A HIGHLY esteemed friend in Vermont writes to know if we do not think “that as large a thing as the World’s Fair should have love and honor enough for the Creator of all things to close its gates one day out of the seven, and as Sunday is the day that is almost universally kept, is not that the day for them to be closed?”
This is certainly a fair and frank question, and we will try to give as fair and frank an answer. First, we will say that Sunday is not kept as a Sabbath by but a small portion of the people of this, or any other country. Even among professed Christians, it is as much of a holiday as it is a Sabbath. Many church-members, after service, spend the remainder of the day visiting friends, and in other pursuits as inconsistent with the proper observance of the Sabbath as a visit to the Fair would be. To the majority of the people of our country, Sunday is nothing but a holiday. The thought of God, or of his service, or of the reason that they do not labor as on other days, does not once enter their minds. The farmer looks after his cattle, counts his sheep, mends a few gaps in the fence, and does various other little things that have been neglected during the bustle and hurry of the week. He hitches up his team, and goes to see his friends, or to see a colt that he thinks will match the one he has got. In the towns and cities, twenty spend the day in idleness, often in dissipation, where one goes to meeting. They go to the beach, to the park, to the ball game, and other places for change, rest, and recreation. They do not keep Sunday as a Sabbath, but spend the day in idleness and pleasure. Idleness is not particularly pleasing to God. It is not Sabbath-keeping. We have known many men, who, if they had labored every day in the week, it would have been better for them, for their families, and for the State. Every day of idleness was ap. 597 curse to them, rather than a blessing. It therefore being an indisputable fact that to the majority of the people of this country Sunday is nothing but a holiday at best, and to many, a very hurtful day, because of the way they spend it, it is also a fact that the Fair would be just as good a place for this same majority to spend Sunday, as other places they are bound to frequent, and to many people a much better place. No one was compelled to go Sunday, and the directors made provision for their help so that no one had to labor more than six days in a week, much as the railroads do in regard to such matters.
Second, We repeat what we have many times declared, that we have had no more objection to the Fair being closed on Sunday than we have to a man’s closing his store on Sunday, if it was done by the proper authority. We objected to the action of Congress in the matter, because, (a) it was an interference in the affairs of the sovereign State of Illinois, which Congress had no constitutional right to touch, and, (b) because it was in behalf of a religious doctrine, of one religion,—the Christian religion,—and Congress is forbidden by the Constitution to make any law “respecting an establishment of religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” Congress would have just as much right to prohibit the opening of the Fair on the Jewish passover or the Mohammedan feast of Ramadan, as to prohibit people from going to the Fair on the Christian Sunday. Congress knew this, and therefore did not attempt to do it directly, but tried to hire the directors to close, by giving them out of the people’s money, $2,500,000. This money did not belong to Christians alone. It belonged to all the people, the majority of whom keep Sunday simply as a holiday. Many thousands have no faith in Christianity. It was paid in the interests of a religious idea believed in by only a portion of the people. For this reason we objected to it, and it is no cause for wonder that such tricky legislation, which attempted to do in an underhanded manner what they had no right to do, should fail of its object.
Third, It is not the business of the government of the United States to “honor the Creator.” Our government was not organized for that purpose. The first paragraph of the Constitution reads thus: “We, the people of the United States, in order to form a more perfect union, establish justice, insure domestic tranquillity, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.” These are the objects sought by the Constitution and the government which it created. It will be noticed that they are all objects that belong to this life.
Our government was designed to make men comfortable and happy here. Honoring God or the future life does not enter the Constitution. That is left for each individual to do for himself, as he thinks proper and right. This wise provision gave us religious liberty. It separated the Church from the State. If the government should attempt to honor God, it would have to prescribe the way, and this would at once open the way for a national religion. But as our government was organized, every person has a right to be religious or not religious, as he pleases. So if any person believes it would honor God to do or not to do any particular thing, he has the right to do or to refrain from doing, unless he interferes with the civil rights of others. Those who believe that it will please God if they stay away from the World’s Fair on Sunday, have an undoubted right to exercise that privilege, but they have no right to compel any other person to refrain from going who desires to spend the hours at the Fair that he generally spends in recreation in the park or at the beach. We simply uphold the Christian and American idea of liberty of conscience in this matter.
Finally, Sunday, although not used by all the people in a religious way, is based upon a religious idea; it grows out of the relation that we sustain to God, and not out of that which we sustain to our fellow-men. It is therefore not a proper subject for legislation, and the majority have no right to dictate to the minority in regard to it. To compel a person by law to keep Sunday, is the same as it would be to compel him to be baptized or to partake of the Lord’s supper. Any compelled service or act of religion, even if right, is neither pleasing to God nor beneficial to the person performing it. God seeks those to worship who worship him in spirit and in truth. Those who thus serve the Lord will not seek to compel others to serve him, nor to influence the government to make laws restricting the religious rights of the people. They can reason, urge, plead, and implore, but beyond this they cannot go. Any violation of this gospel rule destroys man’s free moral agency in his relations to God, puts man in God’s place, and establishes a spiritual tyranny over the consciences of men. These, in brief, are the reasons why we have opposed a government-authorized Sabbath and its necessary accompaniment,—a government-established religion.
M. E. K.