GAINESVILLE.—In my report of our cases last week, I promised to give the city ordinance under which we were convicted “for disorderly conduct and disturbing the peace.” It reads as follows:—
“Any person or persons who shall use loud, boisterous, insulting, or obscene language, or who shall curse or swear, or attempt to raise a quarrel, or who shall act in a disorderly or violent manner, or who shall fight, quarrel, halloo, or make any unnecessary noise within the corporate limits of this city, calculated to disturb the peace, quiet, or good order of the city, or any citizen, shall be guilty of disorderly conduct, and upon conviction, shall be punished as prescribed by Section 68.”
The city presented four witnesses. The first witness called by the prosecution was officer James Latham, one of the two policemen who arrested us. Being sworn, and questioned by the city attorney, he testified substantially as follows:—
City Attorney — “Mr. Latham, do you know these parties, the defendants in this case?”
Mr. Latham — “I have known the one on the left for a few months as Mr. McCutchen, and the other I know casually as going by the name of Keck.”
C. A. — “They are charged with disorderly conduct, and disturbing the peace on yesterday, the 19th. Tell what you know about it.”
Mr. L. — “Well, I went over by the new Adventist church yesterday, and went up to the window, and looked in, and saw Mr. McCutchen using a plane, dressing a piece of lumber,—jointing a plank I believe he was,—though I must say I don’t think he is a scientific hand at the business [trying to make a little merriment of it], and that gentleman [pointing to brother Keck] was marking on a board, as if laying off some pattern.”
C. A. — “Did what they were doing disturb you?”
Mr. L. — “Yes, sir. I think it would disturb anybody in a civilized country [in a sarcastic, flippant tone].”
C. A. — “Did their work seem to be sufficiently noisy to disturb the neighbors around them?”
Mr. L. — “I should think so. When I went over there, quite a number were gathered about in the streets, as if attracted and disturbed by something.”
C. A. — “They seemed to have been attracted by the noise, then, did they?”
Mr. L. — “Yes, sir.”
C. A. — “How did you know of this work going on, Mr. Latham?”
Mr. L. — “I heard of it.”
C. A. — “Was it reported to you?”
Mr. L. — “Yes, sir.”
C. A. — “Who complained to you?”
Mr. L. — “I—I don’t know as that is a fair question.”
The Mayor — “Yes; who was it? Answer.”
Mr. L. — “It was Mr. Taylor.”
T. M. — “The witness is yours, gentlemen [speaking to brother Keck and myself]. Any questions you wish to ask him?”
I then asked him a few questions, and received answers as follows:—
Mr. McCutchen — “Mr. Latham, you say quite a little crowd gathered in the streets in the vicinity of our church. Was it caused by anything going on in or around the church? or by seeing you, an officer, in officer’s clothes coming around and watching about our church, an unaccustomed place for an officer, which will always cause the curious to gather around and watch to see what the officer is after?—which was it that attracted the attention of the people, and caused them to gather in the streets?”
Mr. L. — “I don’t know whether my going there was the attraction to them or not.”
Mr. McC. — “Well, were any gathered on the streets before you went there? As you walked up, were they there?”
Mr. L. — “I think so.”
Mr. McC. — “You think so. Do you know it? Who were they? and where were they gathered?”
Mr. L. — “I don’t call to mind now just the particular ones.”
Mr. McC. — “You know all those people around there. If any of them were gathered out in the streets at the time you mention, you can surely name some of them.”
Mr. L. — “I believe I saw Mr. Lee Parnell and some of his family, and Mr. McKee here.”
Mr. McC. — “But were they gathered out in the streets as if attracted by any disturbing noise? Weren’t they on their own premises?”
Mr. L. — “I don’t know but they were.”
Mr. McC. — “Wasn’t Mr. Parnell in his own house, or rather on his veranda?”
Mr. L. — “Yes.”
Thus this witness failed completely to establish the point he had sworn to positively—yielded upp. 784 the whole question in fact, and it seems to us, without a doubt, perjured himself.
The city’s other three witnesses were, Mr. Taylor, the man who informed on us, and who lives nearly half a mile away; Mr. Melker living near by us; and a Mr. Roark, living in another part of the city. The testimony of each of these was essentially the same as that given above, as to the point of being disturbed. During our questioning of Mr. Melker, brother Keck asked him if the work or conduct complained of was such as would disturb him on any other day of the week than Sunday.
Mr. Melker. — “No.”
Brother Keck. — “Then it was not the nature of the work that was the element in the disturbance, but the day on which it was done?”
Mr. M. — “Yes, sir.”
Mr. McC. — “And why did it disturb you, Mr. Melker?”
Mr. M. — “Because I was always taught to keep that day holy, and never used to seeing people work on it.”
Mr. McC. — “And you regard Sunday as a sacred day, do you?”
Mr. M. — “Yes, sir.”
Mr. McC. — “And it is because of that sacredness which attaches to it in your mind that work on that day disturbs you, is it?”
Mr. M. — “Yes.”
Mr. McC. — “Then isn’t it a religious sentiment that is at the bottom of your feelings of disturbance on seeing work done on Sunday?”
Mr. M. ———
The following point was brought out in Mr. Roark’s testimony.
Mr. McC. — “Mr. Roark, you have testified that you were disturbed. How did you come to be disturbed? Did you see or hear any unusually noisy demonstrations?”
