THE RELATION OF THE CHURCH TO THE STATE

9%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Oct 24, 1893

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 42.

Read the full edition

THE RELATION OF THE CHURCH TO THE STATE.

[Of the many articles which we have lately noticed upon the subject of the relations of the Church to the State in this country, the following, which is an editorial from the Union Signal, organ of the W. C. T. U., is the best we have seen. We hope that when the principles of religious liberty upon which the American theory of separation of Church and State are based, shall be attacked by attempts to make and enforce laws for the observance of Sunday, the Signal will remember what it has said upon this subject, and that it will stand up for religious liberty and the separation of the Church from the State in a practical, as it now has in a theoretical, way:—]
“Render therefore unto Cæsar the things which are Cæsar’s; and unto God the things that are God’s.” “My kingdom is not of this world: if my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight.” In these words Christ struck the keynote of his attitude toward the temporal power of his time, and we believe, of what should be the attitude of his church toward the temporal power. It was an attitude which alienated from him many of his immediate followers, and which finally cost him the allegiance of his nation. Mistaking it, his later disciples have made their most grievous errors.
As the reward of obedience to Jehovah, the Jewish nation was promised autonomy and earthly prosperity; subjection and ruin overtook them (the prophesied penalty of their broken faith), and language is exhausted to image forth the glories of the Messiah’s kingdom who should come to deliver them from their foes. Their whole conception of a victorious, all-conquering nation was of a theocracy. At the coming of Christ the expectation of the people was fixed upon a temporal king. Overlooking the necessary spiritual condition upon which all the promises were based, they looked forward with assured confidence to the glorious reign of the King of kings, who should deliver them from the hated rule of their conquerors. He came, but refused the crown they were so eager to press upon him. They crucified their king, and with him all their hopes.
Had the Jews as a nation accepted the humble teacher whose doctrines dashed all of their hopes, the turbulence and rebellion which ended in the destruction of Jerusalem, and the exile of the nation, would have been subdued, and out of the ruins of the Roman empire, filled with the life which animates Christian nations to-day, Judea would have become the greatest world power that had yet existed. But, blinded by their visions of an earthly conqueror, they turned aside from the glorious future that opened before them, and to-day Israel wanders over the face of the earth, the outcast of nations.
But the mistake which Israel made, Christians have been prone to follow. It is very hard for our human nature to learn that no real conquest (outside the realm of mere material things) is ever made by force; that mind can be subjugated only by ideas. Impatient of the slow progress of the doctrines of Christ over the hearts and minds of men, Christians have striven to hasten these conquests by force. Like the 5000 whom he fed in the wilderness, the would-be followers of Christ have been determined to take him by force, and make him a king after their own petty conceptions of kingship. But the kingdoms set up “in his name” serve only to emphasize his refusal of an earthly crown.
The whole history of man’s attempt to unite Church and State is one long illustration of the truth, “My thoughts are not your thoughts; neither are your ways my ways, saith the Lord. For as the heavens are higher than the earth, so are my ways higher than your ways, and my thoughts than your thoughts.” In the name of Him who bade his followers turn the other cheek to the person who smote them upon one; to love their enemies and pray for their persecutors; whose last miracle of healing was performed for one of the mob that came to drag him to his doom, and upon the cross prayed for his murderers,—Christians of whatever name, when temporal power has been the ally of the church, have silenced those who differed from them, with torture and death. So, too, when man would establish a universal kingdom, fire and sword, torture and death, are his instruments for bringing his fellow-mortals under his supremacy. Time passes, conspirators murder this king of rebellious subjects, or he is forced to yield to the superior prowess of some greater conqueror.
God, too, seeks a universal kingdom. The stone cut out of the mountain without hands is destined to fill the whole earth. But no such ephemeral sovereignty over unwilling and rebellious subjects meets his requirements. His kingdom is an everlasting kingdom; of the increase of his government there shall be no end. But a kingdom thus secure from conspiracy and dissensions cannot be established by any methods known to men. Force can neither create nor maintain it. It must be sustained by willing subjects, and the king refuses all others. The only chain which can bind the subjects of his kingdom is the chain of love. The king wore the chain, and earned his right to the unwavering allegiance of his subjects by giving his life for them. Having been lifted up from the earth, he waits patiently until the great sacrifice shall have drawn all men to him.
We may well long for the coming of that kingdom so unlike anything that men have ever set up. Its glories we cannot overestimate. We cannot but dimly picture the blessedness of the reign which will inaugurate unbroken peace on earth, good-will to men. But we shall only hinder its coming, if we seek to hasten it by man’s methods, if we arbitrarily unite Church and State. The past and the present clearly prove that these attempts only injure the cause they seek to aid. The Jews in their bitter resentment of foreign rule would have none but a temporal king for their long-looked-for Messiah. They scorned the gentle doctrines of him who sought to turn the hearts of the people away from their earthly aspirations to God. They closed their ears to his words, “Seek ye first the kingdom of God, and his righteousness; and all these things shall be added unto you.” The Prince of peace was no prince for them. They crucified him, and with him perished also their hopes as a people. So the Christian church, whenever it has sought first the things that come only as the fruits of the kingdom of God, when it calls to its aid the power of the State, and would compel men’s allegiance by force, has defeated itself. We have happily outgrown the age of savage persecution, yet still in the union of Church and State the church suffers only loss.
God has made man a free moral agent. He who knows the nature he has made, leaves his creature free even to defy his Creator. Man must choose God freely, must serve him voluntarily, else the service is not accepted. And man thus endowed with freedom, instinctively claims his birthright, and resents any attempt on the part of his fellow-man to deprive him of it. Hence when human law demands of him allegiance to a power whose reign is primarily over the spiritual forces of his nature, and which derives its prerogatives from the unforced dictates of his own conscience, he rebels. That is a domain over which human law has no rightful authority.
“The kingdom of God cometh not with observation.” Because it is the kingdom of God, it must be set up in God’s way, not man’s. To serve its interests we must seek to learn God’s ways. We can hasten its coming not by linking it to earthly powers and potentates, nor by bringing to its defense armed hosts and the murderous implements of warfare, but by living and proclaiming its truths until the little leaven shall leaven the whole lump. Only thus, by the glad surrender of each individual soul, can the kingdoms of this world become the kingdoms of our Lord and of his Christ.—Union Signal.