GATHERED THOUGHTS ON THE FIRST EPISTLE OF JOHN.
By August Kunz
CHAPTER III.—VERSES 4–15.
VERSE 4.—Any transgression of the law was considered an abomination by the Jews; but the Gnostics maintained that unchastity, avarice, pride, etc., were not transgressions of the divine law, nor displeasing to God. But John, as well as sacred writ in general, designates them all as sins, so that he can say, “Whosoever abideth in him sinneth not,” and “whosoever is born of God doth not commit sin.” VERSE 5.—The Lamb of God (John 1:29) not only takes away the sins of the world, but will also remove the power of sin and the uncleanness which binds us in it, and will keep us from sinning, by fellowship with him. In the sentence, In him is no sin, the word “sin” cannot mean a sinful nature, but must mean “transgression of the law.” Hence any one who is in Christ, cannot be in a state to transgress the law. VERSE 6.—A correct understanding of this verse, in harmony with the context, is here of special importance. The usual explanation—“Whoever abides in a spirit of prayer, confidence in, and devotion to, Christ, will not be overtaken by sins of weakness, but will walk in an especial measure pure and holy”—would exclude all that ever committed a sin of weakness or ignorance, from the experience of having known or seen Christ in any sense; but that conflicts with 1 John 1:9; 2:2; 3:19-22; 5:16. According to that view, there never have been true Christians; for all confess to having repeatedly committed sins of weakness, sometime or other in their Christian life; i. e., after their conversion and regeneration. We must remember that John wrote against false teachers, who laid claim to an exalted and abiding fellowship with God, and yet continued in known and open sins. The verb “sinneth” is in the present tense both times, which signifies, in the original, a continual sinning; and to sin, according to the definition of the Scriptures (1 John 3:4), is to transgress the law of God. That John aims in this verse, primarily, to warn true believers against false and deceptive teachings, and against teachers who, by high professions and boasted experiences, live in known sin, is proved in verse 7, being a repetition of verse 29, chapter 2. (See comments on the latter, in a previous article.) In verse 8, John makes still stronger statements: Whoever continues in known sin (present tense, denoting continued action) does not have life and power from God, but is of the Devil, and stands in his service and power; for sin does in no sense whatever come from God, neither does he want it. Satan originated it; but Christ came, by his death and resurrection, to deliver men from the dominion of sin and the Devil, and to destroy Satan’s kingdom and works. Hence no one is a member of Christ’s kingdom, who does not let himself be delivered and preserved, through Christ, from the dominion of sin. VERSES 9–11.—To be born of God cannot here mean either conversion or regeneration, unless it be in their perfected, or completed state. It signifies our living in Christ and in God. But in this mortal state such a life is one of utter dependence. A converted believer that is purified in Christ, is not in or of himself a cleansed old man; hence not a citizen of the kingdom of heaven, only by virtue of his being in Christ, the head and firstborn of every creature. Hence we may read: He that has fellowship with the Father and the Son; he who abides in Christ, and has both seen and known him (by faith and experience); he who walks in the light, or, as Paul puts it, is crucified and risen with Christ, will not sin. The “seed” is the word of God. Such a definition of the text harmonizes with all the other Scriptures on that point. Out of Christ all lie in sin and death (Eph. 2:3) and the power of the Devil; but only he can realize and know this who has experienced the new and divine life in Christ, in the light from above. But the unconverted man cannot perceive this, even though he walk to the best of his knowledge and conscience; hence it is unreasonable and unkind, as well as conducive to wrath, to have a converted man tell the unconverted, “You are a child of the Devil.” Again, within the pale of Christianity are many who have grown up in the principles of Christian truth, and have, in many respects, allowed themselves to be influenced in the direction of the divinely good, so that they have many Christian virtues about them, and still they have not reached the point where they have wholly died to self, and risen in Christ Jesus. But as long as he is not yet thoroughly converted, and taken into the fellowship of the death and resurrection with Christ, so long Satan and this wicked world have still power successfully to attack and govern him, and bring him to fall. 1 John 5:18. The doing of righteousness is chiefly to “walk in love,” just as the righteousness of God is the revelation of his love. (See Rom. 3:8-11; Gal. 5:14; John 13:34; 14:15; 15:2.) The apostle shows that this was the gist of the gospel message, as far as their walk was concerned, from the first. And this first, or chief requirement, as it were, is love for those of like precious faith, rather than love toward our fellow-beings in general, for the latter seems to be more an outgrowth of the former than anything else. 2 Peter 1:7. This love was to them a life in Christ and in the brethren, as fellow-heirs with them of the kingdom of God. VERSE 12.—Cain is here cited as a specimen of an apostate believer, who has become a child of the Devil. He is a prototype of the selfish, proud, self-righteous man, who is angry with, and persecutes, the humble believer, who has the testimony of God that he has forgiveness of sins, and walks acceptably before him. (Compare Heb. 11:5.) VERSE 13.—The world hate Christians as naturally as darkness is opposed to light. They do not understand them, and feel condemned by their own conscience, at the sight of the God-like walk and conversation of the true believer, whose example of abstaining from worldly amusements and all false worship, reproves them. But true Christians, on the other hand, should not needlessly embitter them, but act wisely and judiciously, by treating them with love and forbearance, under all circumstances. VERSE 14.—John gives in this verse, love for the brethren as a sure sign of our being in the light. Whoever does not really love the brethren in Christ, or whoever, professing Christianity, nevertheless oppresses them, supposing that because he sees opportunities for doing so, he has a perfect right to oppress them; whoever is not willing that they should fully enjoy the liberty necessary for the prosperity of their inner life; whoever mocks and derides them in any wise, or unites even with worldly persons and despisers of true Christianity, against the humble followers of the meek and lowly Jesus, may otherwise have many good qualities, and may even show zeal and self-denial in certain Christian works; but for all that, he remains, according to John, in a condition of death, in his old self, and possesses neither the life nor the love of the kingdom of heaven. VERSE 15.—If we do not love our brother, which is of itself a sure sign of spiritual death, this lovelessness soon passes, under temptation, into hatred; and whoever hates his brother is a murderer. The last sentence deserves special attention. One may at some time have eternal life, and yet that life may not abide in him, because he allows hatred against his brethren to spring up in his heart. AUGUST KUNZ.