AdventAI

THE PUNISHMENT OF THE WICKED.

By L. A. Smith

From Review and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 41., October 17, 1893

BY L. A. SMITH.

(London, Eng.)

God has declared, “The soul that sinneth, it shall die.” Is this an arbitrary decree, imposed upon the sinner by the Omnipotent, because he has the power to impose it, and wishes to feel the satisfaction of having retaliated upon those who have transgressed against him? Or is it a declaration of the inevitable sequence of sin, according to principles that are immutably fixed in God’s government, and into which there enters no element of retaliation or gratification of desire for revenge?

We confess to having been greatly shocked at an article which has recently come under our notice, in which the passions of a fallen and depraved nature—retaliation, spite, revenge—are represented as attributes of the Ruler of the universe. It is always shocking to see the label “God” put underneath a picture of the Devil; and the effect is not in any way lessened when the picture appears in the midst and by the side of truths which belong to the everlasting gospel. It is, however, but one among many illustrations of a sad truth; namely, that the sin-darkened minds of men naturally and easily invest the great Creator, the God of love and mercy, with their own depraved human attributes, which are but the attributes of Satan himself.

From the beginning of his rebellion, Satan has sought to put himself in the place of God. Failing to do this in heaven, he endeavored to accomplish it on the earth. He overcame Adam, dispossessed him of his estate, the earth, and implanted in his nature the seeds of rebellion against God. But God interfered, and put enmity between the seed of the woman and that of the serpent, and opened the avenue to heaven, which sin had closed. He gave man a revelation of himself, and established his worship in the earth, so that all might still become his subjects. Then Satan sought to enthrone himself in men’s minds and in their worship in the place of God, by giving them a conception of God which was but the representation of himself; and this plan he has followed, with much success, down to the present day. Man has worshiped and served a being whom he has clothed with the attributes of his own fallen nature; and the result is most perfectly seen in the degraded worship and superstition of the heathen, which have “changed the glory of the uncorruptible God into an image made like to corruptible man, and to birds, and four-footed beasts, and creeping things.” Human conceptions of God are infinitely below the reality. A god which possesses the characteristics of human nature is no higher or better than man himself.

God is revealed to the world in Christ; and the life of Christ was a continual declaration that “God is love.” And God was in Christ, reconciling the world unto himself. So far from feeling a desire to retaliate upon the sinner when he had sinned, he thought only of how man might be brought back and re-instated in the place from whence he had fallen. The covenant of grace, the everlasting covenant, was in the mind of God from the beginning. God is omnipotent, and therefore can do whatever he desires to do. If therefore retaliation had been “a principle in God’s nature,” as it has been said, there would have been in his mind a desire to retaliate when man had sinned against him, and no power in the universe could have prevented retaliation from coming. Man would have been immediately destroyed, and earth’s history would have ended where it begun. But in the great heart of infinite love there was—and is—no such principle to be found; and to this mighty fact we who are living to-day owe our existence here and our hope of the life to come.

God is not the enemy of man, but his best and greatest friend. God has no controversy with man. He is continually beseeching them to be reconciled to him. 2 Cor. 5: 19, 20. God’s controversy is with sin. He hates sin, but loves sinners (not because of their sins, but in spite of it). It was for sinners that he gave his Son to die. Was this the spirit of retaliation? When did such a spirit ever move to deeds of love and kindness? When did love and retaliation ever travel in company? Who ever found it possible to obey the injunction, “Love your enemies,” while harboring that spirit in his heart?

Yes, says one, but does not God retaliate upon the wicked in the great executive judgment, at the end of the thousand years? After they have slighted his mercy, and probation is past, and nothing remains but to deal with them according to their iniquities, does God not take vengeance upon them then?—Yes; “the day of vengeance of our God” will surely come; but “is God unrighteous who taketh vengeance?” Is God’s vengeance like man’s vengeance? Will he in that day be actuated by the spirit of a man seeking revenge? Are his ways man’s ways?—No, verily. The vengeance of Omnipotence is the justice of Omniscience. Who ever knew human vengeance to aim at justice? Who ever knew a man animated by the spirit of retaliation to be satisfied with paying back to the offender no more than what he received? The spirit that says, “You strike me, and I’ll strike you” always returns a harder blow than the one that was given. If it does not, it is only because it lacks the power. So while there is nothing wrong about the idea of justice, there is something radically wrong with the idea of retaliation. The one is an attribute of God, necessary alike to the wicked and to the good. The other is an attribute of Satan, and the very essence of selfishness.

