AdventAI

JUSTIFICATION BY FAITH NOT A NEW DOCTRINE.

By W. H. Littlejohn

From Review and Herald, Vol. 71, No. 3., January 16, 1894

BY ELDER W. H. LITTLEJOHN.

  • (Battle Creek, Mich.) *

Within three or four years the subject of justification by faith has attained unwonted prominence in the writings and sermons of Seventh-day Adventists. No one rejoices over this fact more than does the writer of this article. While he is sometimes fearful that some of our denomination are in danger of swinging to the other extreme, and deciding that works have no place whatever in God’s plan of saving men, he nevertheless rejoices that our people are being taught clearly and emphatically that works can never be made the basis upon which a sinner can be justified. He who has committed a single sin in the course of his life, can only be saved through the perfect obedience of Christ to the law of God. This is so for two reasons: (1) Because God, whose decision is final, has decreed that such shall be the case; (2) Because in the very nature of things it is impossible to do works of supererogation, and, therefore, there is no possibility of our atoning for a single transgression, after that transgression becomes a fact. Works are important, as an evidence of faith. James 2 : 18. They also enter into God’s plan so far that he employs them as a measure in deciding what is to be the final reward of a saint; i. e., whether that reward shall be great or small. We read, therefore, that when Christ comes, he will “reward every man according to his works.” Matt. 16 : 27. Observe that when the reward is given, it is bestowed upon every man (not class of men), according to his works, and not according to the works of his class.

But it was not my intention when commencing this article, to discuss the relation of works to justification. My design was to show that some of our good brethren have erred in supposing that the doctrine of justification by faith was not understood and advocated by any of our denomination until within a very brief space of time. The writer has conversed with several who seem to have adopted this view. It is to correct the mistake of such, that he writes as he does at this time.

To begin with, the doctrine in question runs like a golden thread through the Bible, from Genesis to Revelation, binding it together, and unifying the whole. This will be evident from a moment’s thought. If those who now advocate the doctrine of justification by faith are correct in their views, from whence did they derive the doctrine that they advocate? They obtained it from the Scriptures, did they not? But if this be true, then that doctrine has always been in the Scriptures, and, therefore, is not new. Assuredly Christ, Paul, Peter, and other apostles taught the doctrine of justification by faith.

The early church derived that tenet from them and from what they wrote, as contemporaneous history will prove. The reformers of the sixteenth century were firm believers in salvation through the righteousness of Christ. A single quotation upon this point must suffice: “The great truth of justification by faith, which at once overturns the subtleties of the schools and the popish doctrine of the efficacy of works, was boldly proclaimed in the very bosom of Sorbonne itself.” “It is God alone,” said the teacher (and it might have seemed as if the very roofs of the university would cry out against such new sounds), “it is God alone who by his grace justifies unto eternal life.” “What will you then say?” inquired the hearers, to whom such sounds appeared to contradict the teaching of four centuries: “will you say that any one man was ever justified without works?” “One, do you ask?” returned Lefevre; “why, they are innumerable. How many shameful sinners have eagerly asked to be baptized, having nothing but faith in Christ alone, and who, if they died the moment after, entered into the life of the blessed without works.”*

That John Wesley was a firm believer in the view that we can be saved only through the obedience of Christ to the law of God, is made so prominent in his writings that no intelligent reader needs to be informed that such is the case. The commentary of Dr. Adam Clarke, who was a distinguished writer of the Methodist Church, is full of the doctrine in question. Indeed, nearly all of the modern orthodox churches are firm believers in the view that it is alone through the merits of Christ that men can be saved.

The Romish Church, on the contrary, seems to rely in part, if not in full, upon works as a means of obtaining salvation. The question naturally arises, therefore, whether it can be possible that Seventh-day Adventists and Romanists, who have always been at antipodes on every other question, would have been in substantial accord on the relation of works to salvation. The writer blushes to think that such a question could ever arise in the mind of any person acquainted with the facts in the case, and belonging to the Seventh-day Adventist Church. He is aware that our enemies have repeatedly charged that we expect to be saved by our good deeds, but he is also aware that this charge has always been repelled by our people as a foul slander.

Who is there among us who has listened to the preaching of the lamented Elder James White, who has not heard him thunder from the desk these words, “There is no justifying principle in law.” The writer ventures the assertionp. 36 that he has heard the language quoted from the lips of the preacher in question at least a score of times. In every instance they were uttered in order to disabuse the minds of those outside of our church from the calumny which our enemies were constantly circulating against us. But if Elder White was right in saying that there was “no justifying principle in law,” where was our justification to come from, according to his view, unless it came through the righteousness of Christ?

