THE ARKANSAS SENATE VOTES TO REPEAL THE SUNDAY EXEMPTION STATUTE.
By L. A. S.
The Arkansas Senate has put itself on record again in the matter of religious toleration, by undoing, so far as in its power, the work so ably championed by Senator Crockett at its last session. It has passed a bill repealing the exemption clause in the State laws relative to Sunday observance which permitted observers of the seventh day to go quietly about their accustomed labor on the day following. The bill repealing the exemption was introduced by Senator J. N. Tillman, of Washington County. We are indebted to a brother in Little Rock for a clipping from the Arkansas Gazette of March 5, giving the speech of Mr. Tillman on the occasion, and the opinions called forth from other senators. The former is about as outspoken and characteristic of the spirit of the Sunday-law movement, as anything we have yet seen. We will let our readers judge for themselves. This is what he said:— Mr. President: I assume that Christianity is the true religion, and that the first day of the week is the Christian Sabbath. The Christian Sabbath is an institution of God Almighty, and should be respected as such, and if assailed, the civil law should be invoked to protect it. This bill provides for the general observance of the first day of the week as a day of rest from secular enjoyments, other than those of necessity, comfort, or charity. It is in the nature of a civil regulation only. It is not of the character of State protection to church. It does not seek to violate the principle that affairs of church and state should be kept separate. It interferes in no way with the full and free exercise of religious freedom. The State has a right by legislative enactment to provide for the observance of the Sabbath day, and to punish a violator of the same, and keep within the purview of the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of the State of Arkansas. The Supreme Court of this State, in the case of the State against Seoles, decided that the law of 1885, which the bill seeks to revive, was Constitutional. I have a local interest in the measure. In my county (Washington) we have a religious sect known as the Seventh-day Adventists, a very devout and respectable people, but they labor on our Sabbath, and greatly annoy the Christian people of that section. In Springdale, where most of these people live, there exists a very great demand for the passage of this bill. I promised those people to introduce a bill of this kind. I have done so, and worked earnestly for its passage; and if it does pass this Senate, I will meet a hearty “well done” from my friends there, on my return from my labors here. I want to ask senators who vote against the bill if they would like to have their children raised in a community where they would be compelled to see the Christian Sabbath desecrated. What effect would it have on a child to pass, on the way to church or Sunday-school, men plowing or reaping in the fields, when you are doing all you can to bring it up in the way it should go? I imagine you, gentlemen, would not relish exposure of this kind. If you lived in Springdale for a few months, your opinions on the “religious liberty” function would undergo a radical change. Those Seventh-day Adventists are generally good citizens, but they have become very aggressive since the passage of the Sunday law of two years ago, and our people are getting very tired of them. The senator from Independence suggests that if this bill should pass, it will drive these people from the State. That would not be a serious loss. There would be fewer Sabbath-breakers to deal with. After having left Arkansas, they might very truly exclaim:— “True patriots are we,
For be it understood,
We left our country
For our country’s good.”
How this speech was received by the Senate is shown in the following:— Senator Brickell said that he entertained his own ideas on theology, and that while he was neglectful of his religious duties, he was always consoled by the knowledge that there were at his home a wife and a mother whose prayers were constantly offered up for him, and he knew by their experience that their religion was not a myth; and that he wanted all possible protection thrown around them in the enjoyment of their religious worship. He paid a high tribute to his venerable predecessor, the honorable Robert H. Crockett, but on this question he was here to undo what his more brilliant and experienced predecessor had done. Senator Byrne opposed the bill. He knew a large element of his constituents were opposed to the bill, and would have petitions before this body, protesting against the bill, if they had known of the manifest determination to pass it. He had never heard of but one instance where the law had worked a hardship, and that was the one cited by the senator from Washington County (Tillman), and that this legislation was in the interest of Springdale township, in that county. He thought that the long-established principle to worship God according to the dictates of one’s conscience was the foundation of our Government; that Saturday being the Sabbath of the Bible, and a sect preferring to observe that as a day of worship, they had a right to do so, but this bill sought to force them to observe another, and thus compel the minority, on a question affecting the conscience, to submit to the tyranny of the majority. If this law sought to be repealed by the bill, has worked a hardship nowhere except in Springdale township, Washington County, it is an admirable one, for there are few laws that do not work hardships. . . . Senator Crandell saw no harm in the existing statute; it was only religious toleration. Senator Martin knew, if the existing statute was repealed, that some of the best citizens in the State would leave the State. He was in favor of the highest possible attainment of religious liberty. He was opposed to prescribing a day or the manner for religious worship by law. Every sect should be allowed to observe the day of their choice. He said that it was not denied that our Saturday was the Sabbath of the Bible. Senator W. E. Davidson hoped that the bill would pass. He was opposed to any religious oppression. To keep the Sabbath does not mean to quit work ourselves, but that all citizens should be compelled to forego their avocation on that day. He thought we could better afford to lose citizens who would leave the State than to desecrate the Christian Sabbath; that we cannot maintain and protect more than one Sabbath. The tendency is to destroy the Christian Sabbath, and strip it of its sacredness; and the time will come when we cannot convict a man for Sabbath-breaking, if this tendency continues. Senator Warren wanted the bill passed. He said that dangerous inroads were being made on the Christian Sabbath; that it ought to be sacredly guarded. Senator Miller, having carefully considered the bill, and the law it sought to repeal, had decided to oppose the passage of the bill. To abridge in any way the laws of personal liberty, he thought to be wrong in spirit and wrong in theory. He held his membership in the Methodist Church, because he thought it the most liberal. He thought the bill proposed the worst kind of religious intolerance. When the question was put, the bill passed. Ayes 16; noes 11. This does not of course give the repeal the force of law, as the bill must still be referred to the House, and finally, if successful there, receive the signature of the governor, or be passed over his veto, before it can acquire the force of a State enactment; but it has gained a good start, and it remains to be seen what success it will meet with further. The brother above referred to writes us that on receipt of this intelligence he at once obtained an interview with the governor, who promised that should the bill pass the House, he would give it deep thought before affixing his signature; but he stated at the same time that the legislature had already passed two bills over his veto. National Reform tracts were also placed in the hands of each member of the House. Further steps will at once be taken to follow up this work. L. A. S.