BY ELD. D. E. LINDSEY.
(Baltimore, Md.)
Having for years read with interest the Christian Statesman, and attended one of the conventions of National Reformers, and having watched the developments of the Sunday-law party, I have felt impelled as a citizen and a Christian, to examine carefully the arguments against the Amendment to the Constitution, the Blair Sunday-rest Bill, and the National School Law. Knowing that Rome is no friend to religious or civil liberty, and understanding her declared principles not to owe allegiance to any power above the pope, and knowing her hatred for the public school system, I am amazed at the effrontery and boldness of the pseudo Protestants who are courting Rome as they are in our beloved nation. When Protestants are so blinded to their own best interests, and to the privileges righteously guaranteed to us under the Constitution, as to seek the favor of the papacy, the foe of all free Constitutions, it is time for every freeman to raise his voice, and protest against Protestantism.
Have I charged Catholicism with too much, in saying she is the foe of all free Constitutions? Let the following bear witness. Every faithful Catholic is convinced that the primacy rests on divine appointment. With the doctrine of papal infallibility, and that of the church’s right to control in temporal power, it is not strange that they claim, as Schrader says, “It is not only minds that are under the power of ‘the church.’” And his fellow Jesuit, Schneeman, says, “As the church has an external jurisdiction, she can impose temporal punishments, and not only deprive the guilty of spiritual privileges.” I find in harmony with this, the following utterance from the “Civiltà:” “It is necessary that the church should visit her opponents with fines, fasts, imprisonments, and scourging, because, without this external power the church could not last to the end of the world.”
Go back to the time of the Syllabus, prior to the declaration of the council of 1870 which declared the pope infallible, and we find in Prop. 77 to 79 these statements: “It is a wicked error to admit Protestants to equal political rights with Catholics, or to allow Protestant immigrants the free use of their worship; on the contrary, to suppress them is a sacred duty, when it has become possible, as the Jesuit Fathers and their adherents teach.” Schneeman says (“Ut supra,” p. 30): “The church will of course act with the greatest prudence in the use of her temporal and physical power, according to altered circumstances, and will not, therefore at present, adopt her medieval policy.” Before calling attention to the proofs of Rome’s opposition to all free governments, let me quote from Cardinal Gibbons, of Baltimore, Md., in his letter to Pope Leo XIII.; then quote from Kettler, Bishop of Mayence, to show what should prompt the Cardinal to address “His Holiness,” and desire the restoration of temporal supremacy, the loss of which he so sorely laments. The letter referred to, from the Cardinal, is published in full in the Church News (Catholic):—
We are well aware that you have not only fallen into the hands of the ungodly, but that you are completely in their power, and under their domination, thus making your daily life one of ignominy, of grief, and oppression. The mission of the church demands liberty: this liberty is, above all, required by the head of the church in administering his holy office. The body is powerless when separated from the head. For the protection of the freedom of our supreme ruler, we are continually ready to make the greatest sacrifice; for this liberty is the main part of the heavenly inheritance, brought down upon the earth by the Lord himself, and left to us, his sons. It will, therefore, not appear strange to any one that we hold this liberty, as becomes us, in higher esteem than anything else, as valuable, indeed, as life itself.
The close observer will readily see in this an acknowledged allegiance to the pope, above all demands or obligations of our free Constitution. The bishop referred to, expresses himself in “Freiheit, Autorität, und Kirche,” Mainz, 1862.p. 260 Endeavoring to show the moderation, tolerance, and self-restraint of the Catholic Church in its relations with the State and the separate churches, he insists that the church so thoroughly respects freedom of conscience as to repudiate all outward coercion of those beyond her pale, as immoral and utterly unlawful; that nothing is further from her mind, than to employ any physical force against those who, as being baptized, are her members; that she must leave it entirely to their own free determination, whether they will accept her faith; and that it is absurd for Protestants to suppose that they have any need to fear a forcible conversion, etc.
How much this sounds like the words of certain National Reformers, as they seek to allay the fears of those who would be oppressed by the laws sought for by them; but the Syllabus, and Schrader, its commentator, informed the bishop that he had fallen into that forbidden liberalism, which is, according to the Roman view, one of the greatest errors of the day; and that it was by special indulgence of Rome that his book was not put on the index. Here we again behold a similarity between Rome and the National Reformers.
