Why Exemption Clauses Do Not Redeem Sunday Laws
Why, it is asked, do you object to an exemption clause in a Sunday law?—We don’t. The more exemption the better; and better still, if it were all exemption. And if a Sunday law is to be passed, we sincerely hope it may contain an exemption clause for observers of the seventh day; and we shall avail ourselves of whatever may be conceded thereby, and will give all due credit to the good intentions which may have prompted it. At the same time, such a clause would not redeem the law, which is wrong in principle; nor would it secure our support of the law; for we have regard to the rights of others, as well as our own. It would be ignominious selfishness in us to say to the Government, If you only won’t oppress us, we will join in and help you oppress others. The Government should oppress no one; and there are multitudes who pay no regard to the seventh day, who yet do not wish to keep the first day, and for whom a law compelling them to do so would be oppression. While no one should be restricted in his religious practices—due regard being had, of course, to the rights of others—no one should be compelled by law to such practices. Therefore, while we would not in a spirit of defiance repel an exemption clause, we are opposed to the law just the same, exemption or no exemption.