon.