Perhaps a larger number of theories have been built upon Rev. 20:4, than upon any other one text of Scripture. Under the general designation of “Age to Come,” it seems to be considered a convenient place for the development of every kind of people, and every kind of work, and every kind of condition, and every kind of relation and combination, which it would seem possible for the ingenuity of men to devise.
These theories are elaborated in a great variety of ways, and the doctrines passing under the general designation of “Age-to-Come Views” are about as numerous as the individuals holding them. Into remarks upon these individual theories, it is not our purpose here to enter; but however these views may differ in external architecture, there are certain general principles underlying them all; and if these are found to be incorrect, then each and every so-called age-to-come theory, of whatever variety, name, or nature, is left without a foundation, and wrecked beyond repair.
The first and essential condition of every view which supposes a gospel work beyond this dispensation is, that there is to be probation for the human family after the second coming of Christ. There can certainly be no work of grace and recovery from sin in a future age, unless opportunity for repentance is given, and mercy is offered. But if there are to be no more offers of mercy after Christ comes, as we have scriptures which clearly prove, then every such theory rests upon a false view of the Scriptures, and is to be at once discarded.
Another feature common to all these views of the future is that there is a distinction made between the church and Israel, and that there are some promises yet to be fulfilled to the latter which must come in during the thousand years. But if the Scriptures show, as we think they do, that no distinction is recognized in Christ between Israel and the church or the elect, then again all such schemes as involve a special work for, or by, any of these distinctive classes, falls to the ground.
1. There will be no probation for men after Christ comes. Christ does not come in any secret, silent invisible, manner to take his people to himself. It is when he “appears,” that the saints are gathered to him. Heb. 9:28. When he appears, every eye shall see him. Rev. 1:7. The wicked see him, and wail because of him. Matt. 24:30. It is at this time that the “elect” are gathered. Verse 31. Those here called the “elect” are Christians who are loving, and waiting for, the appearing of Christ (2 Tim. 4:8), and include also the righteous dead, who are raised at that time. 1 Thess. 4:16. It is at this time that the living righteous are first taken to be with Christ. Verse 17. How any one, in view of such texts as these, can imagine that Christ comes for his people secretly, invisibly, and silently, is to us a mystery.
This redemption of the saints will be visible to the world; for as they behold Christ, so will they also behold his people. Col. 3:4. “When he who is our life shall appear, then shall ye also appear with him in glory.” And as the wicked will finally behold the righteous redeemed in the kingdom of God (Luke 13:28), why not behold them as they begin to enter upon their blessed reward?
Just before Christ appears, the line will be drawn upon all the living, assigning every case to redemption or destruction. Rev. 22:11, 12. And when Christ actually appears, the same decision is also made with reference to the dead; and then the two classes, the righteous and the wicked, embracing the whole human family, are forever separated. Matt. 25:31-33. Of those on the right hand, it is said that they are invited to inherit the kingdom. But of those on the left hand, we nowhere read that they have another chance, and that many of them are converted, and inherit the kingdom with the righteous; but they are told, “Depart from me, ye cursed;” and they have their portion in the “fire prepared for the Devil and his angels.”
The same great truth is taught in the Saviour’s parable of the wheat and tares. Matt. 13. Thus, the field is the world, and the tares are the wicked. These tares began to be sowed as soon as sinners began to be developed. The wheat and tares were to grow together till the harvest, which is the end of the world. Those who have gone into their graves sinners, are tares as verily as the living wicked when Christ appears, and the parable includes them also. At the harvest, the end of the world, the wheat is gathered into the garner. But we nowhere read of the tares that any of them are ever changed over into wheat, and saved in the garner also; but their portion is to be consumed in a furnace of fire.
These scriptures prove conclusively that there can be no probation after the coming of Christ. And any scheme, therefore, which has the gospel extended into the future age, and a work of grace then accomplished in the conversion and salvation of sinners, is a human invention, and contrary to the Scriptures.
2. This point being established, we are aware that nothing need be said upon the second proposition, that no such distinctions are recognized in the Scriptures as are essential to every extant theory of the age to come. We might reasonably say of this, as the judge said to the attorney who proposed to give three reasons why a certain witness was not present. “My first reason, your honor,” said the attorney, “is that the witness is dead. My second is”—“Hold,” said the judge, “you needn’t say any more; your first reason is all-sufficient.”
