FURTHER INDICTMENTS OF THE MOVIES

7%

Review and Herald Publishing Association · Takoma Park Station, Washington, D. C. · Aug 9, 1917

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 94, No. 32.

Read the full edition

FURTHER INDICTMENTS OF THE MOVIES

MRS. I. H. EVANS
In the Pictorial Review for July, Channing Pollock discusses the movies from the authors’ point of view, and asks the public not to blame the men and women who write the tales that are recast and put on the films, for what they see there. One woman who went to the “projection-room” to see the filming of a play which she had written, says:
“In the beginning, I could discover nothing that even remotely resembled my story. ‘We were obliged to arrange a little introduction,’ apologized the president. That didn’t seem to explain transferring the scene of action from Paris to Chinatown, in New York. However, I ‘sat tight’ while my fashionable hero raved because another man danced with his wife at a ball, and it was only when we came to a gratuitously inserted sensation, when this other man attempted a violent embrace, and her hair came down, and her dress began to come off, that I left my heroine to her fate, and the projection-room to its intimate revelations. ‘Take my name off that film!’ I demanded—and they did!”
Another well-known writer, seeing a film made from one of her stories, declared that “it was extraordinarily confused, and so incoherent that, unless I had been somewhat familiar with the story, I could not possibly have understood what it was all about.”
Commenting on these incidents, and certain experiences of his own, Mr. Channing says:
“Mere lack of training hardly accounts for the blindness with which stories are remade in the motion picture studios, or for the fashion in which their meaning is lost, their themes distorted, and their very narration jumbled and jig-sawed. . . .
“Crime, of course, is the chief reliance of workers through a medium of expression capable of interpreting only physical action. Roy McCardell is one of nine authors who have complained to me of the introduction, without a ‘by-your-leave,’ of burglars into photo-plays innocent of them in the beginning. . . . Take out of the ‘movies’ rough-and-tumble comedy, fustian patriotism, illicit sex relation, crime, violence, and nudity, and see how much material is left to keep going the fourth greatest industry in America!
“‘Off with his head,’ cried Richard; ‘so much for Buckingham!’ ‘Off with their clothes,’ command the motion picture producers; ‘so much for the box office!’ Scarcely a big feature film, from ‘Purity’ to ‘Intolerance’ and ‘A Daughter of the Gods,’ but has made its appeal through public craving for an increased knowledge of anatomy. In the ordinary ‘five-reeler,’ it is sometimes difficult to carry on the educational work, because, despite present modes in the matter of negligee, Broadway doesn’t offer the opportunities of Babylon. However, giving justice where justice is due, the powers that be in motion pictures do their best. There are conspicuous exceptions, but the average director might guarantee to get ‘the female form divine’ into the filming of almost any performance. A friend of mine wagered five dollars that it could not be done with ‘The Poor Little Rich Girl,’—and he lost. . . .
“At the present time,” continues Mr. Pollock, the specialty of the “movies” is—
“Laura Jean Libbey and Bertha M. Clay. If this statement seems harsh, or you doubt it, read the titles in front of any ‘movie’ theater, or in any of the trade journals: ‘The Dancer’s Peril,’ ‘The Mortal Sin,’ ‘The Web of Desire,’ ‘The Price of Her Soul,’ ‘A Woman’s Awakening,’ ‘The Lady Detective,’ ‘The Sweetheart of the Doomed,’ ‘The Perils of Our Girl Reporters!’ Subject these stories, or the slightly better ones handled by the Frohmans of the Film, to the test of print, and tell me in what respect they rise above the level of the dime novel and the family story paper. Crime and violence, sex and the slap-stick!
“At best, it is an open question whether they do not destroy concentration, atrophy imagination, unmake readers, encourage lazy-mindedness, overglorify the physical, develop the sense of hurry, create a craving for sensation, establish thrill and ‘punch’ as the essentials of literature and drama.”
Everywhere thinking men and women condemn in unsparing terms the increasing vulgarity of the films. The editor of the Washington Evening Star, in its issue of July 4, said:
“An extraordinary development of the motion picture enterprise is the evolution of a capacity on the part of a large proportion of the public to enjoy vulgarity. Multitudes of refined persons who before the advent of the motion picture as a means of entertainment would have been shocked beyond endurance by such displays, will sit and roar in enjoyment of supposedly funny antics by famous film clowns without any sign on the part of the audience of disapproval or distaste.”
When we remember that these words are written by men of the world, and wholly from a worldly viewpoint, we must admit the gravity of the charge they contain. Those who would keep their children from the insidious suggestions of evil offered by ordinary moving pictures, will be very likely to find that the only consistent course is to forego them altogether.