AdventAI

Shall We Have a Wandering Sabbath?

By Francis D. Nichol

From Review and Herald, Vol. 106, No. 14., April 4, 1929

No. 10. Was Moses the Author of the Blank-Day Principle?

OUR article last week set forth the astonishing claim of the calendar reformers that Moses was the author of the blank-day principle, that he gave to the ancient Israelites a perpetual calendar, and that the present calendar revisers are endeavoring simply to revive the essential features of that calendar. In order to consider the claim in any conclusive way, we allowed the authors—Marvin and Cotsworth—to state their case quite fully without interrupting with any objections along the way. It will be our purpose in this and succeeding articles to consider in order the evidence they presented. If the reader has before him last week’s article, he will more easily follow the thread of the argument.

The authors declared repeatedly that, from a civil standpoint, the Mosaic calendar was “nearly perfect,” and that from a religious standpoint it was absolutely necessary to the proper observance of the various feasts, etc. And seeing that such a calendar was imperative, therefore, what else can this reconstructed calendar be but the one which Moses gave to the Israelites? This is the general, all-pervasive argument that runs through the authors’ pamphlet.

The first question, therefore, that presents itself, is this: If Moses gave to the Jewish nation such a perfect calendar, so excellent from a civil standpoint and so indispensable to the successful carrying out of their ceremonial ritual, why did the Jews discard it? The authors declare:

“After many centuries of use, [this calendar] was for unrecorded reasons replaced by the more primitive form of a lunisolar calendar,—the change probably resulted from the destruction of the first temple and its archives about 587 B. C., when the Babylonians took captive the people of Israel.

“Although the lunisolar calendar was unscriptural in origin, and even in its more perfect form, introduced large seasonal fluctuations which amounted to twenty-eight days in extreme cases, it seems to have been adopted through the combined effects of exile, foreign influence, and innovations.”—Page 7.

They refer, of course, to the calendar now in use among the Jews, which consists of twelve months generally alternating twenty-nine and thirty days, and which, so far as virtually all Jewish scholars are concerned, is the only calendar the Jews ever had.

Why Did the Jews Abandon the Calendar?

Why should “exile, foreign influence, and innovations” have caused the Israelites to abandon so valuable, so indispensable a possession as this supposed Mosaic calendar? They were in Babylon only seventy years, too short a time for them to forget their former national life. In fact, when the second temple was built, the ancient men wept because they remembered how the first temple looked. Ezra 3:12. Further, upon returning from captivity, the Jews proceededp. 17 with a vehemence born of penitence, to restore and to carry out all the instructions that Moses had enjoined. Their captivity, instead of causing a departure from Mosaic practices, resulted in the very opposite. So vigorous did this reformation become that for a fourth part of the day the people listened to the reading of the law and for a fourth part they confessed their sins, recounting the experience of their fathers from the time of the exodus, and covenanted with God to walk in His ways. Nehemiah 9.

Now a calendar is not a minor feature in national life, at least not in ancient Jewish life, for, according to these authors, “the Mosaic calendar and code of laws were two essential parts of one great ritual.”—Page 8. Too many memories and associations cluster around a calendar, too many secular and religious events are remembered in terms of it, to make the changing of it an easy affair. To this fact the present-day calendar reformers must sadly agree. A concrete illustration of the opposition which calendar changes produce is found in Rumania, where some half million people have risen up in rebellion against the plan to readjust the calendar in regard simply to one church festival—Easter.

Wholly Incredible

If these present reformers, with limitless money and organizations behind them, are finding such tremendous difficulties in persuading the nations to accept a calendar change that would confessedly have numerous advantages, how are we to believe that the ancient Jewish people, who were more tenacious of established customs than we would dream of being, and who at approximately the time of this alleged calendar change were in the midst of a mighty revival of ancient practices, should have willingly exchanged the “nearly perfect” Mosaic calendar for a “more primitive,” “unscriptural” one? Did they revive the Mosaic code of laws, and yet discard the calendar without which, these authors allege, the laws could not truly be carried out? Surely this passes the bounds of credibility.

But passing over the bounds of credibility, let us proceed to an examination of the detailed points. However, before doing so, we wish to acknowledge our great indebtedness to the Rev. Dr. Moses Hyamson, LL. D., rabbi of Orach Chaim (Path of Life) Congregation, New York, and professor of codes at the Jewish Theological Seminary of America, New York. Rabbi Hyamson gave to us more than a whole day of his valuable time in explanation of the various customs of the ancient Israelites and in elucidation of Scriptural passages that the calendar reformers have misapplied. He is regarded not only by his orthodox associates, but also by reformed rabbis, as one of the most learned of Hebrew scholars.

