AdventAI

In the Question Chair.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 3., January 16, 1894

[DESIGNED for the consideration of such questions as will be of interest and profit to the general reader. All correspondents should give their names and correct post-office address, that queries not replied to here, may be answered by mail.]

356.—CANNOT KILL THE SOUL.

Please explain Matt. 10:28, which reads, “And fear not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul: but rather fear him which is able to destroy both soul and body in hell.” M. E. M.

Answer.— The key to the explanation of this verse is found in verse 39 of the same chapter: “He that findeth his life shall lose it; and he that loseth his life for my sake shall find it.” This seems at first sight to be a self-contradiction, till we consider that Christ is speaking of two states of existence; first, the life which we have in this world; and secondly, the life which we are to have in the world to come, if faithful in his service. He who in this world finds his life, that is, preserves it by denying his Lord and forsaking the truth when it is threatened for the truth’s sake, he shall lose the life which he might have had in the world to come. But he that loseth his life for the sake of Christ, that is, who will not deny Christ and turn against the truth, though he may thereby lose his life in this world, he shall find eternal life in the world to come. Now the word “soul” in verse 28 is the same word that is rendered “life” in verse 29, and refers to the life promised to all Christ’s faithful disciples in the world to come. Thus: “Fear not them which kill the body [that is, destroy this present earthly life], but are not able to kill the soul [that is, cannot deprive us of the future eternal life in the kingdom of God, promised to all overcomers]; but rather fear him which is able to destroy both soul and body in hell.” In other words, fear him who is able to take away all existence of every kind in the fires of gehenna, and who will do it with all those who are enemies to him and his truth. This shows that the soul, take it in whatever sense we may, cannot be immortal. See this text (and all others used to prove the conscious state of the dead) fully explained in the work “Here and Hereafter,” for sale at this Office, price one dollar, post-paid.

357.—TRIBUTE TO THE LORD.

In Num. 31:40, of sixteen thousand captives (the soldier’s portion) from the Midianites, it is said that thirty-two persons of them were a tribute to the Lord. Now for what purpose was that tribute given to the Lord? Skeptics make a great handle of this, claiming that they were to be offered up in sacrifice. G. O. E.

Ans.— The Midianites had caused Israel to commit a grievous sin, which brought the plague upon the people, in which many of them perished. As they were the incorrigible enemies of the Lord and his people, the Israelites were sent against them in battle. Vast numbers of them were slain in the conflict, and the remainder, and all their substance were taken as spoil, but not a man of Israel fell in the contest. Verse 49. This is proof enough that the whole matter was by divine counsel, and carried out by divine power.

The reason others besides the men of war were slain, is stated in verses 16, 17. All the young males, who would grow up to be the fighting foes of Israel, and all women who had acted a part in the propagation of that evil race, were cut off, as a matter of divine retribution and justice. Those who were kept alive were not preserved for any evil purpose, as the skeptic avers, from his own wrong imagination. They were to be simply servants of Israel, under certain humane regulations, and laws to guard their dearest rights, as any one will see who will study the whole system of Jewish economy. And those persons who were set apart as the Lord’s portion, were to be employed in the Lord’s service under the Levites, as the Lord’s portion of the sheep and cattle was to be used by the Levites in their offerings and for their own use. There is not the slightest reason to suppose that any of these captives were put to death, but they were kept alive under more favorable circumstances than they enjoyed amid the corruptions and idolatries of their own nation.

Amid the nations outside of the Israelites the slaughter of enemies was promiscuous, male and female, young and old, with no exceptions of any class, boys or girls; and yet we never heard of a skeptic denouncing the character or work of these nations. But when we come to the case before us, where the Lord directed that a class, seemingly best entitled to protection, were excepted and saved from slaughter, amounting in this instance, to 32,000 persons (both soldiers’ and people’s portion; see verses 27, 29, 35), this calls forth all their anathemas and denunciations. Why is this? If any other nation had destroyed the Midianites, there would have been 32,000 more corpses than in this case; and the Israelites were consequently so much in advance of the character of any other nations; and yet they, alone, are the subjects of animadversion and reproach. This reveals the unpleasant reality that the skeptic’s feelings and arguments are prompted, not by facts and reason, but by a desire to find fault in some way with the God of the Bible.