AdventAI

IN THE QUESTION CHAIR.

By Editor

From Review and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 47., November 28, 1893

[DESIGNED for the consideration of such questions as will be of interest and profit to the general reader. All correspondents should give their names and correct post-office address, that queries not replied to here, may be answered by mail.]

346. — LIBERTY TO EAT ALL THINGS.

While our Saviour was with his disciples here upon the earth, he had occasion frequently to chide them for their slowness in comprehending what he was trying to teach them. Thus he would often say to them, “How is it that ye do not understand?” And on no subject did they seem more dull of perception than that of eating and drinking. The same tendency still seems to adhere to the human mind, judging from the communications we receive, and the ideas that are occasionally expressed by our correspondents. Thus a letter recently received says: “As we are taught that we are at liberty to choose anything that we wish to eat, how do you explain Isa. 66: 17, in regard to eating swine’s flesh?”

We respond, “How is it that ye do not understand?” We are not at liberty to choose whatever we may eat. The REVIEW has never so taught. Isa. 66: 17 speaks against eating swine’s flesh. The REVIEW speaks against it also. So there is no disagreement, and nothing to be explained as between us, so far as touching the use of that particular article of diet is concerned. But has not the Jewish law, which classed certain meats as clean, and others as unclean, and forbade the eating of the unclean, been done away?—Yes. And doesn’t that give us liberty to eat all of those kinds of meat which were there forbidden?—Not by any means; for there is another law, which both antedated and survives the Levitical economy, which forbids us to use the swine, and many other things as food; and this is the law of health. The swine is not a proper article of food, and the lawp. 749 of health says that we therefore should not use it. The Jew refuses it because his law forbids his eating it. We refuse it because the law of health forbids our eating it. We both arrive at the same result, only on different grounds. How is it, therefore, that you do not understand? Every kind of food which would inflame and vitiate the blood, and fill the body with humors, and all narcotics and stimulants, the law of health forbids to all men. But there are other things which the law of health forbids to some men, but permits to others. That is, there are some things which some can use to advantage, which are very detrimental to the health of others. Such things the latter class should carefully avoid, while the former could use them. In such cases the language of Paul in Rom. 14: 3 would apply: “Let not him that eateth despise him that eateth not; and let not him which eateth not judge him that eateth.”