AdventAI

IN THE QUESTION CHAIR.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 41., October 17, 1893

[Designed for the consideration of such questions as will be of interest and profit to the general reader. All correspondents should give their names and correct post-office address, that queries not replied to here, may be answered by mail.]

340.—PREACHING TO THE DEAD.

How is Peter’s language, in 1 Peter 4:6 to be explained, when he says, “For this cause was the gospel preached to them that are dead,” etc.? F. G. S.

Answer.—It does not read that the gospel was preached to them during the time they were dead, or after they were dead; but the gospel was preached to them while they were alive; and though they are now dead, their cases will come up in the judgment, just the same; for a record was kept of all their deeds, and from that record they will be judged, as if they were men in the flesh.

341.—REPENTING UNDER THE PLAGUES.

Please explain the last clause of verses 9 and 11 of Revelation 16. If probation has then closed, how can that fact be harmonized with the idea of their repenting, to give God glory, etc.? S. D. H.

Ans.—The very fact that they do not repent under such judgments as are then falling upon them, is evidence that probation has then closed. Always, when there is hope in a man’s case, the judgments of God tend to lead him to repentance; but when there is not, then they only make him harder, as seen in the case of Pharaoh and others. So we understand that those declarations are thrown in there, not to show that there was a chance for repentance, but to show that the time for that had passed, as indicated by the fact that they had no disposition to turn to God even under his most terrible judgments.

342.—CIVIL GOVERNMENTS.

Have purely civil governments any right to exist? If so, should they be so conducted that a true Christian could engage in any and every department of its work? Should civil governments prohibit the running of governmental works on the Sabbath? If not, should a Christian engage in the postal service on the Sabbath? C. L. P.

Ans.—Governments established for the purpose of regulating civil affairs have no right to be anything else but purely civil governments. There is nothing to debar a Christian from taking part in any legitimate work of the government. Christian Daniel served in the courts of Babylon and Persia with acceptance to the government and no detriment to his religion, and even Nero had some good Christians in his household. All men ought to be Christians, and if they were, there would be no others but Christians to conduct the affairs of civil government, and all governments should be conducted just as true Christian men would conduct them, for, “A ruler should rule in the fear of the Lord.” 2 Sam. 23:3. He should be a terror to evil works, not to the good, and be a minister of wrath against those who do evil. Rom. 13:1–6. But all this, of course, in the domain of civil affairs, not religious. In this case the government would have nothing to do in regard to forbidding governmental works on the Sabbath, for that would regulate itself. When the Sabbath came, there would be nobody to work, as no Christian could engage in the postal, or any other service, on the Sabbath. And all business and traffic could be arranged so that nothing but works of absolute necessity and mercy need to be performed on that day. But what the government has a right, or not a right, to do, does not affect an individual’s Christian duty, or his obligation to God. He cannot violate his conscience, though the government gives him permission, or even commands him to do so.

343.—CHRIST ON EARTH AND IN HEAVEN.

How could Christ be on the earth and at the same time in heaven, as seems to be stated in John 3:13? Z. G. B.

Ans.—When Christ made to Nicodemus the declaration found in John 3:13, he was discoursing to him in regard to heavenly things. He wished him to understand in reference to heavenly things;p. 651 but he asks how he will believe him when he speaks of these heavenly things, when he does not believe what he said about earthly things. Then he says that no man has ascended up to heaven, that is, to bring back instruction to men in regard to what is there. This does not contradict the ascension of Enoch and Elijah; for that was not the purpose of their ascending; and they have not come back to instruct the world in regard to heavenly things. But he says the Son of man came down from heaven, referring to his incarnation. He has been there, and hence can tell authoritatively all about heavenly things. And moreover, his knowledge is such that it is just the same as if he was even then personally in heaven. So far as his knowledge of heavenly things was concerned, and his ability to impart to them instruction concerning them, it was the same as if he were there. And, indeed, in spirit and knowledge he was then, and always, there.