The False and the True in Modern Science---No. 4
Additional Facts from the Rocks
GEORGE MCCREADY PRICE
In the previous article we gave some facts which show that the chief geological changes recorded in the rocks must have been accomplished in a sudden and violent manner. The evidence for this is that fishes, shellfish, and other creatures are found buried in immense hecatombs, gigantic graveyards, often miles in extent, wherein uncounted myriads of those creatures appear to have been destroyed by some sudden or violent catastrophe. These conditions are of course not universal around the earth; but they occur in so many instances and in such widely scattered localities, and comprise so many various orders or kinds of creatures, that they may be said to constitute a universal phenomenon of the rocks.
Geologists, it is true, always admit the abnormal conditions in each single or particular instance; but according to their evolutionary theory they arrange these various catastrophes in a prolonged series, separated by long ages of what they term quiet and normal action. This is indeed the keynote of their system. But as has been shown, there is absolutely no scientific evidence to prove that these various catastrophes were merely local in extent, and occurred one after the other during long ages of time. It is really much more scientific to correlate all these various abnormal events together as merely parts of one great world catastrophe; and then these events assume a familiar form, and become merely the scientific aspects of that great event during which “the world that then was, being overflowed with water, perished.” 2 Peter 3:6.
In a previous article we also spoke of the evidences of a sudden and world-wide change of climate. That a wonderful climate, springlike and balmy, seems to have prevailed over the entire globe, is abundantly proved by other conditions besides the elephants and different animals found frozen in the ice of the arctic regions. For example, in many localities the arctic regions contain rocks full of certain kinds of corals; and we know that corals cannot exist except in warm water, which maintains a steady temperature of nearly 80° F. These corals are widely distributed in the arctic regions, and they show that during their lifetime a mild climate must have prevailed over all that part of the world.
Another evidence tending in the same direction is furnished by the immense coal deposits abounding in those regions. Every one has heard of the coal beds of Alaska; but not all are aware that these coal deposits seem to grow richer and better as we go northward. Cape Lisburne, a point of land some three hundred miles north of Nome and about one hundred sixty miles within the arctic circle, contains forty or fifty successive beds of coal, ten of them being each four feet thick, and one more than thirty feet through.
The leaves of the plants composing this coal are well preserved in the rocks, and consist of ferns, horsetails, club mosses, with cycads and palms, which now live only in warm, semitropical regions. We can well understand why the Government bulletin describing these coal deposits says that they indicate “a mild and probably frostless climate.” But at the present time this region is cold and desolate, the soil is frozen many hundreds of feet down, and thaws out only enough on top during the short summer to allow a scanty vegetation of the hardiest herbs and shrubs to appear.
All these facts, with others that might be given, are conclusive evidence that our world once enjoyed a climate of uninterrupted springlike mildness. If we considered these coal beds alone, there might be some chance to suppose that the change from that climate to the present one of terrific extremes of heat and cold was a gradual process; but the moment we begin to speak of a gradual change of climate, those elephant mummies, so splendidly preserved by nature’s system of cold storage, rise up before us to testify that the change was not gradual, but sudden, indeed sudden beyond human comprehension.
Some who are unacquainted with the geological facts have supposed that these remains in the arctic regions merely indicate that these regions constituted the tropics of that ancient world, and that at that same time some other portion of the world was suffering the rigors of an arctic climate. But there is no scientific evidence whatever, either geological, astronomical, paleontological, or any other sort, to prove or to hint that the poles were ever in any other position than where they are at present. And I do not know of any scientist who holds the view that the great change of climate which is so evident from the study of the fossils, was due to the shifting of the polar regions. Indeed, the evidence is all the other way. There are proofs, which need not be enumerated here, which show conclusively that this mild climate was formerly universal over the whole globe.
The generally larger size of the fossils found in the rocks, is another fact of much significance in this connection. I do not wish to convey the idea that all the fossils which we find in the rocks are abnormal monsters. True, there are some huge, unearthly looking monsters, some of them seventy or eighty feet long, the bones of which are found in Wyoming, Nebraska, and elsewhere. There are two such creatures in the Carnegie Museum at Pittsburgh, Pa., and one whole animal and parts of many others, nearly as large, in the Natural History Museum of New York. But I refer to the fossil remains of lobsters and clams and fishes and butterflies and bears and lions, and indeed almost the whole range of animal life. For practically all the fossils furnish specimens which are larger and more thrifty-looking than similar kinds alive at the present time. It is also a very significant fact that this characteristic of larger size is common to all the kinds of fossils found in all the various “formations,” and in all parts of the globe; and that when we pass over into our modern world, the change in the appearance of the fossils is just as sudden and complete as is that of climate.