God is unselfish, the universe has been a long time witnessing the demonstration of this fact, and the process is still going on. Selfishness is the charge made by Satan against God, and the question thus raised is the point around which the great controversy rages. And the full demonstration of the falsity of Satan’s charge will not be reached till the very time when the last great judgment is poured out. Then the mask behind which the Devil works, will be torn completely off, the falsity of his claims will stand fully exposed, and then, from a universe fully convinced will ascend the mighty anthem, “Blessing and honor, and glory, and power, be unto Him that sitteth upon the throne, and unto the Lamb forever and ever.”

What is the purpose of the great work of investigation in which the saints will engage with Christ for a thousand years after their ascension? Is it to find out how much punishment must be given to the wicked,—to ascertain something which will be till then unknown?—No; for God will know at the outset just how much each one has sinned, and what each should have. That investigation will be for the benefit of those who participate in it, and this number will include all the universe, saints, angels, and the inhabitants of sinless worlds. It will be a grand review of the history of this world, in which will be traced out the dealings of God with sinners, and their course toward him—toward his dispensations of love and mercy, and his offers of pardon for iniquity. And when the grand review is finished, the wisdom and goodness of God’s dealings will be fully comprehended by all. The saints themselves pronounce sentence upon the wicked, and the judgments which God executes are only those which his saints have determined.

Man has implanted within him a natural feeling for retaliation. If he had not, there would be no fights and brawls in the street. But when men engage in such things, they are not giving opportunity to the manifestation of a divine principle stirring within them. At least, the writer has never been so impressed during such occasions of this kind as he has witnessed. On the contrary, the principle of retaliation acting in their hearts is seen in all its deformity, stamped with the imprint of the Devil.

God is love. His name is, “The Lord, the Lord God, merciful and gracious, long-suffering, and abundant in goodness and truth, keeping mercy for thousands, forgiving iniquity and transgression and sin, and that will by no means clear the guilty.” “The fruit of the spirit is love, joy, peace, long-suffering, gentleness, goodness, faith.” No place here for the spirit of retaliation. No; but it has a place among the works of the flesh. (See Gal. 5: 19, 20.) Who ever knew the spirit of love to desire to retaliate? And why is it that God “will in no wise clear the guilty”? The question is almost superfluous. Who would want a God that would clear the guilty? There is enough of that kind of work done in the earth to make even sinners long for a change. God cannot clear the guilty, and be just to the righteous. Justice to the sinner is also justice to the saint; for God will not condemn his saints to live in a universe which holds something so hateful to them as sin.

It is with sin that God has his controversy. Every sin must be dealt with, from the very first to the last that will ever be committed. God cannot permit sin to exist. The universe cannot admit of two rulers so diametrically opposite in nature; for where sin exists, sin rules. The universe is God’s, and since he is omnipotent, he will control it in every part.

The death of the wicked is their wages; and the payment of wages is not retaliation. Itp. 647 is their due because they have earned it. It is the only thing for which they are fitted,—an inevitable consequence of their own course, taken by their own free choice. God’s presence must fill his universe. They would not let it fill them, and therefore the only thing to be done is to destroy them.

The “lex talionis” of Moses is cited as a proof of the divine origin of the principle of retaliation, but such a citation does not prove the utility of talions in the economy of God’s government. The same law was once cited to Christ in evidence of the virtue of writs of divorcement, but Christ said it was but an evidence of hardness of heart. He also said, “Ye have heard that it hath been said, An eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth: but I say unto you, that ye resist not evil: but whosoever shall smite thee on thy right cheek, turn to him the other also.” And again: “Ye have heard that it hath been said, Thou shalt love thy neighbor, and hate thine enemy. But I say unto you, Love your enemies, bless them that curse you, do good to them that hate you, and pray for them which despitefully use you, and persecute you; that ye may be the children of your Father which is in heaven: for he maketh his sun to rise on the evil and on the good, and sendeth rain on the just and on the unjust.” This was Christ’s comment on the “lex talionis,” but in the writer’s opinion it is the best that has yet been given.

Therefore we conclude that the judgment of God upon the wicked is not only “not merely (!) spiteful retaliation,” but that it is totally and altogether separate and distinct therefrom; and that in the character of God, as seen in all his dealings with man, there is not one single trace of any principle that is Satanic.