Examine First Link in Evidence

The first point the authors attempt to make is that the Mosaic calendar was solar. This, of course, gave them their foundation for the statement that it consisted of 365 days. Well, let us grant, for the sake of argument, and in order to avoid a technical discussion, that it was solar. What does that prove?—Nothing in particular. Our present calendar is solar, but that gives to it no unusual perpetual qualities. However, the reader of the pamphlet is led to feel that when the solar nature of the Mosaic calendar is established, the other features naturally follow. This feeling is strengthened by the fact that Dr. Julian Morgenstern and Prof. W. A. Heidel—whose views on the solar nature of the ancient Jewish calendar are mentioned in the main text of the pamphlet—are listed along with Samuel Walter Gamble, the father of the whole theory, in a footnote entitled, “Some Authorities We Quote.” Wep. 18 therefore wrote to both these Hebrew scholars, informing them of the theory set forth in this pamphlet, and stated in our letter:

“The writers of this pamphlet quote you as one of the authorities in support of the major premise of their thesis, because of your contribution on the calendar of ancient Israel. Your name and the quotations from your work, placed as they are in this pamphlet under the general head, ‘Some Authorities We Quote,’ lead the general reader to the impression that your researches warrant the ultimate conclusions to which the writers of the pamphlet come. I wish to inquire whether I would be correct in obtaining this impression. In other words, have your researches led you to believe, as do the writers of this pamphlet, that Moses devised a perpetual calendar that placed the Sabbath in a fixed relationship to the month, necessitating the existence each year of an extra Sabbath?”

Hebrew Scholars Reply

The essence of Dr. Heidel’s brief reply is found in this one sentence from his letter: “Messrs. Marvin and Cotsworth have quite absolutely misrepresented my views.”

We quote more in detail from the reply of Dr. Morgenstern, because of his observations concerning a certain calendar which some one tried unsuccessfully to introduce in the third century B. C.:

“THE HEBREW UNION COLLEGE “Cincinnati, Ohio “Office of the President. “January 30, 1929. “MY DEAR MR. NICHOL: “Replying to yours of the 24th inst., I am very happy to be able to assure you that Messrs. Marvin and Cotsworth have used my name in their propaganda for the new calendar entirely without my authorization and knowledge, and that the quotations from my article on ‘The Three Calendars of Ancient Israel’ apparently altogether misrepresent the facts with regard to the history of the calendar of ancient Israel which I have been able to establish. . . . “Certainly I did not advance the thesis ‘that the ancient Jews lived under a fixed or perpetual calendar devised by Moses, which caused the Sabbath always to recur on the same days of the month each year, instead of being an institution related only to the week, as we now have it.’ On the contrary, I showed in this article that, at various times in the history of ancient Israel, different calendar systems were employed, that up to approximately 621 B. C. the old Canaanitish calendar, a purely solar calendar, taking cognizance of the days of the solar equinoxes, was employed in ancient Israel. Then from about 621 to a time somewhat later than 400 B. C., another calendar, apparently a lunisolar calendar, was employed, based apparently largely upon some Babylonian model. It apparently took no cognizance whatever of the Sabbath, which continued a weekly institution, falling upon any date in the month, regardless of any considerations other than that the Sabbath came every seventh day. At some time after 400 B. C., the calendar at present employed by the Jewish Church, also based upon Babylonian antecedents, was instituted. This also makes no effort to co-ordinate the Sabbath with any particular days or dates in the month. “ I showed likewise that at some time, probably in the third century B. C., an attempt was made to introduce into ancient Israel a calendar similar to that which Mr. Cotsworth is championing, with the year divided into thirteen months of twenty-eight days, and with particular attention given to the coincidence of the Sabbath with a particular date in each month, probably the seventh, fourteenth, twenty-first, and twenty-eighth days. This calendar is employed as the basis of reckoning in the books of Jubilees and Enoch, two pseudepigraphical writings which were never regarded as authoritative. This calendar, however, was never recognized as official by Judaism and never came into actual use. Furthermore, Moses himself had no connection whatsoever with any of these calendars. It is clear therefore, that the above-named gentlemen have either not troubled to read my article carefully, or, if they did, have not understood it or have not wanted to understand it. Certainly, the facts which they state and the conclusions which they drew from them are altogether unwarranted by my article. “I trust that this gives you the information which you desire. “Very sincerely yours, “[Signed] JULIAN MORGENSTERN, “President.”

