AdventAI

IN THE QUESTION CHAIR.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 38., September 19, 1893

[Designed for the consideration of such questions as will be of interest and profit to the general reader. All correspondents should give their names and correct post-office address, that queries not replied to here, may be answered by mail.]

337.—JOSHUA’S LONG DAY, AGAIN.

Referring to what has been recently written upon this subject in the REVIEW, a correspondent says that a circular has fallen into his hands, in which the writer, though himself admitting that it was only one day, affirms that the Jews claim that it was two days, which would affect the chronology of that period. To which it is sufficient to reply, that such a claim is pure assumption. The Jews would not go contrary to their own record, and that record says as plainly as need be, that it was only one day. Josh. 10:14: “And there was no day like that before it or after it.” It does not say there were no days like them, before them or after them. In view of such a record, therefore, it is absurd to say that any Jew would claim that it was two days instead of one day.

338.—ALL SCRIPTURE INSPIRED.

In addition to what has already appeared in the REVIEW on 2 Tim. 3:16, further explanation is asked on the following point: The word “scripture” is that word which literally means “writing.” Hence, “all scripture,” would be “all writing.” How, then, are we to know what is meant by that word, as it would evidently not be right to say that all writing, referring to everything that has been written by any one, is inspired. And, secondly, why is not the idea suggested by the Revised Version correct, that all Scripture, given by inspiration of God (or that is given by inspiration of God), is also profitable? etc.

To which we reply on the first point, that those writings which were regarded as revelations from God, came to have appropriated to themselves the words “the writing,” “the word,” “the book,” etc.; so that whenever such terms were met with, it was known definitely what was referred to. We have an illustration of this in 2 Peter 3:16, where we read: “As also in all his epistles, speaking in them of these things; in which are some things hard to be understood, which they that are unlearned and unstable wrest, as they do also the other scriptures, unto their own destruction.” Here the same word is used, literally, the “other writings.” But the reference is only of course to this class of writings, which was well understood. In the case before us, in 2 Tim. 3:16, Paul in the previous verse has thrown in a qualifying word, which removes all ambiguity from this text at least. He says to Timothy, “Thou hast known the holy Scriptures.” This word “holy” was never applied to any writings but those which were esteemed the sacred writings. These are therefore only what he refers to, in verse 16.

On the second point we remark that the idea which some draw from the Revised Version is not correct. To say that all scripture (that is) given by inspiration of God, is also profitable, would not be a complete sentence; for the statement contained in these words, “also profitable,” is a direct, declarative, sentence; but the other is only a hypothetical sentence, and these two cannot properly be connected by the word “also.” There must be some direct statement preceding this word as well as following it. If it said, “All Scripture given (or that is given) by inspiration of God, is profitable,” that would be a correct use of language, and the construction would be complete. But, as has been heretofore explained, there is the little word “and” (Greek kai) in there, which is acknowledged on all hands to be genuine, and which must have its place, and, further, which changes the whole construction of the sentence. It does not alter the case any to translate that word (kai) by the word “also,” as in the Revised Version.p. 599 The fact is, we have a sentence with two members, in neither of which is there a verb expressed, but in both of which a verb must be understood; and that verb must be such as to make both members of the sentence direct declarations, not leaving one of them direct, and the other hypothetical. The only correct construction is that given in the Common Version: “All scripture (is) given by inspiration of God, and (is) profitable,” etc. This that was written to Timothy referred only to the Old Testament, as that is all there was then in existence. But Peter’s language, quoted above, shows that the New Testament also comes in under that designation of “the Scriptures,” and the meaning of the declaration is simply this, that all those writings which God by his providence has caused to be brought into this world, as the revelation of his will to man, known by way of distinction as “the writings,” “the word,” “the book,” are all “God breathed,” and are profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, and for instruction in righteousness. It is not well to try to discriminate between portions of what is known as the Scriptures, treating some parts as inspired, and others not. A keen observer has well said, “Let any man try to make his life conform for a week to the plain teachings of the Bible, and he will be thoroughly convinced of its inspiration.”