The most prominent characteristic of infidel philosophy is its supreme self-confidence. Armed with the mighty weapon of human intelligence, there are few mysteries in the universe with which it will not undertake to grapple, especially if it sees any occasion for disproving the existence of the supernatural. It is bound not to admit the existence of any higher Intelligence than itself, and therefore must needs eliminate the element of the mysterious from all phenomena pointing in this direction. One of its latest attempts in this line is an explanation of the memorable Dark Day of May 19, 1780, showing it to have been nothing more than the result of a little chance acting in unison with some of the well-known laws of nature. This “explanation” appears in the Boston Investigator of Jan. 30. The writer opens up the subject thus:—
Mr. EDITOR: Remarkable as to extent, duration, and intensity, yet clearly within the domain of natural physics, ranks the mysterious Dark Day of May 19, 1780.
Passing over the writer’s statement of the characteristics of the occurrence, which are too well known to our readers to need repeating, we quote what is said as to the extent of the phenomenon and its duration:—
It was on Friday, and the beginning of this remarkable gloom was between the hours of ten and eleven in the forenoon. Its continuation was past the middle of the following night, with somewhat varying features in different localities. The wind came generally from the southwest, and the darkness seemed to come with it from that direction. Soon the gloom became too intense to see common print distinctly, and household duties had mainly to be performed with lighted candles. The obscuration extended all along the New England coast; westward as far as Albany (N. Y.); southward along the coast of Maryland, South Carolina, and Georgia; and northward as far as any American settlement extended. How far beyond these boundaries this phenomenon was manifest, will never be known, but in all likelihood, as will appear further on in the explanation of this mystery, a large part of the area of the present United States may have been involved.
A phenomenon so wide-spread in its manifestation and so awe-inspiring in its features, ought, it would seem, to have awakened a spirit of investigation which would have led to the speedy discovery of the causes which produced it, were those causes merely such as occur in the common processes of nature. To account for the absence of any such discovery, the writer is obliged to suppose that “the ‘scientists’ of the time, if there were any, were under too much religious domination to be either analytical or logical; or were in realms too remote to adjust to home-happenings—had focussed their gaze too far away—as the incubating graduate is sometimes more conversant with the mysteries of the ‘Milky Way’ than with the township boundaries of his county.” He also assumes that there existed at the time a dense ignorance of “the great physical interior of this great country,” the exact place where the chief cause of the phenomenon, as he assigns it, originated. Both these suppositions, and especially the latter, require a considerable amount of proof (which is not forthcoming) to make them tenable.
Having given a brief summary of the meteorological observations made shortly before and during the prevalence of the darkness, and having noticed a few of the untenable theories by which others have sought to explain it, he proceeds to assign the true cause, by which, as he says, this phenomenon is “found to yield readily to solution,” the opinions of Herschel, the “Advents,” and others to the contrary notwithstanding. A brief statement of the conditions of the problem is first given, as follows:—
The atmosphere was heavily charged with a large quantity of vapor floating or resting near the surface of the earth. This vapor was a palpable, visible, material substance, discernible to the sight, sensible to feeling, perceptible to the taste, and recognizable to the smell. These are four important witnesses, whose testimony is worthy of profound consideration. There was a foreign ingredient in the atmosphere, and this, to exhibit any of the characteristics noticed, . . could only come from a limited field of sources.
This “foreign ingredient,” the writer further says, “was not any of the forms of the aqueous, as any of these would condense and precipitate long before attaining any such volume of opacity.” Then what was it? Ans.—An immense volume of smoke and soot from a vast conflagration raging somewhere in the then unknown interior of the American continent. We quote again:—
On the occasion under consideration, there was no one to report the vast conflagrations that raged over perhaps many hundreds of square miles of dry leaves or dry grass, perhaps fanned by brisk gales, and the vapor and sooty substance carried high up by ascending air-currents, to be loaded on favoring breezes to be wafted over the land of the Pilgrims, there to meet, as it were, an atmospheric barrier, and gather volume and thicken as already indicated. This condition would continue just so long as the gravity and pressure of resisting currents remained in statu quo. So soon as this dam gave way, the accumulated substance would move on and disperse.
This, then, is all there was to it; and the memorable and mysterious Dark Day, which has created such a profound impression from that time to the present; which has been universally associated with a divine agency; which many have even regarded as a fulfillment of the prophetic word, is relegated from the realm of the supernatural to that of occurrences whose variation in character from the commonplace is due solely to the intervention of chance. The prophetic statement that “in those days, after that tribulation, the sun shall be darkened, and the moon shall not give her light” (Mark 13: 24) has only the smoke of an immense burning forest or prairie, combined with favorable atmospheric conditions, for its fulfillment. So infidel philosophy invites us to believe.
