AdventAI

Your Boy and His Books

By Mrs. I. H. Evans

From Review and Herald, Vol. 94, No. 8., February 22, 1917

MRS. I. H. EVANS

A FEW months ago we reprinted in these columns an article written for a well-known magazine by Walter Pritchard Eaton, entitled “Your Boy’s Books.” In it the writer set forth some of the dangers of the books which, formerly appearing in their true colors as “dime novels,” “yellowbacks,” and “nickel thrillers,” now masquerade in cloth covers, prettily stamped, and often well printed and illustrated, as respectable and desirable books for the child whose parents would have been horrified to see him reading them in their true guise. Parents and teachers by the thousand buy these books for their sons and pupils for no better reason than that they appear attractive to the casual examination, and may be bought for a price that appeals to the purse.

Would you like to know what one who has written a large number of such books has to say of them? In the December issue of the Ladies’ Home Journal a man who calls himself “A Dime Novel Writer” tells how he came to enter this field, and why he abandoned it. Fathers and mothers who do not know what their boys are reading will find food for sober reflection in the following excerpts from his “Confession:” —

“I have been a maker of sensational fiction, mostly for boys, for many years. I have written half-dime novels, ‘nickel weeklies,’ paper-covered ‘library’ books sold for fifteen cents, and boys’ stories to be bound in cloth and sold for twenty-five cents. It is these latter books to which I wish especially to call attention. Altogether, I have written of such ‘thrillers’ more than one hundred and twenty-five titles. They are all of the type of story that long ago was condemned under the term ‘dime novel.’ Because of this output, I feel I can qualify as an expert on ‘dime novels.’ And because my sense of decency finally rebelled at the writing of them, I propose to tell what I know about such stories.

“I wish to show how they are bought—tens of thousands of them—by people who don’t know what they are buying, conservative people who give them to their sons and daughters freely, Sunday school teachers and church people who would be shocked at the accusation that they are buying ‘dime novels’ for their children.

“I began to write thrillers because I needed the money. I am a college man and a newspaper man. I traveled over this country and a good part of Europe gathering material for a book I wanted to write. I spent five years in travel and study—and then I wrote my book. It took more than a year. But it was a failure, and there came a time when I must earn money at once.

“I got into touch with one of the ‘paper-cover’ book houses, as they call the publishers of ‘dime novels’ in the trade. They liked what I submitted, and I was told to write a detective story of thirty thousand words, and show what I could do. The result was that I was hired to grind out thirty thousand words each week in return for a weekly salary of fifty dollars. So I became a writer of ‘dime novels.’

The Publisher’s Instructions

“The letter telling me that I could consider myself on the publisher’s staff also told me that a batch of books was being forwarded to me, and gave me some instructions. Among them were some paragraphs about like these:— “Read the sample books carefully, that you may familiarize yourself withp. 14

the characters run in the series. For instance, one of the detectives is a ventriloquist, and makes use of his power to trap the men he is after.

“‘A live story has something happen at least every thousand words. Remember to emphasize the fact that crime does not pay, and that punishment always overtakes the wrong-doer.’

“‘Never make a hero of a criminal. If you attribute a good act to a bandit, offset it by saying something like, “How fine a man he would have been had he turned his abilities to honest pursuits,” or, “He was not bad at heart, but had been driven to a life of crime by circumstances.”’

“Now please note that, (1) the publisher knew his stories were likely to suggest crime, and make it look attractive to youngsters; and (2) he therefore deliberately tried to put in something to correct that tendency.

“The stories suggest mean, bad motives to impressionable young people. How far they are responsible for crime I cannot say. I have run across one startling piece of testimony, however. On a trip through the underworld, made in the company of a city detective while I was in search of local color, I was introduced to one of the most expert safe-breakers in the United States. In the course of our conversation that worthy volunteered the information that he and his kind eagerly read detective stories for new ideas and ways to turn their tricks!

Fit for Any Home

“But there is further proof that these publishers are aware that their crime stories are bad for youngsters. For every such house has one or more series that those in the office habitually speak of as ‘good series.’ In their advertising to sell these ‘good series’ the stock phrase is, ‘These stories are fit for any home,’ which may be taken as an admission that their other series are not fit for any home.

“Out of these so-called ‘good series’ have been developed twenty-five-cent books bound in cloth that sell by the hundreds of thousands. The chances are that you have some of them in your house.

