IMMORTALITY NOT A BIRTHRIGHT, BUT A GIFT FROM GOD

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Oct 24, 1893

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 42.

Read the full edition

IMMORTALITY NOT A BIRTHRIGHT, BUT A GIFT FROM GOD.

BY ELDER W. H. LITTLEJOHN.
(Battle Creek, Mich.)
(Continued.)
We have now gone the round of the six texts, in which, alone, the words “immortal” and “immortality” are mentioned in the Scriptures. From them we have learned: (1) That God only among all kings is immortal (1 Tim. 1:17); (2) that immortality is a thing to be sought after (Rom. 2:7); (3) that this mortal must put on immortality (1 Cor. 15:53); (4) that immortality will be put on at the resurrection of the dead (verse 54); (5) that Christ brought immortality to light through the gospel (2 Tim. 1:10); (6) that God only hath immortality. 1 Tim. 6:16. It is not necessary to go outside of these texts to reach the conclusion that the natural immortality of the soul is a fiction. A doctrine which is so squarely antagonized by the only texts which mention directly the attribute which it claims for man, must be mythical in its character.
It would seem superfluous, after what has already been said, to discuss the question of natural immortality from the philosophical standpoint; nevertheless, I have decided to devote to it a little space. To begin with, it should be stated that nine out of every ten systems of philosophy, which have hitherto commanded the respect and secured the adhesion of the greatest and even the best of men, have been exploded and abandoned. It is with great caution, therefore, that one should build his faith in the doctrine of the undying nature of the soul, upon the deductions of logic, pure and simple. Every doctrine which is true, is necessarily philosophical; but it is safer to test philosophy by the truth, than it is to test the truth by the merely human philosophy. “Thy word,” says Christ, “is truth.” John 17:17. The word of God, therefore, is the touchstone by which all questions relating to the spiritual nature of man should be tried. That touchstone in ages past was applied in turn to the philosophies of Plato, Aristotle, and the other Greek sages of the early times, and they were found to be utterly worthless. If systems of philosophy formulated in an age peculiarly adapted to philosophical thought, and developed with the greatest care by minds of the rarest capabilities, paled before the rising splendor of the gospel of Jesus Christ, how futile it is to expect a better fate for the purely intellectual deductions of our time, when revelation has so largely taken the place of speculation.
As already seen, the Scriptures declare emphatically that God alone has immortality. He, therefore, who would undertake to prove the immortality of the soul of man, from the standpoint of philosophy, must overturn the word of God before he can achieve his purpose. Under these circumstances we have a right to expect that the arguments which he will advance shall be of the clearest and most conclusive character. If they are not, they would not be worthy of a passing thought in view of the Scriptural argument already made. If the writer justly apprehends the situation, the candid seeker after truth will be astonished at the utter weakness of the argument of those who maintain that the deathless nature of the soul can be demonstrated from the reasonable point of view. To show that such is the case, a few of the more weighty among their arguments will be briefly touched upon.
1. It is urged that the universal desire of men for endless life is evidence that this desire must have been inborn and, therefore, that it will ultimately be gratified. But pause a moment before indorsing this conclusion. Is it the case that every desire found universally in the human heart, is destined, sooner or later, to be realized? What is the basis of the desire under discussion? It is not for life merely, without reference to the condition of that life, is it?—Certainly not. Where is the human being, for example, who would crave an endless life made up of nothing but excruciating agonies? Such a person could not be found among rational beings. Thousands of suicides are occurring every day, where no physical torment is involved as a provoking cause, the object of the unfortunates being wholly that of getting rid of a life, which, from social surroundings, has become intolerable. No; if men universally desire life in the hereafter, the life which they crave is one where, as they believe, there will be joys and pleasures without alloy. Is there such a life for all men? If so, Universalism is substantially correct, and the Bible is a fraud. Are you ready to adopt this conclusion? Would you reject the teaching of the Scriptures, and take in its place a chimerical notion, that because men desire a thing, it follows as a matter of course that their wishes in the particular in question will be gratified? All men desire riches, honor, ease, and power in this world; nevertheless, there is not one in a thousand who ever reaches the fruition of his hopes. The same God who made this world is the author of the world to come.
Revelation aside, we know literally nothing about the latter. With the former we have a practical acquaintance, and understand its conditions thoroughly. Logically speaking, therefore we are shut up to the conclusion that in the world to come (if there is to be such a world), as in the one which is, there will be a mixture of good and evil, joy and misery. This is so because it is natural to infer, the author of the two worlds being the same, that the condition of both, morally speaking, would be similar, if not identical. Such being the case, the theory that the desire of men in this life furnishes a just measure of the order of things in the life to come, is utterly overturned from the logical standpoint. This is so, since the future which they desire is one of unmixed good, whereas the only one which can be inferred from our present surroundings, is one where joy and sorrow, vice and virtue, good and bad, will be commingled. All that the general desire for immortality could possibly be forced to prove, is that such a thing as life hereafter, under certain conditions and limitations, is devoutly to be wished, and therefore comprehended, perhaps, in the plan of Him who gave to the human soul its legitimate aspirations and ambitions. The limitations and conditions, as well as the eternity of being in question, are all provided for in the gospel through the gift of endless existence to all who accept Christ and purify themselves from sin. Those who will not comply with these terms, will find, and ought to find, their aspirations for eternal life delusive and visionary. The Scriptures say that without holiness “no man shall see the Lord.” Heb. 12:14. Reason indorses this conclusion as sound; for to perpetuate the life of the sinner through the eternal ages of the future would be a misfortune to him, and insure an endless blot upon the universe.
2. An argument akin to the one just discussed, is based upon the claim that the great majority of mankind in all ages have believed in the immortality of the soul. It is sufficient to say, in replying to this argument, that the claim upon which it is based is not true. If the doctrine of the soul’s immortality has any significance whatever, that significance lies in the circumstance that it insures the survival of the spirit of man as a distinct individuality throughout the cycles of eternity. Those nations, therefore, who have not believed in such a survival as this, cannot be said to have been believers in the natural immortality of the soul. The myriads of India, for example, who hold that the souls of men are finally absorbed into the being of the first great cause of all things, can by no just principle of logic be classed with those who indorse the tenet in question. Believing, as they do, in the ultimate merging of all minor individualities into the one individuality of the Creator, they virtually deny one of the fundamental doctrines advanced by those whose opinions are antagonized in this article.
Besides the class just mentioned, there are millions upon millions of the human family who unhesitatingly avow the doctrine that there is no conscious existence beyond the grave. This is not only true now, but it always has been true. Among the Greeks and the Romans there were whole schools of philosophy with whom the final extinction of the soul was a clearly-defined and openly-declared opinion. In the less enlightened portions of the pagan world of the past, the same view was largely entertained. At one time in the history of the French nation the legend, “Death Is an Eternal Sleep,” was written over the gates of the cemeteries of the land. This could never have been done had the conviction in question been intuitional in its character. It is worthy of note right here also that even those who in the past have nominally adhered to the future life of the soul, have always experienced serious misgivings upon the subject. Cicero was full of doubts on the question, and Seneca truthfully said that “immortality, however desirable, was rather promised than proved by these great men.” In view of these facts, what shall be said of the strength of the conviction in question in the minds of the masses? Can it be sufficiently well defined and strong to justify its use as the corner-stone upon which to rear such a stupendous structure as that of the deathless nature of the soul?
(To be continued.)