DEBATE AT WINONA, MINN.
By L. R. Conradi
From Jan. 28–30, I visited the church at Winona, and at the same time attended a debate on the immortality question, which was to take place on the 29th, between Mr. Bush, the German Presbyterian clergyman, and some minister of our faith. I was glad to find quite a company of Sabbath-keepers here, and a neat little church-building, which was well filled. The coming debate seemed to create quite a stir. According to previous arrangements, each side was to choose three judges and they a seventh; thus, much depended upon this seventh man's being one who would judge according to the arguments, and not from personal convictions. As Prof. Holzinger, of the State Normal school, had been recommended to us, we waited upon him, to learn whether he would accept; but we never asked him about his personal views. He consented, and was, when proposed, unanimously chosen. Each speaker was to have the floor three times, Mr. Bush affirming that the soul was spirit, and therefore immortal; I, the contrary. When we neared the Chamber of Commerce, the place of debate, we met people going away, the hall being already packed to its utmost capacity, and many standing up. Mr. B. tried from the very outset to get the feelings of the audience aroused against me; and when I spoke, I was several times interrupted. In his second speech he made light of the passages I had quoted, representing them as my own words, so when I answered again, I tried to make the statement that not I had said so, but the Bible. But I was only able to get my sentence half finished, for I was stopped by an immense uproar, and a hundred voices cried out: “You're a liar.” For a while it seemed almost impossible to quell the uproar; but finally Prof. Holzinger succeeded in restoring order, and I went on, unmolested. Our opponents having failed in their attempt to break me down, they tried to hinder the rendering of a decision, by claiming that Prof. H. had been previously sounded. Then they went still farther, by inserting in the Winona daily Herald of Jan. 30 quite an article, full of misrepresentations. To this Prof. H. replied in the next number as follows:— There was no verbal or written agreement ever made, whether the seventh judge could or could not be first asked whether he would serve. As a proof: Rev. Bush's judges waited upon Mr. J. Leicht, and asked him to act as the seventh judge. They now object to me because these parties spoke to me about it. They simply asked me whether I would serve, and did not sound me. I never stated to anybody how I stood on this question until yesterday, when I told Mr. Conradi's judges that I did not agree with them, but that Mr. Conradi had treated the matter in a most generous way, keeping his pledge to discuss the matter in a fair way, which Mr. Bush did not do. Mr. C. had the best of the argument by all odds. I am capable of distinguishing between my prejudice and an argument. The audience did not treat Mr. C. fairly at all. The next evening after the debate I spoke in our church to a crowded house, on the Christian's hope; and letters since received show that the word spoken was not in vain. A Methodist writes that since he heard the debate and the sermon, he has a different opinion of the Adventists. He states that the Lutheran pastor and also the Methodist minister spoke on the same subject the week following, but that, especially among the Methodists, it has only influenced the people to show more decidedly on which side they stand. One of our brethren writes that the interest to hear is greater than ever before, and that two have since begun to obey. While I am no lover of debates, and this has been really my first, yet I feel grateful to God for the results gained, and I hope that still others may by it be led to see the light of present truth.