“Now the chief difference between the ‘half-dime novel’ and the ‘good series’ in paper covers, is that the former deals with criminals and their capture or with ‘Wild West’ thrills; while the latter deals with boys in school or in business, in travel, in history, or adventure. If the story is about business life, the hero, a poor but honest lad with boundless ambition, starts in as an office boy. He soon makes an enemy, a dishonest office boy or clerk; and then it is a battle of wits between the hero and the villain. They resort to all sorts of tricks and devices; the dishonest boy does not hesitate to commit crime in order to trap the hero; and the hero, the humble office boy, does not hesitate to rebuke any one, up to the president of the concern, in order to prove himself right. In the end he usually marries the president’s daughter.

“For the school story the only difference in the setting is that the scene is laid in the school or in a summer camp, or on a trip to some foreign country instead of in the business office.

“Eliminate the school or the business setting, and you practically have the ‘half-dime novel.’ The hero takes the place of the detective; the bad boy, the criminal. Instead of cracking a safe, the bad boy steals books or examination questions, and hires thugs to beat his rival. The hero first suspects his enemy, then spies upon him, and finally traps him. All the excitement and thrills of the ‘half-dime novel’ are ‘rung in,’ no situations are impossible, and, of course, the hero always comes out on top—in accordance with the publisher’s instructions ‘that crime does not pay.’

“One other notable difference between the ‘good series’ and those that cannot be called ‘good’ is that in the back of the latter are advertised handbooks on how to make love, for example, apparatus for practical jokes, powders to make people sneeze or to cause itching, etc. . . .

A Decline in Profits

“Now the business of publishing paper-cover thrillers, ‘half-dime novels,’ began some years ago seriously to decline. There have been several causes for this. The first break came when the low-priced magazines—some of them issued by the ‘paper-cover’ publishers themselves—were put on the market. People soon found that they could get more for their money in buying such a magazine than they could in a five- or fifteen-cent ‘library.’ As a matter of fact, whereas before they received only one story for their money, each magazine contained a dozen or more short thrillers and two or three exciting serials.

“Then there has undoubtedly been an awakening of the public conscience brought about by the persistent work of organizations, supplemented latterly by public libraries and the best of the popular publications devoted to women and the home.

“Another factor against the cheap trash is the moving picture show. More nickels than ever are spent for thrillers, but it is even more exciting to see a dare-devil action than to read about it. The moving picture magazines also are now bought by thousands of women, young and old, who used to spend their money for the fifteen-cent ‘library books.’

The Disguising Cloth Cover

“But American boys and girls still get trashy, harmful stories. The price and the form are changed, that’s all. Instead of sensational, cheap, improbable stories in paper covers that your boy had to read on the sly, if at all, you may be buying the same thing for him, and encouraging him to read it—in harmless-looking cloth covers.

“It began when publishers of stories in cloth saw a new market for cheap books. Most stories for young people were then made to sell for a dollar or more. These publishers, however, bought from the ‘paper-cover’ houses some of their so-called ‘good series,’ and brought them out at fifty cents, in cloth. They are still sold, though the price is now twenty-five cents.

“The success of this kind of book—a wolf in sheep’s clothing—was immediate. But the stories were old. The next step was the publication of new stories, of a similar exciting character, first at fifty cents, later at twenty-five. To make these books the publishers naturally sought the writers who had been turning out the ‘half-dime novels,’ whose market in paper covers was dwindling, and who were therefore glad of the new work. This was how I came to write ‘twenty-five-cent juveniles.’

A Fiction Factory

“One of the old nickel-novel men, after writing many of these new juvenile books under his own and other names, got a new idea. The houses that were publishing cheap cloth juveniles demanded more stories than he could write himself. So he formed a ‘syndicate’—a ‘fiction factory’—to manufacture this product. He employed many of the old producers of nickel thrillers, myself among the others.

“As I had obtained my work on the strength of having turned out paper-covered thrillers, the instructions for writing twenty-five-cent juveniles presupposed my knowledge of the technic of building ‘dime novels.’ So it was not necessary to show me how to write the story. I was cautioned, however, against producing sensational situations too often,—the old rule was once every thousand words, you will remember,—and told to moralize frequently.

“Descriptions of killings, fights, or of the commission of serious crimes were to be entirely avoided. If my story called for a killing, by Indians, bandits, miners, or anybody, I was merely to lead up to it, and then later state the fact as accomplished. The same was to apply to fights between schoolboys, or ‘our hero’ and any one else. I was told the fights must not be described by rounds or even graphically. I was to lead the characters to the spot, start them going, and then tell who won, and go on. . . .