I need not quote from the testimonies to show that they have always advocated the tenet of justification by faith; for any one who has read ten pages in them cannot have failed to discover that such was the case. Is it possible, therefore, that the doctrine of justification by faith is new to a people who have read and believed those testimonies for forty-seven years?

Had I the space to do so, I might quote from the writings of all of our prominent men, to substantiate the opinion defended in this article. I will, however, give an extract from but one of them. In “Thoughts on Daniel and the Revelation,” p. 589, the language found below can be seen:—

“And though the 144,000 are accused of rejecting Christ and trusting to their own works for salvation, because they refuse to violate the commandments of God (Rev. 14 : 1, 12), in the great day that calumny will be wiped off. It will be seen that they have rested their hope of life on the merits of the shed blood of their divine Redeemer, making him their source of righteousness. There is peculiar force in saying of these, that they have washed their robes and made them white in the blood of the Lamb.”

It is with pleasure that the writer transcribes the foregoing citation, since he knows that the author of the sentiments there recorded has been misunderstood on this question. The quotation made was written in 1865, or twenty-eight years ago.

In 1866, or twenty-seven years ago, the writer commenced to keep the Sabbath. If the reader will pardon the seeming egotism, I will quote a few words from a letter addressed by me to a friend at that time. The letter mentioned was the first thing that I ever wrote to prove the obligation of the law and the Sabbath. Here are a few lines which bear an explicit testimony to my belief in the doctrine of justification by faith at the time in question: “It (the statement in Rom. 10 : 4, that Christ is the end of the law for righteousness to every one that believeth) then becomes a simple declaration on the part of the apostle that we are not necessarily lost, because we have not kept the law perfectly; for having believed on Christ, his righteousness will be imputed to us.”

The importance of having our people correctly represented in the matter of the relation which they have heretofore sustained to the doctrine of justification by faith, can hardly be exaggerated. Admit that this doctrine is new to them, and that it has but recently found a place in their creed, and you have impeached them before the world. The principle of justification by faith is a fundamental doctrine in the great plan of salvation through Christ. Without an intelligent acceptance of it, no man can be saved.* If, as a people, therefore, we had never rightly comprehended and appropriated that doctrine until three or four years ago, all who died in the message up to that time are lost. There is no avoiding that conclusion, since there is no salvation out of Christ, and since he saves only by securing the imputation of his righteousness to the repentant sinner. Rom. 3 : 21–26. Furthermore, if the doctrine in question has not heretofore occupied a prominent place in the faith of Seventh-day Adventists, it is impossible that they have ever as yet given the third angel’s message. This is so, because the people who give that message are to keep the “faith of Jesus” (Rev. 14 : 9–12), the corner-stone of which is faith in the doctrine of justification by faith. Again, the idea that a people who have carried on their work forty-seven years, without understanding the most fundamental doctrine of the Christian religion, should assume to apply the epithet “Babylon” to other churches who have always firmly believed in that doctrine, is so preposterous that one blushes at the thought.

Be very careful, brethren, that by indiscreet and incorrect statements you do not put into the hands of our enemies weapons with which they can overthrow once and forever the work which we love so much. It may be, and doubtless is true, that there is to be found among us occasionally a person, who, from his own obtuseness of mind, or through the failure of his spiritual teacher to do his duty, has never yet attained to an understanding of the doctrine of justification by faith. Such individuals could also be found in any and every denomination. To say, however, that any considerable portion of our people have never been indoctrinated upon the question of the imputation of Christ’s righteousness, is to misrepresent the facts, and place in a wrong light those who have occupied the most responsible positions in our work. The simple facts in the case are these: The nominal churches have been living in open violation of the law of God in the matter of the Sabbath. The duty of restoring the Sabbath and vindicating the law has been laid upon our people in the providence of God. Around these points the battle has raged continually. As the orthodox churches believe in the doctrine of justification by faith, it has not been thought necessary to give prominence to that view in our preaching. This was a mistake, which reacted upon ourselves. The result of that mistake was that the doctrine in question in a measure lost its hold upon some of our people, to their damage. Such a result was natural, under the circumstances. Now that the argument upon the peculiar features of our faith has been fully developed, that branch of the subject does not demand so much of our thought as formerly; and the good Lord in his wise providence is now emphasizing the doctrine of the imputed righteousness of Christ. Let us rejoice that we have lived to see this day, but let us be cautious that we do not play into the hands of our enemies, by admitting as true that which they have always charged upon us; namely, that we as a people have relied for justification upon our own works, instead of the righteousness of Christ.

Notes

  1. *Lefevre as quoted in D’Aubigne’s “History of the Reformation,” book 12. ↩
  2. *The reference here is to the doctrine of justification by faith in its simplest form. ↩