Not only did the ancient Jews not have such a fixed calendar as the authors claim, but when some one tried to introduce one, they refused to accept it! And no matter what sort of calendar was in use, the weekly Sabbath was in no way affected by it. Further comment on this letter is superfluous. Let us therefore examine the next point.

No Proof for Next Point

The authors declare that Moses inserted a leap week every twenty-eight years. The only “proof” that was cited in behalf of this was that Moses was too wise a statesman not to have done so, and that unless he had done so, “his wonderful calendar system” would have collapsed. The only point certain is that the “wonderful calendar system” of the authors will collapse without the leap-week feature. There is no proof in the world that Moses employed it. Thus the theory might properly be repudiated at this juncture because of resting on an assumption.

The next link in the chain is the claim that Moses divided his calendar into twelve thirty-day months, with five supplementary days that could be inserted between the months where needed. Unless he did thus divide the months, the theory could not be made to work. In other words, unless he followed the Egyptian division of months, the theory collapses. But again are we confronted with an assumption, for the authors simply assume that he did. Now when the foundations of a theory rest upon the quicksands of assumption, it is really unnecessary to demolish the superstructure, for the whole edifice is certain to collapse anyway. That the superstructure is no more solid than the foundation, will become evident as we proceed.

Another Unwarranted Assumption

Before proceeding to a consideration of the chief argument for the theory, we wish parenthetically to insert here a brief examination of three texts in Exodus 19, which the authors quote in support of their claims, but which we did not mention in our summary of their argument last week. The first text is as follows: “In the third month after the children of Israel were gone forth out of the land of Egypt, the same day [that is the third day] came they into the wilderness of Sinai, . . . and there Israel encamped before the mount.” Ex. 19:1, 2.

They then quote a portion of the 10th and 11th verses, which read as follows: “And Jehovah said unto Moses, Go unto the people, and sanctify them to-day and to-morrow, and let them wash their garments, and be ready against the third day; for the third day Jehovah will come down in the sight of all the people upon Mt. Sinai.”

They are endeavoring by these texts to support their contention that Pentecost came on the fifth day of the third month (Sivan), as their reconstructed calendar shows it. Their argument in brief is this:

1. That according to Jewish tradition the law was proclaimed from Mt. Sinai on Pentecost; in other words, that Pentecost is a memorial of that great event.

2. That the Israelites reached Mt. Sinai on the third day of the third month.

3. That the three days mentioned in verses 10 and 11 of this chapter should begin with the third day of the month, thus causing the last of the three days of sanctification—the day when Jehovah came down and delivered the law, in other words, Pentecost—to come on the fifth day of the third month, as their calendar places it.

Let us now examine these three propositions. Even if their reasoning and interpretation of these scriptures were correct, the claims of the authors would not receive very much help. But both reasoning and interpretation are open to the most serious question.

The bracketed phrase in the first verse: “that is the third day,” is inserted by them as an interpretation of the Scriptural phrase “the same day.” But Jewish scholars explain that in the Hebrew “the same day” is an indefinite phrase, and cannot properly be forced to refer back to the “third month.” Unbroken Jewish tradition has understood “the same day” to mean the first dayp. 19 of that month. Thus the authors are in the peculiar position of accepting Jewish tradition in order to establish the first of their three propositions—namely, that the law was proclaimed on Pentecost—and rejecting Jewish tradition in order to establish the second point—namely, that the Israelites reached Sinai on the third day of the month. This is really quite an unusual situation.

Christian commentators are quite generally in agreement with Jewish scholars in regard to this passage, at least as regards the point that nothing definite can be understood by “the same day.” We give one typical quotation. Lange, in his critical commentary on the Old Testament, thus observes:

“The same day.—According to the Jewish tradition this means on the first day of the third month, but grammatically it may be taken more indefinitely—‘at this time.’”—“A Commentary on the Holy Scriptures,” by John Peter Lange, translated by Philip Schaff, Vol. II of the Old Testament, p. 69.

But even if it be granted that there may possibly be some defense for understanding “the same day” as meaning the third day of the month, the authors would not have established any sort of case. They must still prove that the words of Jehovah to Moses to sanctify the people “to-day and to-morrow,” etc., as given in verses 10 and 11, were uttered the same day that the Israelites reached Mt. Sinai. Unless they can do this, their third proposition collapses. But no proof can possibly be given for this claim, and every presumption is against it.

