AdventAI

THE EDITOR'S MAIL BAG

By Editor

From Review and Herald, Vol. 94, No. 19., May 10, 1917

When we published the letter from “A Mother” in the REVIEW of March 15, we did not anticipate that it would call forth so many expressions of approval from our readers. We have received during the last few days several letters regarding our denominational schools, and the spirit which should characterize the work they are endeavoring to do.

One of these letters comes from Prof. H. A. Washburn, head of the history department of Pacific Union College. He says:

Marks of Class Distinction

“I wish to express my appreciation of the letter which appeared in ‘The Editor’s Mail Bag,’ on March 15, from the mother with children in our schools, who has thus expressed her convictions. We need more such expressions from our people. A heavenly Instructor, in giving counsel to the Lord’s messenger, said: ‘The subject of education should interest the whole Seventh-day Adventist body. The decisions regarding the character of our school work should not be left wholly to principals and teachers.’—‘Testimonies for the Church,’ Vol. VI, p. 162.

“Students come yearly from the institutions of the world into our own schools, and constant attention must be given to prevent a molding after the customs of the world which is not in accordance with the spirit of our message. The hands of teachers who are contending for the original simplicity of our work are greatly strengthened by such words from parents, as they show the students that the teacher is not seeking to impose his will arbitrarily, but that he is maintaining the principles for which our people are maintaining these schools. . . .”

“It is my conviction that class activities and functions should not be so prominent as is now the case. I question whether we look at things as the angels do, when we allow so many marks of distinction between the senior class and the remainder of the school. I am glad to honor the graduating class, but every year at commencement time I look over the body of students beyond the row of graduates, and note the large number of earnest, faithful, godly students, who have been laborers together with God every day of their stay in the institution, many of whom in God’s providence are closing their school days without any tokens of honor or distinction, yet who will go forth to take their place among the strongest and best workers in our cause. It has always been thus, and it always will be. So, while we give deserved recognition to those completing their courses of study, let us limit the excessive amount of attention which this class receives.”

We believe, with Professor Washburn, that emphasis should be placed upon the need of close coöperation between parents and the teachers in our schools. We were impressed with this recently by the remark made by the president of one of our colleges, in response to an appeal from a mother, that the faculty of the school use its influence in discouraging the many social gatherings being held among the students, gatherings which this mother felt were a positive hindrance to earnest, substantial school work on the part of the students. The answer she received was, “If the fathers and mothers of our boys and girls would only coöperate with the faculty in this matter, the question would be easy of settlement and control. But in too many cases the parents, in place of discouraging these numerous gatherings, only aid and foster them.”

A Good Report from Walla Walla College

Prof. E. C. Kellogg, president of Walla Walla College, writes as follows:—

“I have been reading with interest what has been said with respect to simplicity in dress at commencement time. While it is not at all necessary, yet I have thought it would be all right to send you a few lines in regard to the way we do here. . . . Someway we have taken it right along as a matter of course that we would follow a plain and satisfactory plan. It has been my custom to meet with the class each year when they gather for organization, and give them a little advice, especially calling their attention to the need of being economical, not only with respect to the expenditure of money, but also with respect to the time they use in their class functions, asking, too, that they would remember the ideals of our work and school in simplicity and high standards of quality. To my mind the work has been carried forward in a satisfactory way. There has been no tendency to extravagance, and no difficulty in the class, to my knowledge.

“It is entirely probable that while we speak of the extravagance in the world in these matters, we realize that it is applicable only in part, for considerable attention has of late years been given to the matter of simplicity by high schools and other educational institutions, in respect to their commencement affairs. The inclosed clipping is no special exception, but is in line with considerable that is being done in outside schools.”

The extract Professor Kellogg inclosed reads thus:

“There is a feeling in Kansas and throughout the West that graduation dresses this year should be as simple as possible. In this time of national consecration to the service of the nation, simple white frocks are more in keeping with the spirit of the hour and the necessity we are all under of conserving our resources. In many Kansas towns either white frocks or dresses made of pretty print goods will be worn. The girls of the Sioux City (Iowa) high school are making their own dresses and using such simple fabrics. A neat and simple dress often adorns the wearer more than the showily flounced and beruffled creation that costs much more.”

