HOW IT WOULD WORK

11%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 12, 1889

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 66, No. 11.

Read the full edition

HOW IT WOULD WORK.

As has already been mentioned in the REVIEW, Seventh-day Adventists and Seventh-day Baptists stand on different ground in their opposition to Sunday legislation. This was apparent in the different positions taken by the representatives of the two bodies at the hearing on the Sunday-rest bill before the Senate Committee on Education and Labor. Dr. Lewis would have allowed the bill to pass, with the addition of an exemption clause in favor of observers of the seventh day and the omission of one or two phrases conferring a religious character upon Sunday. Eld. Jones opposed the bill in toto, and with reference to an exemption clause, said:—
Suppose an exemption clause is given. There are people who will profess to be Seventh-day Adventists for the express purpose of getting chances to open saloons or houses of business on Sunday. Therefore, in outright self-defense, the majority will have to repeal the exemption clause in defense of themselves.
Replying to which, the former speaker attempted to justify his position by claiming that “the possibility of any such deceitful claim could be easily guarded against by a provision requiring that in any case of doubt the one claiming to have observed the seventh day should be required to bring official certificate of his relation to a Sabbath-keeping church.”
This objection offered by Eld. Jones to such a compromise was alluded to as “wholly imaginary.” So, perhaps, it was considered by many others who read the Senate report. But now evidence comes to hand that at least one attempt has been made to do the very thing which that objection defined; namely, to use the exemption for the mere ends of business profit. It is as follows, taken from the Plainfield [N. J.] Times:—
As a rule, Plainfield, N. J., is a very quiet city on Sunday. Liquor, provision, and cigar stores are closed by the enforcement of a city ordinance. If a resident wants a cigar, he will either have it given to him by one of the many pharmacists who refuse to sell on Sunday, or he will go to the two dealers who are allowed to open their places on Sunday because they observe Saturday as their Sabbath. Some time ago a man of Catholic faith, who had an eye to Sunday business in that line, became a regular attendant at the Seventh-day Baptist Church. Eventually he asked to be admitted into the fellowship of the church. A member of the official board was advised that the applicant for membership was only working for business ends. He was closely examined by the church officers, and he finally admitted that he wanted to open a cigar store and do business on Sunday. The man appeared at the wrong place for aid in carrying out his mercenary purposes. He was not received into membership.
Thus the very ones who have produced the claim that no one could take hypocritical advantage of the provision upon which they sought to base a compromise with the Sunday bill, are the first to be selected as the victims of such an attempt. True, in this instance the hypocrisy of the attempt was discovered, and the request of the applicant was not granted. But would the Seventh-day Baptist or any other church be able to detect hypocrisy in every case, or even the majority of cases, which might arise in the same way? And further than this, such a provision could even be taken advantage of by liquor-dealers or any others with impunity; for notice, it does not specify that a person shall hold membership in any church to be exempt from the rigors of the Sunday-law, but only that he shall be an observer of the seventh day. This claim anybody could make for mere business advantage, and no one would be able to prove to the contrary.
The fact that such a tendency already exists, under the present mild Sunday regimen, plainly justifies the conclusion expressed in the paragraph first quoted from the hearing on the Sunday-rest bill.
L. A. S.