Stock Models

“You see, then, the chief differences between the old ‘dime novel’ and the twenty-five-cent juvenile I write about, lie in the imagination of the buyer, the price, and the cloth cover. Substitute ‘our hero’ for the detective, bandit, or whatever he may be, his rival for the villain, tone down your situations, and you have transformed the ‘dime novel’ into a twenty-five-cent juvenile. Just as there were stock models for the paper thrillers, so there are for these twenty-five-cent stories. The plot invariably depends upon a struggle between ‘our hero’ and a ‘villain’—often one of his own schoolmates. ‘Our hero,’ though sometimes under a cloud, and sometimes in opposition to parent and teacher, is always right.

“All the old cheap dodges of the ‘dime novel’ are worked over and over,p. 15 with the introduction of modern facts and inventions, such as the submarine, the airship, and wireless, to make them ‘up to date.’ Scarcely any physical or scientific feat is impossible for ‘our hero.’ Who should know better than I that these modern books for boys and girls are essentially the same as the condemned ‘dime novel’? Have I not written both? The pay for the twenty-five-cent juveniles, however, is not so good as it was for the old ‘dime’ and ‘half-dime’ novels, being only seventy-five dollars for from fifty to sixty thousand words.

“However, the writer is relieved of one burden. He is not obliged to work out his own plots. The head of the ‘fiction factory’ works out all his own plots, and sends them to his writers. The plot usually bears the name of the story, and the accompanying letter tells when the manuscript must be finished. Three weeks is the customary allowance for fifty thousand words. The writer is told to ‘stick to the synopsis.’ So, when he receives the manuscript, the head of the syndicate is sure that the story is ‘safe,’ that the old habit of the ‘dime-novel’ author has not betrayed him into crudities that would not do for a ‘good series.’

“Now how does this affect you? If you wish to know whether the boys and girls near you are reading this kind of trash, find whether there are in your house cloth-bound modern storybooks that cost twenty-five cents. Read one or two yourself. If you ever read a ‘dime novel,’ you may recognize some of the old stock thrills.

Only Shams

“I am not condemning these books because of the price. Many worthy books are reprinted and sold in cloth today at this and other low prices. But the twenty-five-cent juvenile of the kind I have written about, and which I wish to warn you against, is a definite type. If you have any doubt of the character of a particular book or series, submit it to the children’s librarian of the nearest public library. Ask her whether the library circulates such books.

“The reason it does not is because such stories are not real stories—only shams. They do not deal with real life, but with worn-out, conventional characters and incidents, juggled now into this, now into that, form of cheap, unnatural excitement. They are made to thrill. Above all, they are made to sell.

“One of the greatest curses of these cheap storybooks lies in the fact that they deaden and finally destroy the taste for real books. Their readers miss the fine, real things. They come to prefer impossible fiction to serious books, to biography, history, or even to stories that present life and character as they are.

What Are You Going to Do About It?

“Since I have shown you the inside of the cheap juvenile ‘works,’ the question is, What are you parents or older friends of the youngsters going to do about it? “I find this test in a recent circular warning parents against this class of books:—

“‘Read your children’s books yourself. Or, better still, get your boy or girl to read them aloud to you. Ask yourself during the reading:—

“‘Does this book lay stress on villainy, deception, or treachery?’

“‘Are all the incidents wholesome, probable, and true to life?’

“‘Does it show young people contemptuous toward their elders and successfully opposing them?’

“‘Do the young characters in the book show respect for teachers and others in authority?’

“‘Are these characters the kind of young people you wish your children to associate with?’

“‘Does the book speak of and describe pranks, practical jokes, and pieces of thoughtless and cruel mischief as if they were funny and worthy of imitation?’

“When you find that your own children, or your neighbor’s children, are getting these cloth-bound ‘dime novels’ from local stores, do what you can to spread the information I have given here about them. Don’t, however, blame the bookseller too much. Remember he keeps such books for sale because you and your friends have bought them, and permitted your young people to buy them. Bear in mind that the publication and sale of such books will be stopped only when the public has awakened to the fact that the old ‘dime novel’ they condemn, and the newer twenty-five-cent juvenile book they buy freely, may be one and the same thing.

“It has not been easy for me to write this article. It may not be easy for you to act on it. But I have done my part in laying bare the situation. And I have done so because I have become disgusted with the whole business. Never will I write another ‘factory’ story.”