A bishop speaks amid universal applause, and the pope condemns his doctrine, and the people who applaud the bishop with profounder homage applaud the encyclical. So, when a National Reformer would calm our fears by uttering such liberal sentiments, the leaders in the anti-Christian movement call a halt, and say, “If these few who are opposed to our work cannot obey and endure, let them be driven to some lone island or dark cavern, and there set up a kingdom.”
They go further still, and cry, “Give us law, and we will soon stop their work; for we would tolerate a thief before we would them.” The same spirit is seen in all the utterances of National Reformers, that has made the papacy the dreaded power that it is; and will result in the image to the papal beast. We have no more reason to hope for any quarter from the National Reformers, however flattering their promises, than had the martyrs during the Dark Ages. If they would recant, they should be saved, when to recant was only to be destroyed, lest they again embrace the pestilential doctrines of the Protestants.
The Syllabus closes with the following:—
“They are in damnable error who regard the reconciliation of the pope with modern civilization as possible or desirable.”—Prop. 80.
Our Constitution and the constitutions of Europe (except Russia and the Roman States) are the outgrowth of this “modern civilization.” In the words of a Catholic writer, who was opposed to declaring the pope infallible, “Freedom of religious profession, worship, and teaching; freedom of political rights and duties before the law: these, with the people’s right of taxing themselves, and taking a part in legislation and municipal self-government are the dominant principles and ideas which interpenetrate all existing constitutions; and they are so closely connected, and so sustain each other, that where some of them are conceded, the rest inevitably follow. The modern civil constitutions, and the efforts for self-government, and the limitations of arbitrary royal power, are in the strongest contradiction to ultramontanism.” For this reason, every genuine ultramontane has a most profound hatred of free institutions and the whole constitutional system. In Vol. IV. p. 265, seq., 1868, of “Civiltà,” we find the following utterance: “Christian States have ceased to exist. Human society has again become heathen, and it is like an earthly body with no breath from heaven.” Speaking of universities which oppose the papacy, it says: “The universities are not only dry, but stinking, bones: and the political power, parliaments, voting urns, marriages, are dry bones.”
You say this is translated, and was spoken to the European countries and universities. Do you suppose that the Jesuits at Georgetown College, at Washington, D. C., have any more love for our American institutions or universities? And yet we see a President of the United States walking with a cardinal to do honor to the Jesuit College at its centennial anniversary. Shade of Protestantism, where art thou? And do we not know that when the National Reformers are once in power, they will declare our colleges “stinking bones?” Are they not already offensive to them? And is not a man who prays for a breath of the Puritan air, as easily disturbed in his Sunday rest as a Romanist? And will he not manifest the same “dragon spirit”?
The English Magna Charta was visited with the severest anger of Pope Innocent III. He saw therein a contempt for the apostolic see. A far feebler successor of Innocent has stigmatized the Austrian Constitution as an “unspeakable abomination” (infanda sane). How did Rome regard the French constitutions? In 1824, Leo XII. addressed a letter to Louis XVIII. pointing out the baseness of the French Constitution, and pressed him to expunge from the charter those articles which savored of liberalism.
Soon after the establishment of the religious Constitution in 1832, Gregory XVI. issued his famous encyclical, since used by Pius IX., which pronounces freedom of conscience an insane folly, and freedom of the press a pestiferous error, which cannot be sufficiently detested. In the United States, Catholics cannot form a political party. Why not?—Because in order to do so, they would have to make an open avowal of their principles, and a declaration of their dogmas, to which the masses would not yet assent. The papacy bides her time, and would lull every lover of our free Constitution into carnal security, while she scatters her horde of Jesuits far and near among us; enters all the walks of life, all branches of business, and many households as domestics, there to strengthen herself with the life blood of him that nourishes her.
All the world must wonder after the beast. Not all the professed allegiance of the Catholic laity of this country, or the quieting words of the priest, or the public recognition of the bound copy of our Constitution, received by Pope Leo XIII. at his Jubilee, will prevent the papacy from grasping the reins of government at the opportune moment, to thus more readily and successfully propagate her own faith. The saddest feature in this connection will be that Protestantism, robbed of her virtue and degraded, will seek alliance with Rome, and thus bring about the dread crisis.
(Concluded next week.)