Questionable Chronology

If the whole passage from the first verse to the eleventh is read, it will be noted that after the Israelites reached Sinai, Moses went up into the mount (verse 3), and communed for a time with God. How long, we know not. Next, that he descended from the mount (verse 7), and told the people what God had said to him. How much time this consumed, we know not. Next, that Moses reported to Jehovah what the people had said (verse 8), and that following these communications the Lord made the statement concerning the sanctifying of the people “against the third day.” The Scriptures do not divulge how much time elapsed in connection with these conversations, and it is only unwarranted assumption that would declare that the whole passage must bear the date of the first verse, whatever that date may be.

If that sort of assumption is to be employed in determining the dates of events, we can quickly bring the authors’ theory into hopeless straits by turning to the sixteenth chapter of Exodus. There we read that the Israelites entered the wilderness of Sin on “the fifteenth day of the second month.” Verse 1. The next two verses immediately declare that they murmured, craving the fleshpots of Egypt. Then immediately follows the statement of Jehovah (verse 4) that He “will rain bread from heaven,” and that “it shall come to pass on the sixth day, that they shall prepare that which they bring in, and it shall be twice as much as they gather daily.” Verse 5. Then Moses declares to the people that “in the morning” the people would have “bread to the full.” Verses 7, 8. Then follows the story of how “in the morning” (verse 13) the people saw the manna lying on the ground, and gathered it up. Then, that “they gathered it morning by morning” (verse 21) until the “sixth day” arrived, when Moses informed them, “To-morrow is a solemn rest, a holy Sabbath unto Jehovah.” Verse 23.

Their Weapons Turn Against Them

Now if we are to date this whole passage in terms of the date given at the head of the narrative,—“the fifteenth of the second month,”—we would conclude that the Israelites murmured the very day they arrived in this wilderness, and that the phrase “in the morning” applied to the very next morning, namely, the sixteenth. But if the sixteenth be the first of six days of gathering manna, then the sixth day, on which they gathered twice as much, would come on the twenty-first and the Sabbath on the twenty-second day of that second month. A glance at the accompanying calendar will illustrate this clearly. But it will also reveal that the authors have listed this twenty-second day in a “workday column.” Thus according to the very rule that they have followed in trying to establish their point in the nineteenth chapter, we can bring their calendar into confusion by the incidents related in the sixteenth chapter.

Now, let us make it clear that we do not necessarily hold that on the morning immediately after the fifteenth day of the second month, the manna began to fall. We simply contend that it would be as logical to maintain this as for the authors to maintain the position they take on the nineteenth chapter, and that by thus employing this principle in both chapters—for a principle of chronological interpretation ought to be able to work in more than one chapter—the theory is brought into confusion.

The Heart of the Argument

Now if the reader has before him last week’s article, he will see that the remainder of the theory has to do with the question of the various annual sabbaths in the Jewish ritual. The essence of this part of their argument is that—

1. The Sabbath command simply means six days of work followed by a seventh day of rest.

2. The annual sabbaths are commandment Sabbaths.

3. Counting “seven sabbaths” from the Passover sabbath on the fifteenth of the first month (Abib) brings us to the fourth day of the third month (Sivan); but the “morrow after the seventh sabbath,” Sivan 5, being Pentecost, which was also an annual sabbath, gives us an extra sabbath, and this must be placed in the “Sabbath column” in the calendar.

4. Now the command to work six days is just as mandatory as the command to rest on the seventh, therefore the double sabbath of the fourth and fifth of Sivan must be followed by six days of work before the next sabbath. This results in giving us a blank day so far as the week is concerned. And this, of course, results in eliminating the one day over fifty-two full weeks in a 365-day calendar year.

The remarkable feature in connection with this line of reasoning is that even granting these four points, the reconstructed calendar will not operate rightly. This is easily made evident. What does the Bible say concerning the nature of Pentecost? We read: “There shall be a holy convocation unto you; ye shall do no servile work.” Lev. 23:21. It is because of this statement that the authors place Pentecost in the “sabbath column” of their calendar, “since it could not, by any rational procedure, be put in any one of the workday columns.”—Pages 14, 15.

