The friends of the Examiner (Baptist) would like to know what its position on the Sunday question is. Some time ago it reviewed a book by the editor of the Evangel and Sabbath Outlook,—“Paganism Surviving in Christianity,”—and promised, at some future time, to examine the positions taken therein concerning the Sabbath. If it has done this, the fact has escaped our notice. Under date of Nov. 16, the Examiner refers to the late discussion in the New York Ministers’ Conference, as follows:—
“The moderator, Rev. R. M. Luther, D.D., was in the chair, and the attendance was large, it including many pastors of the larger churches in New York and Brooklyn. The morning was given to the discussion of the paper by Dr. E. T. Hiscox, on ‘The Arguments for the Transference of the Sabbath,’ read at the last Monday’s meeting.
“No hastily written and condensed report could do justice to the accurately written and critical statement made by Dr. Hiscox. While the positions taken in the essay seem to be incontrovertible, the statements were startling to many who had not carefully examined the question. The essayist began by defining the conditions of the question. The appeal is to the word of God, not to tradition or the custom of the church in any age. When we examine exactly what the New Testament says, one is surprised to find that there is no definite statement on the subject. The first and most common argument for the transfer of the worship day from the seventh to the first day of the week, is based upon the supposed fact of the resurrection of our Lord upon the first day of the week. The statement is simply that very early in the morning of the first day of the week the disciples came to the sepulcher and found that he had arisen. It is not clear upon what day Christ was crucified. If it was Friday, his resurrection could not possibly have been on the first day of the week. The probability is that the day of the crucifixion was Wednesday, and that the Lord rose on Saturday, or the seventh day.
“When we come to examine the meetings of the apostles, we find that they met naturally on the day succeeding his resurrection. Their next meeting was after eight days—certainly not the first day of the week. The same uncertainty attends the statements made in the epistles and in the Apocalypse. The much-quoted passage in the book of Revelation, in which John says he was in the Spirit on the Lord’s day, the time is not definite. It may refer simply to an intermediate period, as does the similar phrase, ‘the day of the Lord.’ In conclusion, there is no definite and clear statement in Scripture that there was any transfer of the observance of a Sabbath to the first day of the week.
“The discussion was without the call of the roll, and was participated in by many brethren, the line not being drawn between members and those who were not. Rev. Messrs. E. T. Tomlinson, Ph.D., G. W. Samson, LL.D., Norman Fox, D.D., Walter Rauschenbusch, J. B. Simmons, D.D., Lemuel Moss, D.D., Professor N. Schmidt, of Hamilton, and Dr. D. J. Yerkes, of Plainfield, N. J., were among the speakers. Of the discussion it may be said in a general way that very little new light was thrown upon the subject. The best thing that can be said of it is that it proved to be one of very great interest to the ministry of the churches. The discussion itself was very unequal. Some good points were made, as when Dr. Tomlinson said: ‘Suppose Constantine had forced Sunday upon the church, when the seventh day had been continuously observed, what would have been the effect upon Christians who had learned not to hold back their lives dear unto them for the gospel’s sake?’ And by pastor Rauschenbusch, who asked, ‘Suppose the Lord Jesus to come into this Conference to-day, would he prefer those who keep the seventh day of the week to those who observe the first day? There are greater questions than one of days for us to be agitated about—as that, for example, of the condition of the outcasts and the poor of this great city.’ Dr. Hiscox replied at the close of the discussion.”
That is a fair bit of history, but the Examiner is pre-eminently the able champion of Baptist doctrines and usages. Shall we conclude that Dr. Hiscox’s “startling” and “incontrovertible” statements concerning the utterly unscriptural character of Sunday observance are good “Baptist doctrine”? The Evangel and Sabbath Outlook believes they are. Does the Examiner? If not, why not? Tell us plainly. Why was “very little new light thrown upon the subject,” when the wisest and ablest men in that association, after a week of special preparation, discussed it with an intenseness almost discordant?
Has the accumulated wisdom of three hundred years of vigorous Baptist life failed to find the “new light”? Is the Sabbath question so deeply obscure that some new form of higher criticism, some new-born system of exegesis, some new examination of historic Christianity, is necessary to bring out the truth concerning Sunday? Is the New Testament so foggy a document that even the Examiner cannot find its “bearings” nor any “soundings”? Is it offshore and “scudding under bare poles” before the no-Sabbath storm? Has it got a copy of an old chart called the New Testament? That chart can be found in any bookstore; it is not “out of print.”
Up to date, so far as we have been able to read, the Examiner has been extremely successful in quitting the field and avoiding the issue whenever the Sabbath question comes up. Will it surrender to Dr. Hiscox with his semi-Seventh-day Baptist heresy proudly floating at the mast-head? Will the Examiner get down in the fear of God, and examine things? Its friends wait to see.—Evangel and Sabbath Outlook.