Another very important aspect of modern discovery has to do with the conditions now prevailing around our ocean borders and on the deep floor of the ocean itself.
It was formerly taught that parts of the coast of Greenland, Sweden, Italy, and other countries, are rising slowly and gradually above the sea, and other parts are gradually settling beneath the waters. It is true there are old shore lines or raised beaches around all the continents, in some places fifty orp. 7 one hundred or five hundred feet above the present level of the ocean. In other places we have submerged forests, with the stumps of trees still visible beneath the water hundreds of feet out from the shore. However, these are an evidence, not of gradual, but of sudden changes of level; while the raised beaches at least are inseparably connected with the other vast geological changes which took place in the great long ago, and cannot be separated from them in explanation.
In addition to this, it was long supposed that definite markings placed on the shores of the Baltic and elsewhere during the last hundred years, tended to prove that changes of sea level are now going on. But a very full and complete examination of this supposed evidence has been made in recent years by some of the leading scientists, such as Sir Henry Howorth and Professor Suess; and their conclusion is that there is no sufficient evidence of this supposed gradual change of sea level, the latter author declaring that “displacements susceptible of measurement have not occurred within the historic period.”
Thus another of the teachings of evolutionary science turns out to be merely a myth, without any substantial facts in its support. The sea coasts of the continents are not now on the seesaw, up and down; and this alleged modern movement, which turns out to be based upon mistakes, cannot be appealed to in order to explain the great changes of sea and land which we find recorded in the rocks. These past changes of the sea and the land were wholly abnormal and without any explanation from similar changes which were once supposed to be still going on.
It was long taught that in our deep seas and oceans the currents are all the time wearing away in some places and building up in others. Therefore it was supposed to be necessary only for these beds of sandstone or limestone, which had been formed beneath the ocean, to be lifted up above the waters, in order to constitute the lands as we now find them, where mountains and plains are composed of strata of limestone containing corals or crinoids, alternating with sandstone containing shellfish, and shales full of the leaves of land plants.
But the investigations of the “Challenger” Expedition (1872-76), which was sent out by the British government, with other similar expeditions which have since been organized by the American and other governments, have proved that the bottom of the ocean is not being subjected to any such movements of the waters. The ocean currents do not extend below a thousand or two thousand feet, while the movements made by the mightiest storms are even more superficial in their action. On the contrary, over the whole bottom of the ocean there is a perpetual calm.
Around the borders of the oceans, extending out in some places a hundred miles more or less, the waves and currents are still at work, and deposits brought down from the land by the rivers and streams, are still being laid down. But as all kinds of sediments tend to be precipitated about twenty-five times as rapidly in salt water as in fresh, these sediments brought down from the land never get very far from the shore. The result is that there is what is termed a “continental shelf,” or border, around all the continents, on which these deposits are still accumulating, but beyond which they do not extend. Indeed, the true oceanic area begins with the edge of this continental shelf; and from this edge, the bottom rapidly sinks to the general level of the ocean floor.
Over this bottom of the ocean, with its cold, dark waters, there are no beds of sand or clay now being shifted or deposited; nothing but the slow accumulation of the slimy ooze formed by the silent dropping into these depths of the minute fragments of the millions of creatures, many of them microscopic in size, which live and die in the surface waters from one to six miles overhead. No gravel, no sand, no clay, is being moved or disturbed from end to end of the whole true bottom of the ocean. The materials now found throughout the whole of this vast extent are absolutely different from any deposits which we have yet discovered as composing the hills and lands of the continents—different, I mean, in their mechanical texture and make-up, and different in their method of formation.
Yet in the chalk cliffs of the south of England, of Kansas, and of many other localities, we have strata hundreds of miles in extent, composed of the very same kinds of microscopic remains which we now find over the larger part of the Atlantic bottom. In other localities we find brachiopods and crinoids, exactly like the modern kinds which live a mile or more down in the depths of the ocean. And the remarkable and telltale fact is that, in all these instances, these relics of the deep ocean are found mixed with or alternating with clays or sands or other materials derived from the lands, but which are not now associated with these deep-sea animals throughout the whole range of our modern ocean.
Thus in still another way we have evidence that the deposits composing our mountains and plains must have been formed by some very abnormal action of the waters of the ocean. Indeed, whenever we see these kinds of rocks, which now underlie such cities as St. Louis, Chicago, and London, they speak to us of that awful time in the long ago, when “the fountains of the great deep [were] broken up.” Practically all the limestone rocks found so generally throughout the world are composed of materials which thus afford us reminders and conclusive proof of the truth of the universal deluge.
Accordingly, we see that wherever we turn, the rocks contain within themselves evidence of the truthfulness of the Scriptural record.