AdventAI

“WHAT SONG BOOK SHALL WE USE IN OUR SABBATH-SCHOOL?”

By F. M. Wilcox

From Review and Herald, Vol. 70, No. 40., October 10, 1893

BY ELDER F. M. WILCOX.

(Oakland, Cal.)

This is coming to be a frequent question of late with some who have wearied of our present collection of sacred songs. It is argued that our present Sabbath-school singing-book, “Joyful Greetings,” is too small to answer the demands of a longer period of use, and that to awaken and maintain desirable interest in the song service of the school, a new collection of hymns and tunes is needed. There may be, we are willing to admit, some argument in these considerations for a change of singing-books, provided that in the new book chosen exist all needed qualifications to make its use safe and proper. But we should be very unwilling to admit that the above considerations, or any others that might arise, would furnish sufficient ground for the introduction into our schools of song books published by other denominations than our own.

The varied collection of song books published by our people would certainly make such action as that wholly unnecessary and unwarranted. For if the songs found in “Joyful Greetings” are “worn out,” the excellent hymns contained in the “Song Anchor” can be brought into use. And if any of our schools have exhausted all of the songs contained in both of these books, which we think is quite improbable, our church hymnal, “Hymns and Tunes,” could be taken up for present use. In fact, some of our schools have always used our large hymn-book, or selections taken from it, since its first publication, and they sing its hymns and tunes to-day with greater zest and appreciation than ever before. Here, then, we have three song books published by our own people, or recommended by them, from which to provide music for our schools. It would certainly seem that these were sufficient for present needs, or until some new collection shall be published, without looking to other publishing houses for supplies.

But there is another phase to the question of using outside song books, which to our mind transcends in importance the ones already noted. While it is entirely unnecessary in view of the books published by our own houses, it is wrong and impracticable to do so. We all know something of the errors of doctrine commonly held in the world to-day, and of the relation they sustain to Bible truth. These false doctrines are not preached alone from church pulpits, but are as freely and quite as effectually taught inp. 631 the popular hymnology of the times. Few indeed are the song books which are free from these errors. None have we ever found outside of our own denominational books, which are free from these failings. Shall we place these errors before our youth and children, and not expect them to be contaminated thereby? Surely we cannot do so.

But some may inquire, “Do not many of these books, as for instance, ‘Gospel Hymns,’ contain many excellent and soul-inspiring songs?” We answer unhesitatingly, Yes. But alongside of these same excellent songs, are others full of errors and misleading doctrines. Unconsciously are we led on step by step. Association with error makes it appear less dangerous, and ere we are aware of our departure, we will find ourselves singing with as much zest and earnestness, but not, however, to the glory of God, the song containing the admixture of error, as we sang the song that harmonized with Bible truth.

Quite as well, it seems to us, might we drop our good church paper, the REVIEW AND HERALD, and go to taking the church paper of some other denomination. We can find many journals published by the great religious world, which contain much excellent matter. But we would not wish, certainly, to place these before our children for constant perusal. For in connection with the good instruction they contain, are advocated many false doctrines and misleading theories.

Or by the same logic of reasoning, why might we not as well drop our own Sabbath-school lessons, and use in our schools those prepared by the International Sunday-school Lesson Committee. We would find many rich gems of thought and truth, presented by some of the most talented writers of the day. But this, too, would be inconsistent; for while these lessons would contain many good things, they would also teach doctrines which we could not accept as the truths of the Bible, and many of our children and youth, and unconsciously we ourselves, would be affected by the same. But why object to the one, and accept the other. The same underlying principle of right obtains in the matter of song books and the study of lessons. One perhaps may be a greater perversion of a right principle than the other, but both must be considered from the same standpoint.

We cannot afford to place before our youth and children, or even before ourselves, that which leads from Bible purity and simplicity. Every hymn sung in the Sabbath-school should be sung to the glory of God. Every move made and action taken with reference to the singing, should be done with direct reference to its influence upon the hearts and minds of our brethren and sisters. We might be able to discriminate between good and evil, and by the Lord’s help to choose the good, but the question should not be one with reference to ourselves alone. Are our brethren and sisters able to do it? Are our youth and children able thus to discriminate? As parents and teachers, let us watch jealously the eternal interests of the souls committed to our watch care. Some day we must render an account of our stewardship.

We understand that a new song book for Sabbath-school use is already in process of preparation by some of our leading workers. This we shall be glad to welcome. But until it appears, whether its publication be speedy or long delayed, we trust that our schools may be able to find in our own song books that spiritual instruction and satisfaction which it is their privilege to draw therefrom.

In answer, then, to the question, “What song book shall we use in our schools?” we answer without qualification, use some book published or recommended by our own denomination, and none other. “Joyful Greetings” is to be preferred. It was designed for Sabbath-school use. But if any of our schools feel that they cannot longer content themselves with that, let them take up again for awhile the “Song Anchor,” or use for a time our regular song book, “Hymns and Tunes.” There is a smaller collection published, “Selections from Hymns and Tunes,” which may be obtained very cheap. Let us stand by our own denomination, and what we believe to be the inculcation of right principles, in music and singing, as well as in every other line of duty in church and school work.