So we might say that the first of the foregoing propositions is all-sufficient, and forever settles the question. Nevertheless, we will offer a few words upon the second.
At first the world was one family under Adam. After the flood, Noah, became the head of the race, which, on the confusion of tongues, was broken up into different nations. All these having apostatized, God chose Abraham, and made his family (afterwards developed into twelve tribes) the depositaries of his law, and the custodians of his truth and worship in the earth. Ten of these tribes having apostatized, God cast them off, rooted them up, put them out of his sight, to be no more forever accounted of in any of his future purposes. 2 Kings 17:18, 20, 23. After the 70 years’ captivity of Judah, some of all Israel returned with them to Jerusalem, so that all there were of the ten tribes recognized of God, were then considered as dwelling in Judea. All the twelve tribes were there represented. Ex. 1:5; 6:16, 17; Acts 26:7. All speculations, therefore, about ten lost tribes being still preserved, which are to come hereafter to glory and dominion in virtue of their genealogy, are simply phantoms of the imagination.
These twelve tribes of Israel are likened by Paul to the branches of an olive tree. Rejecting Christ, these branches were broken off. This brought the literal seed to the end of any special dealings on the part of God with them as such. The Gentiles were grafted in, and the olive tree was perpetuated by these new branches, and the line of Israel was continued by these Gentile accessions; and people were henceforth to be reckoned as Israel, not because they were by nature connected with Abraham, but because they were spiritually connected with Christ. Rom. 11:19, 23; 9:7, 8; 2:28, 29. Eph. 2:12–22; Gal. 3:29.
In the same olive tree are involved all the gracious promises and purposes of God, covering all the future. The Gentiles come into the line of these promises by being grafted into this tree, or in other words, joining through Christ, the commonwealth of Israel, and thus becoming Abraham’s seed. In Gal. 3, Paul discourses in regard to the promise to Abraham, which includes the sum total of his gracious purposes for the world, in all the ages of the future, and declares that these are to be obtained only through Christ. He says: “For as many of you as have been baptized into Christ, have put on Christ. There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither bond nor free; there is neither male nor female; for ye are all one in Christ Jesus.” Gal. 3:27, 28. That is, so far as all the blessings and promises of the future are concerned, nothing depends on whether you are a Jew or a Greek, or whether you are bond or free, or whether you are male or female. All distinctions of this kind, so far as the promises are concerned, are lost in Christ. If you are Christ’s, you share in the promises; if not, not. And whether we are Christ’s or not is determined by our course in the present state, and not in the future.
In the face of such testimony as this, why contend for national distinctions in the future state, and base special promises and positions of pre-eminence upon such distinctions?
But it may be asked how certain prophecies found in the Old Testament are to be disposed of on this view. The prophecies to which reference is made, were written from 800 to 400 years before Christ; and we may be sure they do not contradict the plain statements quoted above from the New Testament. Without specifying any particular passages, it will be sufficient to state that all the principal prophecies of this kind, relating to Israel, etc., may be classified under these three heads: 1. Those that were fulfilled by the return of the Jews from their captivity; 2. Those that relate to the triumphs of the gospel and the future kingdom of Christ; 3. Those which were conditional, and, the conditions not having been complied with, are not to be fulfilled.
While there may be some obscure prophecies the application of which is not at once apparent, yet if we take out all which clearly come under one of the foregoing divisions, very little will be left upon which to base the enormous claims set up for a future age of probation. And certainly the great guide-posts erected for us in the unequivocal testimony of the New Testament Scriptures, should not be departed from nor ignored. According to these, we must adhere to three great facts: 1. The final separation between the righteous and the wicked of the whole human family takes place at the second coming of Christ; 2. There is no further probation for men, after Christ takes his position as King; 3. In the future all distinctions are lost in Christ, and all the saved are reckoned as Israel, inhabiting a city on whose gates are the names of the twelve tribes of the children of Israel, and on whose foundation stones are the names of the twelve apostles of the Lamb. Rev. 21:10-14, 24.