We believe, in harmony with the custom prevailing in Walla Walla College, and we hope in all our colleges, that the faculty should exercise a molding influence in arranging for the exercises of commencement week. In years gone by we have known of instances in some of our training schools, where the students, instead of the teachers, created the school atmosphere, and molded its policies. Their inclinations and desires determined the standard of social life. They chose their own times for social gatherings, and determined who should act as their chaperons. They arranged the exercises of commencement week, with but little if any consultationp. 7 with their teachers. We believe there should be the closest coöperation in all our training schools, medical and evangelistic, between the teachers and the student body; but teachers who permit wrong influences to mold the school are certainly recreant to their sacred trust.

Our teachers are set in our training schools not only to conduct class exercises, but to teach by example as well as by precept. They are there to mold and fashion the young lives committed to their care. This they can do only as they act the part of leaders in the intellectual, spiritual, social, and industrial life of the school. But it is so easy in both the church and the school to sacrifice principle to popularity; to let down the standard to meet popular sentiment, to desire to be counted an agreeable teacher or preacher. Surely there should be no place either in our schools or in our pulpits for spineless teachers or preachers. God calls us in this work to be standard bearers; to hold aloft the banner of truth; to rally our fellows around that banner diplomatically, kindly, considerately. Failing to do this, we are untrue to the trust committed to us.

We present also at this time a letter from a graduate from one of our colleges. This sister is engaged in responsible work in the far West. By her request we omit her name:

Fighting the Spirit of the World

“As a graduate who has recently passed through a commencement at one of our colleges, I wish to indorse the protest of ‘A Mother,’ in the REVIEW of March 15. I know from experience the financial burden commencement extravagance places on many students. When, as I know has been a fact, the expense of the last week of school aggregates more than the whole year’s tuition, I think our sense of true values has become warped. But while I could say much in blame of what has been, I am more anxious to see a reform in the 1917 conditions.

“Cannot our seniors everywhere this year save by avoiding unnecessary display, and put the money into home and foreign missions? Money thus translated into the coin of the kingdom will always be a source of joy, not regret. And the joy of such service will deepen class mottoes, class-night speeches, and commencement addresses, into more than forms of words. This is a ‘war’ commencement, and our graduates should be fighting the spirit of the world as earnestly as the nations of the world are fighting each other.

“There is one form of graduation cost to which no one begrudges a cent—the class gift to their alma mater. Let more be expended in gratitude, and less in self-gratification.

“A wealthy sister in whose home I once worked, explained her simple method of dressing: ‘I will not dress so any one about me will feel uncomfortable or ashamed.’ The beauty of that spirit outshone her richest silks. Surely our seniors can set standards of dress that will not shame or burden classmates, nor force any to forego graduating with their class.

“I wish to make a heartfelt protest against the hypocrisy of the obligatory gift system. I remember yet with a heartache how, when I sent an old friend an announcement, I received promptly a gift with only name card inclosed,—not one loving word,—as if I had sent her a tax assessment. Another friend whom I thought I was complimenting assured me that when she was not so hard up she would make me a gift. The sting of that unjust misconstruction is sharp yet. Let me defend the graduates from the selfishness of people who feel obliged to gratify their own pride and self-esteem by making gifts when what we would rather have is loving words straight from the heart.

“Who knows how many more commencements our schools will enjoy? Cannot the seniors of ’17 make their class program one of real consecration, by seeing to it that none of the means provided by the sacrifices of parents are spent in mere gratification of sense?”

The practical suggestions made in this letter are worthy of careful consideration by all interested in the true prosperity of our schools.

A Worthy Example

The senior class of Pacific Union College proposes this year to follow the plan suggested in this letter. Writing to Elder J. L. Shaw of the Mission Board, under date of April 12, Chester A. Holt says: “The senior class of Pacific Union College has voted to dispense with certain class festivities, and devote the money which would have been spent in that manner to the support of a native worker in China.” He asks for instruction from the Mission Board as to how this plan can be made effective.

We greatly appreciate this spirit, which surely presents a worthy example for the classes of our training schools, both medical and evangelistic, which will finish their courses during the next few months.

We have appreciated the interchange of thought expressed in these communications which we have printed from time to time, but perhaps it would not be profitable to continue at this time further discussion of the question. F. M. W.