But unfortunately for this theory, it is out of harmony with facts. Exploration and settlement to the southwest of New England had long preceded the advent of the Dark Day, as a reference to almost any American history will show. We quote from Johnson’s Cyclopedia in reference to the early settlement of Missouri and Illinois, territory as far removed from New England in the line of this alleged conflagration as could well be supposed to have been the scene of its occurrence. In Vol. IV., p. 195, is this reference to Illinois:—
The first white settlements in this State were made by the French from Canada, and were the result of the enterprise of the great explorer, the Sieur de la Salle. He came from Canada in 1679 to the Illinois River, which he named from an Indian tribe which he called Illini, living on its banks. In 1682 he came again with a colony of Canadians and made settlements at Kaskaskia, Cahokia, etc. These settlements increased, and the Jesuit missionaries visited the region early in the eighteenth century. . . In 1763 the English Government, by the conquest of Canada, succeeded to the dominion over all this region.
From Vol. V., p. 481, we quote in reference to Missouri:—
The present State of Missouri was known as Upper Louisiana. Under this name its lead mines began to be known as early as 1720, and settlements were made not long after, at St. Louis, Cape Girardeau, and (probably about 1755) at St. Genevieve. In 1763 it was ceded to Spain with the rest of the Louisiana or Mississippi country, while all east of the river came into possession of the English in 1775. St. Louis had attained some reputation as a fur-depot and trading-station, and had about 800 inhabitants, and St. Genevieve about half as many. New Madrid had been founded some time before.
It needs no argument, indeed, to show that at the time of these settlements, there must have been hunters, trappers, and other adventurers scattered all through this territory, to say nothing of the Indian tribes which had long made the region their home; and the same could not have been less true of any portion of country less remote from the frontiers of civilization. The supposition, therefore, that “on the occasion under consideration there was no one to report the vast conflagrations that raged over perhaps many hundreds of square miles” somewhere to the southwest of New England, in the light of a few historical facts, loses at once all traces of plausibility. A conflagration of such magnitude as would have been required to darken the Atlantic coast from Maine to South Carolina, besides obscuring an unknown extent of country inland, could not have escaped observation by a person anywhere in its vicinity; and the fact that no report has ever been made of such an occurrence, either in the traditions of the early settlers or of the native tribes, is conclusive evidence that nothing of the kind took place.
But this theory of accounting for the Dark Day, though perhaps new to the readers of the Investigator, has been long known to investigative science, and by it thoroughly considered and disposed of. We quote again from the foregoing cyclopedia (Vol. II., pp. 851, 852) an extract from an article on the subject of the Dark Day, by Mr. F. A. P. Barnard. Speaking of dark days in general, he says:—
The several hypotheses which have been suggested in explanation of this subject, and which seem to exhaust the limited list of possibilities, are as follows: (1) The smoke of vast burning forests, loading the atmosphere, and shutting out the light of the sun.
Then follow other hypotheses which it is not the purpose of this article to consider. Coming to thep. 137 separate consideration of each, the writer continues:—
The first of these hypotheses is disposed of by Dr. [Noah] Webster very summarily, by presenting two conclusive considerations, which are: (1.) that there has been no evidence of the occurrence of great forest conflagrations immediately before these days of darkness or simultaneously with them; and (2.) that if such conflagrations had existed, the cause is not adequate to the observed effect. “Had the woods,” he remarks, “from the 40th to the 50th parallel of latitude been consumed in a day, the smoke would have been insufficient to produce the darkness of the 19th of May, 1780.” And as a further confirmation of this conclusion, he adds that the color of smoke is very different from that of the obscuring stratum on the day referred to.
Further evidence on the subject is unnecessary. To the minds of the party represented by the Investigator, this solution of the phenomenon of the Dark Day may be very satisfactory; but while the philosophy of which that journal is the expositor, turns from this attempt to its regular and ever-progressive job of “upsetting Moses,” the memorable occurrence of May 19, 1780, will remain undivested, so far as this “solution” is concerned, of that mystery which has made it, in the minds of most Americans, an occasion of awe and wonder, and vividly suggestive in its characteristics, of a direct exercise of supernatural power.
L. A. S.