Should They Receive State Support?
I am glad that the question of State aid for church purposes is agitating other minds than our own. For several years now the relations which should exist between the church of Christ and the powers of earth, have been much discussed, and many have been the opinions expressed thereon.
With the Roman Catholic Church the union of the civil with the religious has long been a settled belief. True, many times Rome has disclaimed such doctrine, but this has been only when the Roman Church could not be the leading and controlling factor in the government. When she herself could rule, Rome has taught and upheld the union of the religious with the civil power. Nor has she abated one jot from this faith to-day. She believes in such a union still, and is only waiting in this country for the auspicious moment to arrive when her power and influence will be sufficient to bring to her the reins of governmental power.
Protestants professedly have opposed such a union. At the same time, however, they have adopted such tactics, and worked on such lines as to force them logically into acquiescence with the same fatal conclusion. Thus do we now find that those very churches which have felt in the past, in the days of their poverty and unpopularity, the persecution which is the outgrowth of Rome’s logic, are adopting in their popularity and wealth, the very arguments, and using against others the same principles of unrighteous judgment once employed against themselves.
It does not require the mind of a philosopher to discern the trend of religious teaching at the present time. It requires but a meager history of past ages to see that the Church is following in the same paths laid out by the Church in the fourth century. Nor does it require the eye of a prophet to see that the same fatal results reached by the Church then, will be reached by the Church in the future, if the same tactics are persisted in. Now, as then, the Church is clamoring for State aid and influence.p. 38
The preaching of politics from the pulpit, the lobbying of ministers in the halls of legislation, the almost universal clamoring for new Sunday laws, with the enforcement of existing ones, the acceptance of State funds for church schools and missions,—all these indicate an alarming tendency in the political and religious worlds. It was by such means in the fourth century that the beast rode into power. It is by the same means that the image to the beast will attain its growth and development.
At such times as these, when the great majority of the public journals are throwing their influence in favor of a union of Church and State, it is refreshing to hear an occasional voice disclaiming against such a consummation. The great majority of the religious writers contend for State aid to church schools and to church work. Occasionally there is found one who is so thoroughly conversant with the history of the past, and sufficiently free from religious bias, as to see the influence and tendency of such principles. We present below a portion of an article found in the current issue of the Missionary Review of the World. It is from the pen of one of the associate editors, Dr. A. J. Gordon. Under the caption, “Education and Missions,” he speaks of the influence and mischief of State aid to church schools and missions; and from the history of the past makes valuable deductions for the instruction of the Church of Christ:—
“Is affiliation with the State, or separation from the State, the true method in missions? It sounds strange to hear a minister in a national church—the late Professor Christlieb, of Bonn—attaching so much importance, as he does, to exemption of religion from government control. In tracing the rise of the missionary spirit in America, he says: ‘Certainly it was no mere accidental circumstance that a livelier interest in the missionary enterprise began after the privileges of the State Church had been abolished in New England.’ It was when ‘delivered from the incumbrance of State aid,’ he goes on to say, that the American Church first began to rise to the greatness of her obligation to the heathen.”
“The eminent theologian thus puts emphasis on what it might not occur to us to notice. But those who are acquainted with Christlieb’s experience can read into his words even more than he has himself expressed. His high evangelical views won for him the reproach of ‘pietism,’ and more than once the ‘powers that be’ came near laying disciplinary hands upon him for this offense. It is always liable to be so. The stipend rarely fails to assert its authority over the stipendiary; subsidies are almost certain, sooner or later, to subsidize. Therefore let missions be on their guard against ‘the incumbrance of State aid.’”
“The history of primitive missions is instructive at every point, and nowhere more so than here. ‘When the Church had the least money, it had the most might,’ it has been pointedly said. And we may unhesitatingly add that when it had the least aid from the world, it made the most rapid conquests in the world.”
“When the Church held most uncompromisingly that her citizenship was in heaven, absolutely refusing to be affiliated with the kingdoms of this world, then it was that she was irresistible in her onward movement. This attitude of the early Christians gave great offense to heathen rulers, who often desired to be friendly to those who stubbornly refused to be befriended by them, lest their friendship with the world might prove enmity to God.”
“Here is the picture which Uhlhorn gives of the victorious Church of the first three centuries: ‘The coming of the Lord was then believed to be quite near, and this hope dominated the whole life. No provision was made for the long continuance of the Church on earth, and all efforts were exclusively directed toward remaining in the world without spot till the day of Christ’s coming.’ This is the time, and this is the spiritual attitude in which Christianity made its most extraordinary advance among the heathen, so that Tertullian could say: ‘We are of yesterday, and yet have filled every place belonging to you,—cities, islands, castles, towns, assemblies, your very camp, your tribes, companies, senate, and forum;’ and Eusebius observes that ‘the saving word has brought the souls of men of every race to the devout veneration of the God of the universe.’ Indeed, so rapid and so firm was the progress of the gospel during the period, that Dr. Warneck estimates that ‘at the end of the first century there were in the whole extent of the Roman empire at most, 200,000 Christians, and at the end of the third century, about 6,000,000; that is, about a twentieth part of the whole population.’ (See ‘History of Protestant Missions,’ p. 4.)”
“Without letting go the hope of the final advent of the Lord, the Church now entered upon its historical development and its citizenship on earth. . . . Just here, in the assumption of earthly citizenship, was the turning-point in history, when the pure and primitive Church swung into the paganized and apostate Church. If our citizenship is on earth, we may receive tithes, and collect revenues from the kings of this earth; we may allow human governments to pay tribute to us. But let us be on our guard against the perils involved in such a course. To swap civilized education for heathen money may be fair trade, but is it the calling of the merchantman in heavenly pearls to engage in such traffic? To give secular teaching in exchange for government grants may be an honest transaction, but is the missionary of the cross commissioned for such a business? As a matter of fact, the missionary societies of free churches and established churches alike, have fallen into the habit of receiving government grants in aid on the foreign field. The system of secular education among our missions is largely related to this usage. The wrong principle—alliance of missions with the State—has led to what many regard as a wrong result. The principle, therefore, needs serious reconsideration. It was through this principle, gradually and almost imperceptibly adopted, that the early Church, from being ‘more than conqueror,’ became more than conquered, since, instead of Christianizing paganism, her Christianity was paganized. The law of the kingdom of heaven is not the law of the kingdoms of earth. The world’s motto is, ‘In union there is strength;’ the Church’s motto is, ‘In separation there is strength.’”
What position the Missionary Review has taken upon the questions of Church and State, which have agitated the world for the last one or two years, I am unable to state, as I have not read its columns with this in mind. What position it will take in the future in this deepening and widening controversy, it will be interesting to note. I trust that it ever will be found consistent with the principles of its own logic, as expressed in the editorial quoted above.
F. M. WILCOX.