Mr. Roark. — “No, sir.”
Mr. McC. — “How did you know any work was going on at the church, and you living so far away?”
Mr. R. — “I heard of it.”
Mr. McC. — “And were you disturbed by it?”
Mr. R. — “Yes.”
Mr. McC. — “Did you see or hear any work going on yourself?”
Mr. R. — “I did after I finally went over there with Mr. Latham. [Mr. Latham probably brought him over that he might see us work, and be a witness against us, for they both came together, and looked in at us through the window.]”
Mr. McC. — “But you had heard of it before going over?”
Mr. R. — “Yes.”
Mr. McC. — “And were you disturbed by it as soon as you heard of it?”
Mr. R. — “Yes, sir.”
Mr. McC. — “Before you ever came within hearing of it?”
Mr. R. — “Yes, in a way.”
Mr. McC. — “What sort of way?”
Mr. R. — “Well, I was always accustomed to seeing people refrain from work on Sunday; it is our Christian Sabbath, and it was disturbing even to hear of work going on on it,” etc., etc.
Mr. Taylor, the informer, and another prosecuting witness, who was “disturbed” (?) also lives nearly half a mile away, only he passed by and heard our work. We had only one witness, and that was Mr. Lee Parnell, mentioned in Mr. Latham’s testimony, given above. Of course we did not pretend to try to disprove our having worked. The only point we sought to prove by our witness was that there was no disturbance in what we did. Mr. Parnell’s house is by far the closest one to our church,—only fifty feet away,—and he testified pointedly that he was not disturbed, though himself and family are strict members of the church, and Sunday-keepers. And if the nearest neighbor was not disturbed, why should those half a mile away be?
We had no attorney to conduct the trial nor to defend our cases, but went into it in the fear of God, trusting him to give us wisdom and words to use in accordance with his promises. In making our plea, when I explained to the mayor that we kept the seventh day and worked the first day, from conscientious religious convictions, he replied that it “was not a question of conscience, but one of law;” and yet the injured feelings of the complaining witnesses, whose consciences were so tender that they were greatly hurt by the mere knowledge of the fact of work going on half a mile from them, seemed to have great weight with the mayor. Surely there must be a great difference in men, when one is not allowed to have any conscience at all, and another is permitted to enjoy one half a mile long! In examining the witnesses, when I asked one if he did not know of other violations of Sunday, the mayor promptly informed him that he need not answer that. In the plea, I told the court that the ordinance under which they had a charge against us was specific; that we had been guilty of none of the things forbidden by it; that they could not point to the testimony of a single witness that we had used loud, boisterous, insulting, or obscene language; or swore or cursed, fought, or attempted to fight or raise a quarrel, hallooed, or anything of the kind; that the only thing he could find against us was working on Sunday, and that he had no ordinance against that; that it was a religious sentiment at the bottom of the whole thing, as shown by the testimony of the witnesses themselves. And yet, in the face of all these facts, and on such testimony as I have given herein, his honor had the heart, after giving us a very pious lecture, to convict us, and fine us $50 and costs, or ninety days each on the streets, and probably thought it an exhibition of great zeal for “our holy religion.” He is a leading spirit in the Methodist church here.
It is very evident that our cases have not taken the turn the mayor and others of his way of thinking expected. He thought, when he imposed the fine, that it would simply be a question of our putting our hands into our pockets, and pulling it out, and paying it. Thus he would get a snug little sum for the city’s coffers (I learn officially that the city is in desperate straits for funds), and a chance to laugh in his sleeve at us, and that that would be the last of our Sunday work; and in addition to all the rest, he would have the honor of putting it down. He had no idea, I am confident, that we would go to jail; and it is giving him quite an unenviable reputation. He is getting sick of the notoriety it is bringing him; and has begun already to make explanations, by a card in an Atlanta paper.
The odium of sending two inoffensive men to jail for their religious convictions, and that, too, in a case over which he had no jurisdiction whatever, and the pretense of convicting us for disorderly conduct are not very enjoyable to him. He finds that his tyranny and injustice to us have only created a good public sentiment in our favor, though of course there are many bitter enemies yet, and that all the people do not sustain him in his position. All these things together are a little more reaction than he was counting on. All the lawyers here think the cases that go up from his court to the Superior Court will undoubtedly be set aside; but I look for those in the county court for Sabbath-breaking to be stubborn ones. There is one thing about it, I think is a good thing, however, unless I fail to understand it, and that is, that neither the accusation they have against us in the court, made out, too, by the prosecuting attorney, nor the section of the statute which they have us charged with violating, mentions Sunday or the first day of the week, but simply says “the Lord’s day,” which will, I think, give us a splendid chance to make an argument as to which is the Lord’s day, and thus preach the Sabbath to the court and people.
The statute relating to Sunday regulation, mentions Sunday in one or two sections above the one relating to our cases; but in that section itself, it is not mentioned by that name, but simply as “the Lord’s day.” I don’t know how this will stand for us, but think it will give a broad opening to present the Sabbath fully. The penalty for Sunday-breaking here is severe—not exceeding $100 fine or six months’ imprisonment, or twelve months in the chain-gang, one or all of them within the discretion of the judge. Our trust is in God, and we go forth in his name, hoping to be prepared for whatever he may have for us.
Nov. 28. W. A. McCutchen.