BY ELD E. R. JONES.
(Healdsburg, Cal.)
The “People’s History of America,” in speaking of the effect of the laws of the colony of Massachusetts, in which the chief end of the civil law was to serve and sustain the church, after stating that all dissenters and unbelievers were disfranchised, further states on page 244:—
Though dissenters from the colonial church were thus deprived of political privileges, it does not appear that they were subject to any other inconvenience, except where their tenets were considered as blasphemous, or when they endeavored by the propagation of them to detach others from the Established Church, or by the practical realization of them to disturb the public peace. The exclusion from political privileges to which they were subject seems not at first to have given them any annoyance; but to have been felt to be the necessary consequence of that intertexture of church and commonwealth in which the main end of political institutions was the preservation of the church estate, and the chief value of political privileges considered to arise from their subservience to this end.
That is to say, If any persons under such a government did not believe or teach or practice any other faith than that established by law, they were tolerated; that is, they were graciously permitted by the forbearance of a pious and law-abiding people to stay in that country, and nothing more. But should they complain of the law or of the doctrines, they were immediately considered offenders, and dealt with accordingly.
The same history, p. 245, says of Roger Williams, that he held and taught that “the magistrate had no right to restrain or direct the consciences of men; and that anything short of unlimited toleration of all religions was detestable persecution.” For such seditious sentiments he was driven out of the colony.
In a National Reform convention held in New York in 1873, Rev. Jonathan Edwards, D. D., in a speech on the much-coveted “State and religion,” said of the atheist, deist, the Jew and the seventh-day observer: “These all are, for the occasion, and so far as our amendment is concerned, one class. They use the same arguments and the same tactics against us. They must be counted together.” What he says of any one of them therefore applies equally to all. He significantly asks, “What are the rights of the atheist? I would tolerate him as I would tolerate a poor lunatic. . . I would tolerate him as I would a conspirator.” The lunatic would not be sent to an asylum if he was very quiet, and said nothing,—“does not rave.” The conspirator would be closely watched, and for the first act or word that suspicion could magnify or distort into an evil design, he would be severely punished. It is natural and easy for those who hold any religious faith or sentiment supported and enforced by civil law, to think any other faith both blasphemous and dangerous, and the practice of it rebellion, and the teaching conspiracy. In the language of our zealous National Reformers, we might ask, What are the rights of such persons? Would they be tolerated? The answer is not doubtful. They would not be tolerated; they would be imprisoned or exiled.
Let those who clamor for a national religion say what they will; let them disguise it as they may; the history of many nations with strong hand tears off the mask, and reveals the unsightly fact that religious legislation invariably results in intolerance and persecution.