With this as our guide as to which days should be placed in the “sabbath column,” let us now consider some other scriptures. We read: “In the first month [Abib], on the fourteenth day of the month at even, is Jehovah’s Passover. And on the fifteenth day of the same month is the feast of unleavened bread unto Jehovah: seven days ye shall eat unleavened bread. In the first day ye shall have a holy convocation; ye shall do no servile work.” Lev. 23:5-7. Because of this the authors place the fifteenth of Abib in the “sabbath column.” But the next verse declares: “In the seventh day is a holy convocation; ye shall do no servile work.” Identical language is employed to describe the nature of the “first day” and the “seventh day” of the feast of unleavened bread. Now if the fifteenth day is the “first day” of the feast, the twenty-first is the “seventh day” of it. And if the fifteenth belongs in the “Sabbath column” then the twenty-first belongs there also. But the calendar does not place it there. Why? The authorsp. 20 do not explain. Again are we justified in repudiating this supposed calendar.

Day of Atonement Destroys Theory

Come now to the seventh month. On the strength of the command that the first, fifteenth, and twenty-second of the seventh month were to be holy convocations to the Lord, in which “no servile work” was to be done, the authors place these three days in the “Sabbath column.” But the tenth day of that month, the Day of Atonement,—that day which was a “sabbath of sabbaths,” to translate literally the original, on which not only “servile work,” but “any manner of work,” was forbidden under penalty of death,—is placed in a “workday column.” Now if Pentecost, on which only “servile work” was prohibited, “could not, by any rational procedure, be put in any one of the workday columns,” no possible sophistry can justify placing the Day of Atonement, the tenth day of the seventh month, in “any one of the workday columns.” The endeavor of the authors, as quoted last week, to avoid this irresistible conclusion, serves only to reveal more clearly the desperate plight in which this Atonement Day sabbath places them. They strive to show an analogy between the choosing of the Passover lamb on the tenth of the first month and the Atonement Day on the tenth of the seventh month. Their objective is not quite clear, but their attempted analogy is absurd. When we read it to Rabbi Hyamson, he threw up his hands in a gesture of horror and disgust. For to all devout Jews Atonement Day holds a place far above all other annual sabbaths, and is above analogy to any other activity of the year.

The authors attempt to argue that because the first, fifteenth, and twenty-second of that month are sabbaths, revealing an obvious seven-day spacing between them, therefore the tenth day must be considered as something different and relegated to a “workday column.” What need is there to answer such reasoning? The very same Bible chapter that declares that those three days are sabbaths, declares also, and in more emphatic language, that the tenth day of the month is a sabbath of sabbaths.

Must Surrender Another Claim

Furthermore, with this tenth day of the seventh month allowed to come in a “workday column,” what becomes of their interpretation that “the command to work six days is just as binding as the one to rest on the seventh”? How could a man put in six days of labor between the eighth and the fifteenth of that month, seeing he must wholly abstain from work on the tenth? Simple arithmetic prevents that. Now if the Sabbath commandment does not here demand six days of work following a Sabbath, then how can it be made to demand it in connection with Pentecost? But if the demand be surrendered, then the whole argument based on the “extra sabbath” at Pentecost collapses. In other words, if during the seventh month a man need work only four days between the sabbath of the tenth and the sabbath of the fifteenth, why is it necessary that during the third month he must work six days following the sabbath of the fifth (Pentecost) before he can have a sabbath day’s rest again?

Therefore this marvelous calendar cannot be made to operate successfully, even when we accept the premises set forth by the authors themselves. This is truly a most remarkable situation. The two most basic propositions in their argument cannot be held at the same time. They set forth that (1) the Sabbath commandment means simply six days of work followed by a seventh day of rest, both the work and the rest being commanded; and that (2) the annual sabbaths are commandment Sabbaths.

A Dilemma Confronts Them

If the first of these be true, then the second proves false, because, for example, there are not six working days between the sabbath days of the fifteenth and twenty-first of the first month, or between the tenth and the fifteenth of the seventh month. But if the second be true,—if the annual sabbaths which are found at such unequal distances from each other in the months, be intended by the Sabbath commandment,—what then does that command mean when it speaks of six days for work and the seventh day for rest? The seventh day of what? Not the seventh day of the month, that would not operate. Not simply a seventh day following six days of labor, for we have already shown that in the first and seventh months this method of reckoning would have been mathematically impossible of application. Into what confusion would those ancient Israelites around Mt. Sinai have been brought had they attempted to employ the premises of these calendar reformers to the understanding of the Sabbath commandment!

Yes, and into what confusion are the calendar reformers, and all such Sunday advocates as interpret the fourth commandment to mean simply one day’s rest in seven, brought when they are confronted with the actual facts concerning the uneven spacing out of the annual sabbath days in the first and seventh months!

F. D. N.

(To be continued)